Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Court Decisions Legislation Analyze in Legislator
1-08-11479/9 AI generated

1-08-11479/9 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Põlvas

Case Number 1-08-11479/9
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia · Case Law (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

                       !" #!$%&'           ()*+ ,+        '(&'(      +- +  ../+  (  0##&"1,"+  2&&( %     +- +   + +/3 4##5 ( + *++"+ /-+5 ()((& 6 (( + ((&5...

Legislator headnote

Placeholder

Keywords

Placeholder

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

      

             

  !" #!$%&'  

        ()*+ ,+        '(&'(  

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

#"    - :7 &*  + -"+& ( +/ ../+  (   &+ (&5 ++  &* +- + 5&,/(  0 4104&" #5%+"( )%+ )+ (&( (&&( 5(!!#<!  (&& !## :+ $%&' )--  %&&( ( '&&  -(:+ ) (( #! )& &&+1*( % (+ &-/ +)( %+/ :(& @&+*5 ("+ ((+)+ ),"+" - 99999951+)+ ("-+-"++& (/ (>?0#&"-%(((+)+ ( ! ((% (+ , +&(   (-) &&:& &&+ '+)+ ( (" (&&(" (-/'+/  1& +/1%(-/(+/!

   4>?  ++& %--( (+))+ (1 (&&(,+" ---&((+/ (('+"  ( -"/1,")+ (/%(-/+/3  ---! !   -/.& (/5(!!#<!(&&:+ %++    ! !1+- + +"  $%&')&(77&(!%+/1+ ! + 5 1+%'&&+ ! !-+-"()+  '++) ("+--+)''7711,+ )")!',-/(/)+-( ((&, .&( -+-" ((1,(& %++ ((& ',&1' :/! :%("1,1(& +' ( ++ ('+" /!,&1 -,"+5 (  ")+-( :():&-( (' &+ .+! ++& %--( ( ,+"  +  (&"&.&+)1&++" &((&/!! + + %-/( (&&+++  =)BC  --+ 1 ! !    -  .& (/5 ( !!#<!  (&&  :+ +)  $%&')& &++& %--(  ! + + :& 1+/ %+/"!  + ( +   1+ %'&-+-"()"&+!!!--('+ ',+ ()5! +    1+' (5 +"+ :+//  1 :../+  &+/(   ((& +/5 1  %++  '+ ' :/! :%("1,1(& +():(' &(& +'+" /! ())((&( &+")+-(:():&-((''(&1(&)&-/!++   ((&&+)BC  --+ 1!D! - .& (/5(!!#<! %++ :&+ (+)(-+- ) -(:+ ((& &('&( .-/) &(! :(& -,"+5 ( %+/ :(& @&+* &+  (" ((& ' '+  -/ 1+' ( 1 %+-/ '  :/!:():&-(")+-(('&+.+5+/'(&1(&!(''%+ .1(-(/ .&"&+*+ ()+ ( ,+" !   '++*+-/ + ++/  (+ -,+-/5 (  &+/ (--( () &(1%/)+ +"& (+)(/C  ../+ ' +- + +   -/ .& (/5 ( !!#<!  (&&  :+ 1+ $%&')--  %+/5)+&&( &+/ ! !1!!!++ (  &+)B!  ((&5(--(&"1' '+5,+ )+-"+). 5)+&&(1," (& &,   ' .&" ((:&(5 -+-"     1+' (5 +"+ :../+  (/ &+"((&+/5'1  +/+1:+/+-+-"'( ,+!:%)+ (& ' :/ +/(+ (/ '++*+1/'+" /C  .-/) '& :&& A/(">&#?5(!!#<!(&&!= 1& & + .-/)  '&  $%&' )--  %&&( ( '&&  -(:+ ) (( #! +&)((+&5   %+/ :(& @&+*5 ("+ +),"+" 9999995&+ %+-/ (&"(+&)"5+'& ("((& -(:+ - ((& ',&1' :/!& (,+" A+ ((++.&"&+*+ ()+ (1,&1(/>4?(--( :+-()+ C  &++& %--( (    (()+" >& 4?5( !!#<!  (&& !##1& $%&' )--  %&&( ( '&&  -(:+) (( #! +&)((+&   %+/

:(& @&+*5 ("+ +),"+" 9999995 1 ! +  (*%+"( %+/++ ( 1 ',( ( %+/"() (%1+' (-+-" %++ '  -/1((&',&1'  :/-+-" (&&(&() (- +/'+" / ! !1!!C  &++& '(-/+.&(' (:&&>&?5(!!#<!' + %+/

:(& @&+*5 ("+ +),"+" 9999995 '& (& ) &" 5 (  :():&-(")+-(('&+.+C   &+ ( :(/+')  >& ###?5 ( ! !  ( +-(   -+))(&.&+ &.&+( ):( +-)/5)+ - //7)*+',"+'&&+)(&5'%+)&+5(!!#<! &++& %--( (,+" 5-+-")+ (+&((&&+1'&+ (&&:%1 * :+1&+ (('+ (1  ((  ("(-)+/C

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

   <>? ((" '%+  ../+ '& !!#<!  && 1* :++ '& %+/"() + 1 (/)+ + -/ (( (+ -/+ ! ++&  +&)-()+ (& ',(-/    ++  1 :../+   / -&&+ (&&(1+' (.&(! ../+ '5---1--+ 1(.& ("-+-" .-/) '& :&&+"- ' /5(!!#<!&++&):,+( (:+ (&+-(1((+'! (+&( .-/)  '& :&&+  ),"+/ -/)(+/ (( &' (+ -/+ ! ++& %--(  +)  (&+ (&:+&1&"1 '+ !../+ '.& ( (&&&( +/' (+ %+-/! ((" &+/ &++& %--( ( 1& 1   +&) +5 (( 1 &++& &/ (/ -+-" &++& +(/ ',+(1(( (+ -/(! )&+  1 '&+ (  -+-" ((%  .&/-  &(* :+//  1&5 (  ("((&&(+/*&+)%-+-"+/(1&+ ++'(!  '( /(  %++ ((&-('+/  1& +/5 &(+*  5 ( !!#<!  (&&  :+ $%&')& -(:+)((#!+&)((+& ../+ ':&'&+/ %+/++ 6&+"+ )B6'  () %+/"() (&(-+-"'(  (+ +0 #4 ,( /-%/(+/5 )+ %:&(& &"(/&+ ( %+/++ ('&+.&"&+*+ ()+ (:%1 ( ! -&++& %--( (1," (&&+ %+/")+-(:():&-(('.+5+/('+(+ &('/(&//(" (&&(.1(-()+ (:%1 1 ( ((&',&1 %+/"+/-+-" (/ (+ &( '%+)&+  :(" (-) (5 ++  (+ &( ',&+ /5 (  .&"&+*+ ()+ ( :%1  :+ ('+.1(-()+-(! )+-&++& ( :(()*+ (( & +--+-/5((''%+ .1(-(/ (--(.&"&+*+ ()+ ( )+ -+-"('+.1(-()+ (:%1 (&(  -/+-/& ( (&&('& (1+)+ ("! - ('+ .1(-()+  .&"&+*+ ()+ ( ,+"  * :+// :(" +-& &( (  -+-" (&&((+)+ (:%1 (+&('%+)&+(-)-&&+/(" &/ ',, (&' /1 ((%.&"&+*+ ()+ ( )+ (("(&+:%1 +-/& (5 (&&(:, &(+*  5(&++& %--( (&":%1 (  -% (-/%'&/)& 5)+/&(* %&"(-// 0&"4& (& ../+ '  ! ((" &(* &"(/ &++& %--( ( :%1 (  (-+&+-( '+"   ('+ ) .1(-()+-(5)+&&("1,1(&  ../+ '-&&+1+' (.&(1 %++ '  :/!  '( /(  1&5(' /(+&( ../+ '("*1(++' ( )%( 5 ++ &(* %+"( )%+  0##&"1,"++(%(-/) (% 0&": & (&!  ,/(  (&&( 5(:7+:&(+&( ../+  )/(/1")  ../+ '&( + (%+" (5(+&(&'%+)&+' / ../+ ',+)+ (  0#4!&%+(  ,( / +( -- (+/ ( (  (&&("5 (  1+  5 )+&&(  %++  ''77" -%(( (&+--+)---> !0<:=-%/((+)+ ( ?51'++)-( + &++& %--( (,+"  (('+"  (!   0&" (&.'+*%+"( )%+ '  (&)(-(& &/++! - )%+ +  ../+ '%+"( &&(( +/ ../+  ( ,+(&+&5 ++ &(*1, %+ )(-(& &/ >> &+ ( :(++ + &/ 6 #= -+ >& #4?5 ),,/ + 1&() /++"+%+" *+ 6#-+>&=<?5&++& (-+&+ (( :(++ +&/6 # -+ >& <?5 + 1&( +)+-&+)+ )(1&+/(  :+ ("()+ ( &/ 

   >? <#54-+>&?1 ( )+ (&/6<5=-+>&<??5 !<45 -+++"+-/!    (("()+ (&1+-/  '((& 0 4<C04&" #-+-"0/( 46 4#14!     ()*+ ,+  -+