Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-10-39871/5 AI generated

2-10-39871/5 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus

Case Number 2-10-39871/5
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

   

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-10-39871/5 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus:    

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

   

        !"#$%&'"  

(#$ )$!   ))*#''                  +!&#*,(($ )#$*-. (-% %*'#%$!                    /($ ''!"(++"!#$0112.2 ())' '$3!+ 2.0 ())'           - / ($ ''!"(. (!#( ))3 44444444. !$ )#,3$!($%''5 )!#-++.! $ ))344444444444.%$ )#444416 ($+    /($ ''!"(++"!#$+ 7%-*!#++ /($ ''!"( !$ !01128"! 9'39 !#$#'%!3 '% 9'3 $$!: ())'-2!'#+ 7%- *!# +  +  / ($ ''!"( !$ ! ""! .2; &7"! &'$3%#. !) 2.0 ())'%#%#!+$$!#!# $'&'$3#7#*!'+

$''!#3 )#$)#!$!##!#""#*##73#" !+      /($ ''!"(*'#%$! $%$3-7##++ '3+ 7%- *!# +  +  / ($ ''!"( !$ ! *'#%$! $%$  0 8!#! #$# "!!3: ())'+

7!)%")#!$!-$!#$*!!#%#! $'#7#*!'#$%,++#!$3*'#%$! $%$%# ""!#<=%#!!%$!!##'7#$3$%#$!!  

    

)#$)#!$! &% ",  &7" -)) !$%. %#! )#!$! 7###)*#*!!#. $3 *## %-* $ " $$ *>>3$*!% )#!$! "% $%# ##" !#*!!#. !#3 &%%#!))' ,$! (#$ ' )'' )#$%+ &%%#!))' ,$! "3 ! %'33 (-% $!*'#%$!!. $ ,$!!#)#%#!%%%'3*!#!#$'%+    !""# "$" #% "# &'# &$##%#$(##

8: 

)$! )' )$!#'$3 )!#-# )#$% (-% $%# "!#* 1 &7" -)) !$% %#!  7###)*#*!!# 8#% 1 :. )#3! !*!. # $ )!#- )#$% *77(#$3 #7#- ! (-% $%#  "!#. )' )#$% $!  #!%-)#!$! ($%33+ )!#- "#, (-% $!"!#$!! )#$%-'$3 !8#%:+  !#"%# !=111%", (-%3"-&-'3")!"7%--7## )!#- !"#$% &'"!#)#!$!!#.!%#$*#''!#+ 

!=11%. )!%#. $ )!#-"#, )#$%!##$3"%3$!!-'$3  !. ($%3, )$! + $   !"#*' )' !##$3 )#$% "%3$!!. "# ! "%3$! #)* $!!+ $ )!#- "%3,   !"#*! )#$% %*'#%$!!.%'3, )$!!- )#$!#$'#&3*#+ 

!=% )!%#&))%? #%!!-)%$ )#!##$3"73"-#'3*!#. $ "!#!&))% "#, !%% )* !+ * !"## )' ? #%! "7# #'*$!## - !%!'%''$!#$*' )#$%3(!!(#$3 (-% $!"%3$!!+ 

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

8:

!=11%%$!%($%3*!%- )!#-%##$%,- !$ !"7%-*!#0112. 2 ())' '' ("!#3! ! = 2  !7#!##$# ""! .2; &7"! &'$3%#. !) 2.0 ())'%#%#!!#*!%-7('"!#&7"!#.!)%#!+$$!#!# $'&'$3#7#*!'+ 

! = 12 %  &  )!%# #$''!#, )$! )*% %#$!% ##!# ""#*# #73#" ! !"#$%&'")#!$!+%!-)%$3% )$!#$''!#, !=12 %  &  %$!%   !"#$% &'" )#!$! )*% %#$!% ##!# ""#*# #73#" !+ 

!=2% )!%# '',*'#%$!! $%$3&))%. %% -$ !)#!$!##+

)$!.($%33!.-7#, !=2%%$!%*'#%$! $%$3 )!#- '3+ 

! =  1  %  )!%# )!#-  !"#$% &'" )#!$!#*! )((%*77(, )$!  !"#$% &'"! )#!$!! %! ! *'#%$! $%$3 -)#$!%  9"#"# *'#%$! $%$3(%!!$$($!. $!-$$(! != 2%1 )!%# )%3# !=  2 %   !7#!##$#. $ *'#%$! $%$3 *77(# ! '3% ! ! =  1 !7#!##$3 )((!+ -#)#%, )!#-%#"7%-*!#*'#%$! $%$'"%3$!!#*!%#!$#$3 (%" 0 ())'''*'#%$! $%$3%#""!<=%#!!%$!!##'7#$3 $%#$!!+ -)'!#'$3*'#%$! $%$!3#'3"3) $*'38#%0. :+ 

! =3  % .  )!%# )' *'#%$! $%$3 *'#%$!)!%!# )#$ $%$3 - )#$"7%!3 $%$3. $!-$$(! )#$ $%$3 )' (%". $#!-)' '' !- %7,"#*! $%$3+!#"%# !=%&.%#$%,(%"$#!$3%#''(%"$ !$$($!!%#$,#!"%!-''!#. $!3$!!)%##'7#$3#!#+  %!-)%$3% )$!%,.# $' )#$)#!$!-7#-*'#%$! $%$ )!#- '3 ''("!#3! != 1%!7#!##$#*77(, )$! !"#$%&'"!)#!$!! %! !*'#%$! $%$3-)#$!% 9"#"#*'#%$! $%$3(%!!$$($!. )!#-&)% *'#%$! $%$3!$$($!% "!#$"7#3!#'$3+#$%, )!#-%#"7%-*!#- *'#%$! $%$'"%3$!!#*!%''%##!$#$3(%" 0 ())'+ )!#-% #$%,%#!)#!$!-$!#$*!!# $'#7#*!'#!$3*'#%$! $%$%#""!#<=% #!!%$!!##'7#$3$%#$!!8!)$())& ! &''#(!!*77(@ ;!#!:+    )#$' A