Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-10-14707/4 AI generated

2-10-14707/4 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus

Case Number 2-10-14707/4
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-10-14707/4 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

         

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

     . +&  &" / 0%+) +3 (+&")  , (70 " *    "7+$$+* " +3 $+ #+$ " + 0++ "  $??3 $+ !  "#    0+"  0" $+* !  +&"&&"# * "  ! ")  0%+3"

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

+03  "# %$++3   + )+++3& 3  " '$7!+  ++ $+(+& * $+ "#   + )+++3& 3 "#   ("" $ " "$$ &+"+&+& '  "#   3 3 &  B0%+ " (3  00 + 3 !0 %+  $' (+&  "+&&+" $ "+!*   "#  ) 7+$(+&  # $ " +"0+3$)++A&+& " $++&+$ +'  + )+++3& 3 0  -''- " 0 &% 3 (%#+ $$ ,--* - "!&+ / . +&  &" " %+  &% 3 "%!0&% 3+3' 0   + )+++3& 3 (+&   (+&  #  " +" 0 $)+++3&  " $++&+$ *" +"+ !0+3&% "#7#(70"*"#  )"

,8:  $ 7#"  $  $$ 0++0+ *2 ; + $"$+ 0++0+ 3 (70 '

&!0& 30++0+(!+3+&+2','' &% )"0++0+ $+  $$,-*-"!&+'+ 3&% ). +& &" /#+ ' '0 12* ,1 "!&+  $+* $+ 0%&0  & ,--* - "!&+  0++0+3 ,-* - "!&+' 7# 3   > ,1 ) #  " 07 $%+  #+ +$+ " &+ (%#+0%&0 7++"  $+&+0++0+*2;+$"$+0++0+ 3(70'  &$&% 3(%#&3$+""# +& 37!"+! +)+++3& 3" 0# %$+ 3 (+& * 93+&+$ * 7!"+!3 " + 3 !0* 0++0+ !0 &+&&% 30 $++8-:' 

&#+03 %+ +" (%#&3& 3#+$7!+ 3 +3*0++3= > 316-66(*16,*$+3"# )"#  7+ 00(+& 0%+3 ' +"#  7+$+7#(70&"+&3"$77! 30%+  &) 0% # $ *  ) "#   7+  7#(70* "  ! "#   !+"" $+& & 0% #  &0 "#   7+$ 7$+& 0%+ $+"#& 7+$+&* # 7+$+0++0+$+&' +0%&+"&"#  !+"" & 3*0%+)0% 3&% 3 "#  7+$+!#+"#  7+$+0++0+$+"!!&% 30++0+'#+ "#   7+$+ 0++0+$+ "!! 0%+) 0% 3 &% 3 0%&+"  0++0+ +&!+ 80++0+:*!0"#  +&% 0"$  $+" &+"#7+$+&+' 

 & #+ #+03  $7!+ 3     3 %+ +"  (%#&3 3 &+& #(+ 3A"++307+3 ) 3"($"0% "' )  >  $+'+ 3"  )#+  > "# !# 3$+&+&" )#" "07$%+12* ,1"!&+!03  >,17 0++0+*2;+$"$+0++0+ 3(70   $ (%#+&% 3*  ,--* - "!&+  #+ +$+*  <'$7!+  " &+(%#+&% 37+$+&+'   >1-("# &&+)"# $ +0++0+$7+30"  '   >1"#"&&)#+$& "  3(*""# " #+'# * !# 33#+*7)  >1 $& "  3""&3'  0  >,$77!)"# #  "+&3""" #90+03$& "  3*" +#+)"# $77! 3"$& "  3&+$"+!* "  !   > 1   "# + "#3   > 1   , 7 * " + $& "  3$77!""+&3"  >7 3"!!' 

 & & 3 $& "  3 &+$"+! "# " 07 $%+ #+03  +$+  3!+++%+0"!&++&3$" 3 %+ )+2"!&+'

 ) " $& "  3  !  "+&3"0 #&3+ %  $+ " &+ 7+$+&+$& "  30++0+ $+= >,+ &7# 3  '

&+& 3$& "  +3%&3033" $&3+381*,,:   >3,-*"#&$& "  3$& +"# "  3"# 07+3 "  3* "  ! "# "  3 & !+++%+0* " & &+&  7)+0$+ "  3' 0  >,<(*, )!+++%+0  3#+&+&!+++%+0  ! % )+0++ #+&&*" +3 +&7# 3+++'3 !03 )"#" "

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