Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-10-7860/4 AI generated

2-10-7860/4 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus

Case Number 2-10-7860/4
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

+.++ #"!#!  %$ +  +0* %+ &+!#+0 $ :+'!+ +'0

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-10-7860/4 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus: +.++ #"!#!  %$ +  +0* %+ &+!#+0 $ :+'!+ +'0

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text













  



 

 

 !





"!# $!





 %&''

 













    







()!!&"!# $!%*#+"+#%'!

  



 

  



 



*,#" '+



   

-#+./+''$+ ).!,(*#" '+'&!0)

 

    





$

-#+./+''*"+"+# 011111111*!# $

2&( +''*+'0+."'"*

-2!+'!'# 3

#   ) * ++#!# 0 11111111111* !# $ 11111 ,

&"!

  

"$!00

-#+./+''$+ ).!)

4 %&+  ) 

- #+./+''#!#,(5'+!$6#0#$##6%%'0

# %7#" '+'+)

4%&+ )

-#+./+''#!#.++.+*89:4.!%:&$+'&!0* 

*,#" '+).;"!"+#!'+:&$+'&!04+%+'+)

!''+0# $! !+.++.+%4+0.#)

 

 



-#+./+''%'!#!!04 )#'0)

4 %&+  ) 

- #+. /+'' #!# %'!#!!  8 5## !$ ##0

.++#6%%'07#" '+)

4 . !&!!%+#!'+4+%+'+!; )!0%'!#!!.++.+

<=(+!'4$!0!!!%!%%)







  



- #+. /+'' .&+; +0 :+ '#;! ( :4.  #!*  !

#4 +%%+* #!+0 %+ $+% #!+ .++ #!! %>>0!%+ "! # $! !

.+#! .# %+* "! +'# ''# $!* #!!!" #;! .&+0#

$'00#+"+#!%'!*#!+#;!+ $'0%++!'+)

 ).&+;+0 "!# $!&"!# $!% !:#*#!+%

.!!*%+ + !%+!#* ++'+!0%&!.:&$!) 

5,7

.&+;+0&!%%&!.:&$! % !*#!+?7$+.%4%+:!$!

+$+#  +%!0#4%!!.+++#!+++#+#!#+".!6'0%+37

# $!+!'+ +%!% 4%+ :!$! + # $!#!  +%!0 #  .&+ %

+'0 #4 +++ #!+ ++#+#! #+" .! 6'0%+ .&+ # $!+!'+3 (7

 ! + .&+'!0 0! # $ $)  .&+; +0  !

#4 +%%+  , :4.  #! '+' #!+  ! !; #4  +%0

.4:  +  ;"++#+ .&+ .+#! .#%+* .&+; # +0 !

#4 +%%+:4. #!) !+ !$+%'!&!*

# +.'!04$# $!.&+++%!'!0+!'+*!;#+0#&+#

 .%+%+ &:!.++%+# .+#) '!;+  %+ :; %'!;+

 0!4!04$4"+%+#%4$##%'! +%+'!*

%+%+#%'!;+ ;*#&++%#5 =7)



  !""# "$" #% "# &'# &$##%

#$(##



$! ' # $!'!0 #  # $! #+"+#! .% , :4.  #!  $+

#4 +%%+ 5 (,7* $ +0 %*  #!+ #  # $! %44"!0 4$#

#+"+#!+.* '# $!&+!$+ !"$!00)



+.0!# +0%44"!#+"+#!.!'0%+# $!! '# 

++#+#!#4 +%!0):"++5,@7) '# 0+##.!'0%+

# $!!) *## $! '%44"'!0#+"+#!.%+4$*+ 4$

# $!#+"+#!.'!0)



 = ,  * ( # $ .&+; # $! $  ! $+  ! "$!00

$+.0! %4"+!0   !0 &+!+#! :&$'0!0 !!* #!+ # * #

# $! ' %44"'!0 .%+ 4$* +  4$ .'!0* ++ #!+ $+  +%+

# #4.4+"+++.&+#!+ +%+#4.+#!)!$! #$+!0

A#++0 .4+0 #  :  %#.&!# '+'  ! .&+;  !$! $

# $!+!'+ :+0%) $! +;*  + +' # ++  = ,  8 %4"+!0

 !%+.4+.+0 !+0)



+  !0 # $! +;*  $+ ' $+.0! %4"+!0 !!   !0

&+!+#!:&$'0!0'+'# $!$'0; =,*(*84!".0

  !)  = ,,,  , 4+0 ".0 +; # $! ! :&$'0.

6#'&+!+#!:&$'0!)



+.0!# $&%+# ++) # ;"+(++!%+:+'!*%+

! # $!!+ :##!% #  % ;++A '++0+0 '!+0 '+' #  # $!!

0!0  '!  &+  "!" !% .. +!0 ".)

%

#+"0:+'!#+''++0: 0*# $!!.04+%:+'!$!%!#+# .

!" A ' 8 #!%+ #+"!) . :+'!  #+"0 ' #  # $!!0

%#%+ .++.+%+ # "" !% .++.+ *8 9 %#%+ #!!!. !%% +

%#%+.++.+!0:4.*#!+0%+.4$%#!+#" '+)+ .!$'&!0

# .!!%%*,#" '+*%++'0!.0.++.+0)+!0".!! '

# #!'!0+: :#!!0#!:!B'!+0''0!%'+'"+##!'!0+

#4+!%+ :  .$ &%+!0 :+'! +'+%!+)  ' ".'!0 .++.+ :"+ 0+

)(), #!'+ )) '+' $ '&!; #  .++.+ !%+ !%% * ,

#" '+)C$: '&!0 %'0%+ '.&'+#!'!0(8#" '+)+ !0

(5,7

'&!;

-#+./+''$+ ).!,(*#" '+!%+*%+:&$+.&'.! '

*,#" '+'+'.++.+0@*,#" '+)4$!0 =( ;$# 

.4%&+$#!#.++.+0:"+ 0+$++%+#!'+:&$+'&!04+%+'+*8

9:4.!%.&!%%)



 '$+.0!&+!+#!:&$'0'!0$+%4"+!0 !+0*.++0<=

0333:*3(*%+0# $!;# $!!4+

.. :+'! .&+ 0!* #!!!" # $!! "+##!%+' ' .&!$ !'.

# $!! 4+% 4%+' .&+ %+# $' 4+%+'* $! 4+%+ .++.+%+') !+

.&'+# ' # $!! "+##!'!0* .&+; .&!0 '&!0 # $!! 4+%+  "$+

# $!! 4+%+ .++.+%+ # "" '&!0 .++.+) $+ # $!! 4+%+

.++.+%+# "".&+;.&!0'&!0.&'+#!.++.+!+'"+5.++.+7*".# $!!

+'&!.#%!!!%+#!'+# $4+%+'+)



 ' $+ $+.0! %4"+!0 !!   !0 &+!+#! :&$'0!0 '+'

$: +!0A#++0.4+0!;!0# :  %#.&!#)  ;

=,! !%+)+ !0#!!!;$+ =,

# $  ! "$!0%+ '+' #  !; $ #!# .4 %&+

,(*  #" '+  ".0  = ( 4! .++.+ *8 9 :4. !%

:&$+'&!0*   * , #" '+  $+ +%+*   ).;"!"+  #!'+

:&$+'&!04+%+'+)



=,:# $!''+;# $! %!+.++.+%4+0.#

 !)



=# $#'';$+%'!#!!0: *##$!# !$+) $!*

"$!00$+*4; =!%'!#!!0# #'0)



. =,(%44";# $!$ ! !#+'0### 

$6.+.0%'!#!!0*#!+$+;# $!%44"!0#%'!#!!0'+%#+"*

#!!!"  =   , # $ + # $0  =    ( 4!* #!+

%'!#!!0 %44"# #+'0#  = , 4!0 # "")  '  '!0

%'!#!!0 '+%#+" # $ #  .4 %&+ $+.0! +%+ !!0

"+++&+.   #" '+* %##4! #++"%'! .0! +%+ !!0 "+++&+. 8

#" '+ '+' +'0 %#!0 ! &+!;+  8 #" '+   ; # 

%'!#!!0!!"!#+'0#.$'0+&!!%+#!'+4+%+'+%'!#!!0

.++.+ !%+ < = (   '4$!0 !!!% !%%)  ' +'!0

%'!#!!+0&'0.00 #!%'0+058*(((7



=0(*# $ '%'!#!!0%'! +# $!#!!0# $!.4+0

#!!0* #!!!" # $!#!!0 ' "+++&+.* #! ' '+'  4;+.%+ #!!0) .

=(@:*(!;"+++&+.!!0$+'+'"+++&+.!!!"!&!;+.++

$+''*#!+0!+ '4$!0+++). =,,: '# $!.4+#

#!!# %##4! #++"%'! #!!0 !$!* #!+ %##4! #++"%'! .0! 4+

%44"!"$!0% =,(:(!*.4".!0*#!+$+ '%'&!0

+!0 $+% #!+ 6# #!! :4" #++"%'! &::!)  0! ".0 !; # 

$ #!# .4 %&+ %'!#!!' $+$+'0 ".0 $+.0! +%+

!!0"+++&+.#" '+%##4!#++"%'!#!!"+++&+.8#" '+



,5,7

.  = ,, :  ' # $!.4+0 #!!0 %'! + +'0  '&!

#!!0) =8# $*#!+%'! +':;%'!#!!0 !#+'0#

%44". # $!$'0+ # $ #'0% + %'! + +'0'!0 :+'!+ +'0

#!!0*%&+;# $!#!!0.4:&$'0!0.+#!!!) $!+;*#4 .

+.++ #"!#!  %$ +  +0* %+ &+!#+0 $ :+'!+ +'0

#!!0 !0!!"!# .4%&+%+)'!0$+'4  '%+''%$+*

%+0 #!# # "0!. %0 '&! # ""  %+ ' % +! 6$ +0)

".0'&!0!!"!'+' !*+.++++ '!0#"!+'%$!#: 

.$ + '!0 .+0!* + $'0#  !* :; # $! :&$'0!0 

.+#!#&+!;+#!!##" '+)



+ !0# $!+;*#!'# $! !4+$%'!#!!# #'0'+'

".0 =,(4!.&+;# $!$ ! !#+'0#

%44" # #  $6.+.0 %'!#!!0* !; #   )  .4 %&+

- #+.

/+''#!#%'!#!!'"+++&+.$+.0!%##4!.0!+%+# ##!

8#" '+$+'0#!!!%%#" '+*# ##!%'!#!!8

#" '+) !; !&!!%+#!'+4+%+'+!0%'!#!!.++.+

<=(+!'4$!0!!!%!%%)





$!'+#?