Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-10-18346/4 AI generated

2-10-18346/4 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus

Case Number 2-10-18346/4
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

 

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-10-18346/4 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus:  

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

 

 

 

         

   

     !"#         $ %&' $( )"*!+ )" *,! !"    )"*,! !"     *!-" $ %&' $( .-""+ ////////0  ////// 1! ////// *!+ # +0 "+  !""- !+23   ")"!+ 1!!""    !++$"! %&' $()"*!+ *,! !+$"! %&' $( .-""+ ////////0  ////// 1! ////// *!+ # +2  )   !"! !!4  ,,)"!+" 1!!"".++ 56"-7186) 9

!"0!:40442  #!!+  " 1!+! "7 -"!  !!  # #7+ 

  #   !"   #!!+ +  + "! !   !0 * )" *,! + $!"+ +++ "!" ),*0  )"!+"!"-")"*,! !""+*!-"*0 !+""! +,"",),* " *!) ! "+ ), "+ ,  ;;+"0 "+  *""  "" !0 "71!+!*!!+ !!+"",  "+"",- " ! "+0 *  ""!0 "+ " ! !+ ), "--!"++!+"<,)"*,! !"*!-"! *!-*,""*"7**1!+  <",,!7*""*"!,""!  <"+*!++!"*,! +$!"+ +++  =,    9)"!!"  ,,- "*""!     ++)"*!+-"7"+!*!-"! "!+"!

 . 2 -*," )+*!-"*"**"!"+,""   #,! ")"**! ")"!+" 1!!""" !+  "!+"::4.!""+"1+*""2" 1!!" "".""+::9:90*!+ $&><2 "-!+1*"" .+!"1+2" " 5 6"-718.-""+ 99 0*!+44$ ?+72     

,, )! *"7 "+ ,,7 4 ),* !0 ! ,, ,""0 "-! # +  !"!#$%!&#'  <"*!+!!7$ %&' $(+)"*,! !"0 "*+ "!"  "-!  ! )"+"* * "" )!+++!!,"1"-+ 0"+!++ *!!+  +"+    " ! *!-"  +!" ! !*! """*!-"*" !!"!+"! *!-" +!""+"!*! "<"*!+"""- 1!*+*!-"+*"+#!-")"!-""* "+  ""!)")"+"!,0"*+","+!"!*"!" ,"+*"+ !"" ""+  #!-" " ! *! !" ,"  ""-* ,"!-"+*!-",""-" !+-"" )+*+ +-* ,")""*+ ,"7*+"+ #!-" )-" !  "-* !," ! !)!"! "0  +-! " !"+  "+ &!+ !! !7 $ %&' $( < @+  !- 0 !- 3 9 !- 3  3  !-  !! !-+ $ %&' $( )"!  !+ *,!  $ %&' $( ) #!-"  )"*!+! !"+ !   )    *+ "- "" .!0 02  $#%$&$'$ $   $ " )"!+" + !  $ %&' $( + 99!  ,"-"" -""+ 99 ! "1"- )"-*  !+ !,7" -+ )"+" 99:!","")"+"# !"!,"!71!0")"!"!*,"! +7 " "* *!"+"- )" 999! " & #6  "70  +" + !)"+ )"+ !+" ! " $! *!! 7! 1! !  )!"-0  +" ,"+*! !++ )"   99! " //////*!!!//////)+"70"!!"*"";"+0)+//////  "+ ! " ""- -!" ++ !!* )+"7" !! """ !+" 1* !!! ,"1"-! " ")"!" "!" " 1! )+"  +-  * +" **  ""+ #!-"  *++ + ! !! ,"1"- ! !!" *!-" -**!+ !" )+" " ! !"+  -*! "" *  "  " !)"- !! )"! *+ ! "  ,"+*! **!" 7*+ +"*"+

 . 2 )"+ "  "   !" -*0  ""* 11-"  .1)"+"2 )" !7 *,- )!  "! !! !"+  *!-"  +!+5 !*"*+-"+ "++"")! 0  * )-"+ "+ " *  !!  ,"1"-  +!+ *"*+ + -""* &+! !) *!-"   +  "-  ! (1" 1)"+  -""++ ,  &) "+  ! +-  1)"+  1-!" , "

  " !+ !"! 7" ! ""+ *!-"! *"!" 1))!"!  "!!""- )"*!-"!+0!""+11 !"!!)!"! "-0*,!"+!))*"++"  )!: +!,"1"-11-"!+*"+*!+  +-  ,"1"- " "+ *, " #!-" !)  +  "- 9! ""+ *!-"! " !"+"- +*+ "+  !  +"-&1)"+"!-97"-!"0+ *,-  )"+ )"0 " !" 4 A +* *!-"- !)"+ " <, !! !)"- " !" *!-"! *,- !"+  -  "+0  !! !"+!)"-+!!" + *711-"!)"!"!)+ (  ,,*7-"""+"!"!+&*-* ," "++)+"#!-"!!"+*!*+)+ ,"7!+#!-""?+7$!-+9*+!&><$ ,"*!-"!!-+!!1" !"!0"! "" , - "*""!9", -'- - " !*!-+ !" "  *7" 11  ////// ;;  "" #!-"  -  -* *,!! + 1 $ - <!!-+"+*!+1 7""! "" #! " -" !)""  ," $ - <! 0  *!-" *"7  )"-*- + *" $ - <! "!0 ,,+ " + *"   "  !)!+ !))+ !""+-0 "!! ! $

- <! )"+"  *!-" )! "*  + *! )+" "!!)""$ -<!0*!-")!$>* *++"7*+$ -<!07-"*-1!!+  7+!"!**!-$ -<!$> -* "!0  !77 *++ !+"0 !)"- !" !)) "- *+"+ )"+" !+ +" *!-" !  ! *" $ - <! ,  "! -"" -""+0 "+  * "- *!-" *!+ !+ *"+

;;*+""!+*!-"!*"!"*"+$>+  !!! ,- $ > )! *!)"- 1!1!" ("""-!)"- ,- !)"  *+ !"""-+ ! *""*" -" +"  $ &> <

 + !+ *+  *!-" ","+ 1!+! ,"1"- -*!)+"-);;++)!,"1"-)"*,! !" #!-" )"+"+"+ ,*!  ,"1"- -* )"+"! 99   1!+ ! "+  ! $!  "!7 * 11-"!+ *! ,"1"- -* 7! *,"0 *)"!" !* " =, -""* );; ,"1"- -*  "+  +! B ,"1"- 11-"!+*!+!* +-""" );;+!*,+0!  ! " ,"1"- -*- + )1"!"+ " ! ++ !!"! *,++ "1"- )"!  7 !   + , ,-! *,+0 "+ "- 9 " * ,"1"- )"!  + ,+ ! <"*!+ ! *" "-  *!-" )"! - ! -""*  B  499  " $ " )"!+" *  *!-"  

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

"+ *!-+  +"  

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

!"70)"*!+++ !7!+"! 

"-"! ,,7 *!-" "+ )"*!+ +  *"7 )" *,!  !".!:2$ "!+7)"*,! !".!::2  $ ")"!+"+!"+-"-*!-")!"+*!-+ * "" +0 *!-" 7"!" "- + ! .! 0 0  2 ! 

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

 . 2 $ " )"!+  "+   !+ *0 "!! !   " )"!+"   ::4 "  !+  0 " .!  9:2  !"70  *+  " !+" ;;0 ;;   0 !7 ,,  "! )"!+"!1!,""::4"0"!!!*,! -"   +  ""-"! "! <"!+" !! !7 )"* *!!+"::4"*,! " ")"!+" 1!!"""   !- + !+   " !+ "+ !,7" 5 6"-71 80 1*"" !   0 " 5 6"-71 8  1!!" " ""70"!C11"!"""* -,"7! 

"E