Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-08-64673/5 AI generated

2-08-64673/5 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus

Case Number 2-08-64673/5
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-08-64673/5 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

           

        !"  

#"$!%"   !!&'((                 ))*&+)'#"$!%"& ,$+# +$&("                    '"(("- . %+ *  *  /" 0 00 $#!!(+ ('"-* 1$#!!(+          '"(("- .,#+#+$!!-22222222,"$!%34#+ 0'#"+((,+(-  (++/+5 $!  *  * , ++$"$!!- 22222222222, #+#+ 6#( "$!% 22222 /-  222222222222, +$ /++7+&+$!%-&*    #%"--'"(("- .%+**/"!+* 6 &'+**'"(("- .$"$#/-"$!(!(#) )18 9-7($ /'+ #/-"$!(! (# )11)0)   :($     ;$%$ "%$$-$%$$4&&(-$%$<$#!!(+*

"((+-$!%"!"+/++/+&6+-/$*      '"(("- . &("$""- 6  = "" *  *  $(-  *  * &("$""-)=""'"(("- .$(-* 6  &'+ *  *  '"(("- . $"$ &("$""  ;$$- $%$$4&&(-+<$#!!(+#/-"$!(!(#) )189-7($/'+ #/-"$!(!(#)11)0):($*  

     '"(("- . /'+7 +- >+!!($7"  >6/ !!$",  !" $6!+&&+, $"+- &+ %+ & $"+ /++ $"" &??-"&+ #" $!%" !" /+$" /$ &+, #" +($!(($!%", $" ""# $7" /'+-$ %(--$+# +$"&(",$"+$7"+!%(-&++"(+* **/'+7+- #"$!%"'#"$!%"&  !">$ ,$"+ & /"", &+ !+  !" &+ "$, !+ +(+"- &' "/

 ;< >'% "*   /'+7 +- '"& &' "/ >'% " !&!", $"+@ )< %+ /& 6&+>"%"!+%+$! !+&"-$6&""/+++$"+++$+$"$+#  /"4(-&+5<$!%"+"(++&"& 6&+>"%"!+$!%"$"!+&"- $!  /'+ & +(-  $6 +++ $"+ ++$+$" $+#  /" 4(-&+ /'+ $!%"+"(+5 <  !" + /'+("- -" $!% %*   /'+7 +-  !" $6!+&&+)>6/ !!$"(+($"+ !""7 $6 !+&- /6 >!! +  7#++$+ /'+ /+$" /$&+, /'+7 $  +- !" $6!+&&+   >6/ !!$"* "+  !" %+ &(" '",  $!  + /("- 6% $!%" /'+ + +&"("- +"(+, "7 $  +- $'+$   /&+&+ '>"/++&+$ / +$* ("7+!&+>7&("7+! -"6"-6%  6#+&+$ & 6%  $ $ &("!+&+(", &+ &+$  &("7+ !7, $'++&$ ; A)<*     !""# "$" #% "# &'# &$##%#$(## 

!%" !( $!%"("- $!  $!%" $+# +$" /& %!+- &,  $"+ $!  $!%"&66#"-6% $$+# +$"+/,!($!%"'+"%+/'(/" +(-"/ /++/+('"- !"#%"--*  +&# +-,&+!(-"-$!#-"/% >!!(6+-"-$! -#+22222 ) +(( # "&!($!%">!+"">!!"-%!+"6% &??-"&+;), ,,,0, , ), , <*:'% :!++>#B$""#+->!++!$!(('+(-+$!%+ ! !""("- /'+&+$"$ * *  &#  -- -#+ 22222  ),  $!(#!+&+$+"+/("-;<* !%"&66#"- %+&# +- 6+ *-&7#+ 0** & >!$+ ; <* %/+$"#+#+ (-&7+ 6#+ !( $!  #+#+ 6#( "$!%$!%+$"!&/+"4$"6>"22222/-222222222222; <*$" 

!+&+ (-&7+ 6#+ !( *  *  !"- &$"/+- /6 &$+- /++&+ ""+ 0**  C# # >!! ; 1<*   !7 $!  &("-!$"&(+- /+$$" $6!+&&+* !  !( $!%"&66#"-  %+&# +- /+$" $6!+&"- /-&+ &+$ -(( * ("#+ ) ; )<* /+$" $6!+&&+!7$!%"#/- A )16"&("-!$"&(-+- $!  $6!+&"$*  !( $!  -+$ $ /" (-&+ $!%""* ! , $ $!%" !( &66#("- $+# +$" /&+ 6% , + ! 6% $!%" $+# +$" /("-* 

 A   ),  $!% /'+7 $!%" %  !" %+  !" #%"-- %+/-" &6#+"-   !"- '+"+$" >'% (-"- "", $"+ $! , $ $!%" !( &66#("- /&+ 6% , + ! 6% /("-, ++ $"+ %+ !+&+ $! $6/6+#+++/'+$"+!+&+$6/+$"* "%"!$% +"- B$++- /6+- $!  >!! !&$/'"$ (+(  !" /'+7  "%" % $!%"+"(+>+-&* 

!%"+7,%+!(%+/-"&6#+"-""  !"-!+'+"+$" >'% (-"-(+($!%"%(-7 A), ,1,1)6"#/-   !"* A6+-#/-+7$!%"!">'% (-/! 4$('+"+$">'% (-"* 

 ;< +/-"$!%'&++->!!-*&+(">+(",&+$!%(%  $!  1  $#!!(+*   $(-+ (""&& $!  >($!(!* & %  >!! $!#-"/ ('"-&+ /'(/" "&+$ + ! $!  (">+(" " $$+("- /'(/" "("-* !  /'(/" %   !( 0 00 $#!!(+, &+ >'%+/'(/"!(1$#!!(+,)$#!!(+!(+(#+/'(/",/6%(-"->>#%/) $#!!(+  /6%(-"- /++/+/'(/" )1 $#!!(+*   !( !& ('"- >'% (-&+$ $!%"+("-$!!>+-(">+(" $! -"-%!+"-*   !(%+/-"'+"+$">'% (-("-%+&6#+"- !"+-,/++-DA-5 )5)5)))>)*  D A  $!% !( #7+ $#-++-+>+( $#-++-+>+(, &+ !& & (-"/'+ $"/""/$#-++-+(- ((7/'+$!%""7(-&#7+ $#-+++/'+("* 

!%"+7,>!!/%*&+'&+"-(">+(!(#7+ $#-++-+>+(DA  6%(-"*   (-+ (" !& & (-"/" #&, $!  !( #7+  /''+"-"6%(-"*   !(%+/-"'+"+$">'% (-("-%+&6#+"- !"+-,/++-DA-5 )5)5)))>)5)) *  /DA-)5)5)"7$!%""6+//>+("/'+-"*

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

 ;< #7+ $#-++-+>+(" 6+&+ /++/+&+  6#+* +&"- '+ + (6  /'+&" ('"- #7+ $#-++-+>+(" $!## 6+&+ /++/+&+ >>#%/+* !!-" "(/ "7% ('"$! >>#%/+)$#!!(+/6 &'+&+$ 6#%"-&*  !(%+%+/-"&6#+"-""  !"-!+'+"+$">'% (-"- (+( %  >!! +"- B$++- /6+- "7 "- $!  >!! !&$/'"$*   !7 A)" !"&+*+ !"-$"""7%+ A  ) $!%  !" !+ #%"-&+ (+( $!  "7 %  $"$ /6  &'+$#!!(+* 

A)>$!%"((+7$!%"!&"+/++/+&6+-/$  !"*+ !"-$!%""((+7 A)>" !"!& "+/++/+&6+-/$* 

 A )  ) $!% $((7 %+&(" $""- >!!, $ $% "$ !" %+* /  A )   ) $((/- %+ !+ #%"-&+ $!## $((/- >!!- &("$""- /'#- !-, $"+ $!%" + ! &("$""+- /'#-+ %+ #%"-&+ "" /'+ + 6 &("$""+- 6++$" /'+ !+ >!! (-+ $(-*

!%",#%"--%+!+="", 67% &("$""-="" $! $(- $! &("$""-)=""% $(-*  / A)) &66#7$!%"% !" !"$+(-$$$!  %4/+/-&("$""-,$"+% +7$!%"&66#"- $&("$""-(+&$+# *  !(!("-$! /6 &'+&("$""(""-#+++'+/"-* 

A-) ),$!%!(&("$""-&("!+$!%"$""- $!%"/6+- $""-, $" ""# $!%"$""- !( #+++'+/, $" !( (+(   67+/&+ $""-* /

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

!%"(+$@