Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-10-15165/4 AI generated

2-10-15165/4 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus

Case Number 2-10-15165/4
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-10-15165/4 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus: 92: #&33"*!*" $& ," *"< *#&3$** &*( ( (1%*<*3 ! "# ++++"# $ )"," *$ 1  ,$** $* ",**&* 3$% 1)%# ( 1%*<*3% $$% 1)%# $ ," *@:#*1$8$*) #  *#*"*$ 3"8$ 1*" ***"*" "*!1 7&3$*5: "# * &* *$ $ 8$* ) #  * "# "  *$ 3 " 1%* $ *&3 "8 *** " * **"*"  "*! 1  7&3$* 1%* "# * &*5 .:   * 1%*& 3 3  "# #(  1%*< *3   "8*$$*  2 )81 "  &*& " *    < "8 *$3 18) *  <!"* 1%* 1*"  1"$*, 1%*< " *3   "8*$$*-)81" ( * #*$& % , "*1& 38#"# 1%***$ & 3* &*, <"*3"%*"  1$*$* %) 1$*" 1*"( & <* $* )< $& <* 3 8 38#8!*$*"$8#""$& *$*& , $*$*"$& <*<,"%**$"9  >-6:(    !""# "$" #% "# &'# &$##% #$(##  #  & "# & 3 " "#  "*!*"  1$ 2 )81 "   #* "8*$$* 9 '.:, #*3 $,  " * " "#  $88! 3 8#" "*!*" *1,&"# %* #* !# 33( 

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

         

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

     / *&  &" 0 1%*< *3 )*&"<  . )81 " ,    "8*$$*, " *3 $* #*$ " * 1 "  $??3 $* !  "#    1*"  1" $*, !  *&"&&"# , "  ! "<  1%*3"

92: #&33"*!*" $& ," *"< *#&3$** &*( ( (1%*<*3 ! "# ++++"# $ )"," *$ 1  ,$** $* ",**&* 3$% 1)%# ( 1%*<*3% $$% 1)%# $ ," *@:#*1$8$*) #  *#*"*$ 3"8$ 1*" ***"*" "*!1 7&3$*5: "# * &* *$ $ 8$* ) #  * "# "  *$ 3 " 1%* $ *&3 "8 *** " * **"*"  "*! 1  7&3$* 1%* "# * &*5 .:   * 1%*& 3 3  "# #(  1%*< *3   "8*$$*  2 )81 "  &*& " *    < "8 *$3 18) *  <!"* 1%* 1*"  1"$*, 1%*< " *3   "8*$$*-)81" ( * #*$& % , "*1& 38#"# 1%***$ & 3* &*, <"*3"%*"  1$*$* %) 1$*" 1*"( & <* $* )< $& <* 3 8 38#8!*$*"$8#""$& *$*& , $*$*"$& <*<,"%**$"9  >-6:(    !""# "$" #% "# &'# &$##% #$(##  #  & "# & 3 " "#  "*!*"  1$ 2 )81 "   #* "8*$$* 9 '.:, #*3 $,  " * " "#  $88! 3 8#" "*!*" *1,&"# %* #* !# 33( 

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

*13  "# %$**3   * <*3& 3  " ($* 6 8!$" )*& , $* "#   * <*3& 3 "#   )"" $ " "$$ &*"*&*& (  "#   3 3 &  B1%* " )3  11 * 3 !1 %*  $( )*&  "*&&*" $ "*!,   "#  < 8*$)*&  # $ " *"1*3$<A&*& " $**&*$ *(  * <*3& 3 1  -((- " 1 &% 3 )%#* $$ -, . "!&* 0 / *&  &" " %*  &% 3 "%!1&% 3*3( 1   * <*3& 3 )*&   )*&  #  " *" 1 $<*3&  " $**&*$ ," *"* !1*3&% "#8#)81","#  <"

.92:  $ 8#"  $  $$ 11* , ; * $"$* 11* 3 )81 (

&!1& 3)!*3*-((-" &*(.(11*2-,"!&*(*  3&% </ *& &" 0#* ( (1 .2'.,2"!&* $*,$* )%#*1%&1  &  -, . "!&*  11*3 2-,  "!&*( 8# 3   > .6 < #  " 18 $%*  #* *$* " &* )%#*1%&1  8**"   $*&* # " " 11* , ; * 11* 3 )81  " &* )%#*1%&1   $*&*(  & $ &% 3 )%#&3$*" "#  *& 3 8!"*!   * <*3& 3  " 1# %$* 3 )*& , 73*&*$ , 8!"*!3 " * 3!1,11*!1 &*&&% 31 $**96.:( 

 & #* #*13  $8!* 3     3 %* *"  )%#&3 3 &*& #)* 3A"**318*3 < 3")$"1% "( <  >26  $*(* 3"  <#*  >26 "# !# 3$*&*&" <#" "18$%*.2'., 2"!&*!13  >.68 11*,;*$"$*11* 3)81  $)%#*&% 3,-,."!&*#*13 *$*,.($8!* " &*)%#*&% 38*$*&*(   >2-)"# &&*<"# $ *11*$8*31"  (   >"#"&&<#*$& "  3),""# " #*(# , !# 33#*,8<  > $& "  3""&3(  1  >62.$88!<"# #  "*&3""" #71*13$& "  3," *#*<"# $88! 3"$& "  3&*$"*!, "  !   > 6  2 "# * "#3   > 6   . 8 , " * $& "  3$88!""*&3"  >628 3"!!( 

 & & 3 $& "  3 &*$"*! "# " 18 $%* #*13  *$*  3!*%*1"!&**&3$" 3 %* <*"!&*(

 < " $& "  3  !  "*&3"1 #&3* %  $* " &* 8*$*&*$& "  311* $*= >.* &8# 3  (

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