Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-08-49808/16 AI generated

2-08-49808/16 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus

Case Number 2-08-49808/16
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

"#  & $33!& 1 0$* 3#- *  3# 0& 1- ** " * #* *$*

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-08-49808/16 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus: "#  & $33!& 1 0$* 3#- *  3# 0& 1- ** " * #* *$*

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text













   







 





! "# 





$

%&&

 













    







'()!*+,,,,"# $-"*!*"$& 

  



 

  



 





'./-/"!&*



   



&"#*((0 './-/"!&*&% 1(

 

    





#

&"-!*!*"1,,,,,,,,- "#!&&*

2 *&&- )*& *& *&1 !* 3&0  0(10

45!*6$-10"1*75!6#8

$3* 9:

"((-**" "1,,,,,,,,,,,- "#,,,,,"5

,,,,,01,,,,$"&1(

  

!# 11

&"#*((0 (

3 $%* (  (  

 &" " " ' ./ ;"""5$$&1 *  # ""1

"$"5$$&1" <"!&*/&*(

&&*1"#  *00*$3*10"(

 

 





&"$& "  13(("&1(

3 $%* (  (  

 &" " " $& "   2 ;0  # 5#"1

"#""5$$&1<"!&*(







  





 &" 0%*7 *1 )*&"7  . )30 " -   

"3*$$*- " *1 $* #*$ " * 0 "  $==1 $* !  "#   

0*"  0" $*- !  *&"&&"# - "  ! "7  0%*1"

#&11"*!*" $& -" *"7 *#&1$** &*(

((0%*7*1 ! "# ,,,,"# $ )"-" *$

0  -$** $* "-**&* 1$% 0)%# (

0%*7*1% $$% 0)%# $ -" *>+<#*0$3$*) # 

*#*"*$ 1"3$ 0*" ***"*" "*!0 5&1$*:<

"# * &* *$ $ 3$* ) #  * "# "  *$ 1 " 0%* $

;.<

*&1 "3 *** " * **"*"  "*! 0  5&1$* 0%* "# * &*: .<

  * 0%*& 1 1  "# #(  0%*7 *1  

"3*$$*  + )30 "  &*& " *    7 "3 *$1

03) *  7!"* 0%* 0*"  0"$*- 0%*7 " *1  

"3*$$*)30" ( * #*$& % -

"*0& 13#"# 0%***$ & 1* &*- 7"*1"%*"

 0$*$* %) 0$*" 0*"( & 7* $* )7 $& 7*

1 3 13#3!*$*"$3#""$& *$*& -

$*$*"$& 7*7-"%**$"; 

?+'/<(



  !""# "$" #% "# &'# &$##%

#$(##



#  & "# & 1 " "#  "*!*"  0$ + )30 "   #*

"3*$$* ; .+<- #*1 $-  " * " "#  $33! 1 3#"

"*!*" *0-&"# %* #* !# 11(



*01 "*1$33! "*!*" 0 &1$*"#  &"

"3*$ 1 

?.+3 1"!!+(07! !*+;/<(

&"

1*""0 &1$*"#  (-""# &$33!& 1"*!*" 0$*

3#-*3#"# "*!*" 0& 1(





 ? '  +- . "# 0%*7 "#  #   #*   !# 11

#*01  $3!* 1   1 %* *"  )%#&1 1  - " * "- "

"#  & $33!& 1 0$* 3#- *  3# 0& 1- ** " * #* *$*

""303*!*0%*" **$*"30*" (

 # "#* 1

@"**1 03*1 " ) $"0% " &*&   0%*7   #  #

"# * &* )*1$( #  *7-  * *& " ** 

 ? '  2 $3!* 1

 $*03*0*1 *1(



*  1 "#  *7-  #* & #*01  $3!* 1     1

%* *" )%#&1 1&*&"# #&17 

?'+-.-23 !01

  ( 

 ?    3*1 !01 *7 "#    )%#&10

5"&%* *" )%#&1 (



*01  "# * # " 0  &% 1 +2(& !*   %$* 1

0% &&*  -$*"#&"0%&0 # $ $$'./-

/"!&*(+2(& !*0% &&* &0!$* 100$!*0  

)*&   0 1 ") 1 33*  ( *  1 &% 7 

 &" #* (  (

0 './-/"!&* $*;+.-/<(

&$&% 1)%#&1$*""# 

*& 1+2(& !*" 10% &&* ;'<(



A

?1.+:'/+:+:+++)+"#&)*&-$* 7""#  

3*$**- 71  "**0"#  0%*$* &&*""#  

$ - 0% &&* ( #    7 3* 00 )*&  0%* 1 - "  !

"#   !*"" $*& & 0% #  &0 "#   3*$ 3$*& 0%* $*"#&

3*$*&- #  3*$* 00*$*&(  * 0%&*" & "#   !*"" & 1- 0%*7

0% 1&% 1"#  3*$*(



.;.<

 & #* #*01  $3!* 1     1 %* *"  )%#&1 1 &*&

#)* 1@"**103*1 7 1")$"0% "(

7



?'+  $*(* 1"  7#* 

?'+

"# !# 1$*&*&" 7#" "03$%*'./-

/"!&*(





?/+)"# &&*7"# $ *00*$3*10"

 (





?+/+"#"&&7#*$& "  1)-""# " #*(# -

!# 11#*-37 

?+/+ $& "  1""&1(



0 

?+'+.$33!7"# #  "*&1"""

#50*01$& "  1-" *#*7"# $33! 1"$& "  1&*$"*!

"  ! 

 ? +'/   "# * "#1 

 ? +'/  + . 3 - " *

$& "  1 $33!" "*&1" 

 ? +'+ 3 1 "!!(

 & & 1

" 03 $%* $& "  & #*01  *$*   1 !*%*0 + '2 "!&*

&*& *&1 $" 1   %* 7*   . "!&* ;*$ "3*7$" <- """  

$& "  2"!&*(

&*& 1$& "  1&*$"*!$& "  *1

%&1011" $&1*1;/'<(





?1+.+-"#&$& "  1$& *"# "  1"# 03*1

"  1- "  ! "# "  1 & !*%*0- " & &*&  37*0$* "  1( 0



?+.)+-. 7!*%*0  1#*&*&!*%*0  ! % 7*0

#*&&-" *1 *&3# 1***(1 !01 7"#" "

03 $%* #*#*&1 !01 $& "  & !*%*0 #*01  *$* + '2

"!&*(



0 

 ? + ) + & "# 03*1 "  1 $& * *&1  &% 

"  1( 

?+'2+-"#-" *$& *&)7$& "  1 "*&1"

$33!0 "# #&1* "# "&1$ * $& * *&1& 1 )*& * *&1

"  1- $%*7 "#  "  1 03 )%#&1 1  0*"   - "  ! 7!*

*  "#7 )*& * *&1 "  1 * $& * *&% 1$*

)!$33!1( 7!* *  ()$7!*  $33!  &! +.' )*& * *&1 

&%  "  1 * $& * *&% 1$* )!$33!1 "# & *0

#*&&" &*+"!&*$"*$*&% 0"  2"!&*(



 & *& 1 10"1*75! 6#8

$3* 9 !01  %* &  ! &11

" 1%*"(1 3# 17"#  

?+'2 ."!&*#*&1

)%#&1 "0*" ""  "(



* 1"# *7-" &"#  3*#$& "  ""&1&*&

!01 

?+'+.3 0%*7"# #  "*&1"

$33! " " #50*01 $& "  1  7 " (  (  03 $%* 

 &"

" "$& "  &!*%*0+'2"!&*#*&1"   $$."!&*-

""" $& "  2"!&*(



# &*">