Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-10-14998/5 AI generated

2-10-14998/5 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus

Case Number 2-10-14998/5
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

709 (#  (& (# "&#1 ( "-" ("#$ '-$#$" ! ")  %5! -(( #$ $"   5"""()")  " 7"$ *9. ("1  ) . " # ( "- ("#$ )55'"#1 "5"-  '-$#$"! ".(&("#$# " $-(" # '#$11+ ( "-!"3'-$#  ! "#  ("#$-&#1 7"$9+   "!$" =$!3'-$1!-%-&1!( !5$--5""( "- !"#$ %&! "(" #  ". $"#)"&& "+  =$.0( $".#( "-!"3("#$ ""#1!$1#  -&#1 . '#$13(# + # !")&(& ""#1("#$!$1#  .!" !$1#  "()# + # ( "- !$13   !")  ("#$ $)&"$#  . $&13 (#   -("# "#&"%1)"+  =0$( $"%(($>"$  -($#(" ""#1!51!-"&1) ".# ! " %(($ !"3 $$ () + ) !"" (& >"$  !5" "&)# "" - $ &$& &# "#)&("#$1' '"#1'-$# !$1#  +  (# $3."##$#3 =10$4$.0$# $ (  ( "- !"# '#$1) $.'! "1 ("#%(($" ""#1# $%-&1# +  !$1# ( $" $)"+)5'" $%(($"!$$%&.)$$ ( "-"#&& "  () !$&!# " -$ ##'#   ?.  '((&+ )""#1 $%&# !""  ( "- &1$(# "# !$$!1')  )5'$" #1$" )5'"  "##$ $"## 8)&&1 ##%5! $  ##$ "$())#&$) "$,,,,,02,,,,  " - $$$ ##$ " #) $ ##$#!$ &"' ) $ $   ? '((& && ) " &"' !$ #))- $$$##$ $"$ &1#!"())#&$) "-55$" ##'#   .2 ; %5! + (($)" ('1#!" " )$1"#$"# " " %($ ( "- $"    " &(!)3'## ""( "&#18") "-(& $$ ""#$&!$"$%&#"&)# ($#$ $" '#&#1+ %&#"&)# " ('1#! '#)  """# (" # "  - !$ #)). $ &1#&#1 &"' ) ". ())#&$) " && $%%"'!  &#1)   %<<'1#1 ("# %(($ - "  + )5'" $  ( "-$ ! "!  #$  '-+ $  -($#1$ "  /,,,, && !'+ ++! "#.0'((&&#1 . )$$ "!$ #))(&.2'((&." #)"&"' ) 1(&*.*'((&- $%%"'!'((&&&!5$-) "( "-$"%(($"!$  "$%&# ""#$&!!!  %&#1$" ##'#   .2; %5!  $"  5 ($!  ") $ -5'&! " %5! " #& %&#1 "5$# " #) &+ - (& () &#1 %-&1)   ("#$  "&#1%(($"!$ $)"#1$%&#.((&1())#&$) "'! "# -" #)  ("&&'-( "-$7"$2.*.9+  @=1*2$44$%.2( $""#$3(# "# "5"! "!$"$%&#$. # -##'  (# "#  '#)& (& !$ #"  "#$&! (# "#  "5")" -5")& ! )""(& "5")&. $#$  "5")  !!")&+ # !$& (& (# "# " '#&#1. !3 !$# $1- &#1 (# "#  "5") " - '$  (# "#  "5")  !!")  (''$ &#1 !! "+  "!$" @ = ? $  (& $%%"'! $%&#  ""&5"#1 $%&#" '#&#1 $%&#%(($ (# "#  ) " -# ""#1 $%&#%(($$ $%&# )55'"#1' #))+  $ -($#1$(# $3."-&#!$&!# !5$-) ")  (&!$1#   "((1#1 -($#1# $#$"%-&1"#1&& (  ( "- !"###$#3 =$$# $'#$1) $-( "-$""#$3- # !5$-) ".

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-10-14998/5 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus: 709 (#  (& (# "&#1 ( "-" ("#$ '-$#$" ! ")  %5! -(( #$ $"   5"""()")  " 7"$ *9. ("1  ) . " # ( "- ("#$ )55'"#1 "5"-  '-$#$"! ".(&("#$# " $-(" # '#$11+ ( "-!"3'-$#  ! "#  ("#$-&#1 7"$9+   "!$" =$!3'-$1!-%-&1!( !5$--5""( "- !"#$ %&! "(" #  ". $"#)"&& "+  =$.0( $".#( "-!"3("#$ ""#1!$1#  -&#1 . '#$13(# + # !")&(& ""#1("#$!$1#  .!" !$1#  "()# + # ( "- !$13   !")  ("#$ $)&"$#  . $&13 (#   -("# "#&"%1)"+  =0$( $"%(($>"$  -($#(" ""#1!51!-"&1) ".# ! " %(($ !"3 $$ () + ) !"" (& >"$  !5" "&)# "" - $ &$& &# "#)&("#$1' '"#1'-$# !$1#  +  (# $3."##$#3 =10$4$.0$# $ (  ( "- !"# '#$1) $.'! "1 ("#%(($" ""#1# $%-&1# +  !$1# ( $" $)"+)5'" $%(($"!$$%&.)$$ ( "-"#&& "  () !$&!# " -$ ##'#   ?.  '((&+ )""#1 $%&# !""  ( "- &1$(# "# !$$!1')  )5'$" #1$" )5'"  "##$ $"## 8)&&1 ##%5! $  ##$ "$())#&$) "$,,,,,02,,,,  " - $$$ ##$ " #) $ ##$#!$ &"' ) $ $   ? '((& && ) " &"' !$ #))- $$$##$ $"$ &1#!"())#&$) "-55$" ##'#   .2 ; %5! + (($)" ('1#!" " )$1"#$"# " " %($ ( "- $"    " &(!)3'## ""( "&#18") "-(& $$ ""#$&!$"$%&#"&)# ($#$ $" '#&#1+ %&#"&)# " ('1#! '#)  """# (" # "  - !$ #)). $ &1#&#1 &"' ) ". ())#&$) " && $%%"'!  &#1)   %<<'1#1 ("# %(($ - "  + )5'" $  ( "-$ ! "!  #$  '-+ $  -($#1$ "  /,,,, && !'+ ++! "#.0'((&&#1 . )$$ "!$ #))(&.2'((&." #)"&"' ) 1(&*.*'((&- $%%"'!'((&&&!5$-) "( "-$"%(($"!$  "$%&# ""#$&!!!  %&#1$" ##'#   .2; %5!  $"  5 ($!  ") $ -5'&! " %5! " #& %&#1 "5$# " #) &+ - (& () &#1 %-&1)   ("#$  "&#1%(($"!$ $)"#1$%&#.((&1())#&$) "'! "# -" #)  ("&&'-( "-$7"$2.*.9+  @=1*2$44$%.2( $""#$3(# "# "5"! "!$"$%&#$. # -##'  (# "#  '#)& (& !$ #"  "#$&! (# "#  "5")" -5")& ! )""(& "5")&. $#$  "5")  !!")&+ # !$& (& (# "# " '#&#1. !3 !$# $1- &#1 (# "#  "5") " - '$  (# "#  "5")  !!")  (''$ &#1 !! "+  "!$" @ = ? $  (& $%%"'! $%&#  ""&5"#1 $%&#" '#&#1 $%&#%(($ (# "#  ) " -# ""#1 $%&#%(($$ $%&# )55'"#1' #))+  $ -($#1$(# $3."-&#!$&!# !5$-) ")  (&!$1#   "((1#1 -($#1# $#$"%-&1"#1&& (  ( "- !"###$#3 =$$# $'#$1) $-( "-$""#$3- # !5$-) ".

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text







      !"#$%&!   '"#(#    (()"&&                 *+%'$$,,,,("#)-.'-$$)&"$#                   

/ ,,,, && !'  +  + +  ! "# . 0 '((&&#1 + .2'((&           - / ,,,, && !'. ' "'((1 ,,,,,,,,.  #("31# ,,,,$&&4 ( "-+ ++. #((1,,,,,,,,,,,.$#(",,,,, 02,,,,+   

/,,,, && !'+ ++! "#+ 5$-) "+ ++6$" /,,,, && !' # 7&$8))&18 "#"   1 " "9'((&-0 &"+ 5$-) "+ ++:$" /,,,, && !' # !! .2;%5! %&#1$". (.2'((&$"$" 0+)5'"  "#&%&#1"5") &+ #&& "1("#(" # "" "!!")""51"! +     

/,,,, && !')&"$# #$#1-5""+ ++&1+ 5$-) "+ ++:$" /,,,, && !' # )&"$# #$#27## "#"9 '((&+  

     ("#(" #  %$ !3 0 %5! -(( #$. $"  (" #  5"""()")  ". #1 )"" $-) # ! ## )<<1#) $ (" #  !$#$" ""! ")  ".  "1 %$$" ((&3#  '"# &(&&("#$+ %$$" ((&3#  !1  $&11 '-$# )&"$#  .#3#  "("$" $$$&1) " "#&$+    !""# "$" #% "# &'# &$##%#$(## 

709 (#  (& (# "&#1 ( "-" ("#$ '-$#$" ! ")  %5! -(( #$ $"   5"""()")  " 7"$ *9. ("1  ) . " # ( "- ("#$ )55'"#1 "5"-  '-$#$"! ".(&("#$# " $-(" # '#$11+ ( "-!"3'-$#  ! "#  ("#$-&#1 7"$9+   "!$" =$!3'-$1!-%-&1!( !5$--5""( "- !"#$ %&! "(" #  ". $"#)"&& "+  =$.0( $".#( "-!"3("#$ ""#1!$1#  -&#1 . '#$13(# + # !")&(& ""#1("#$!$1#  .!" !$1#  "()# + # ( "- !$13   !")  ("#$ $)&"$#  . $&13 (#   -("# "#&"%1)"+  =0$( $"%(($>"$  -($#(" ""#1!51!-"&1) ".# ! " %(($ !"3 $$ () + ) !"" (& >"$  !5" "&)# "" - $ &$& &# "#)&("#$1' '"#1'-$# !$1#  +  (# $3."##$#3 =10$4$.0$# $ (  ( "- !"# '#$1) $.'! "1 ("#%(($" ""#1# $%-&1# +  !$1# ( $" $)"+)5'" $%(($"!$$%&.)$$ ( "-"#&& "  () !$&!# " -$ ##'#   ?.  '((&+ )""#1 $%&# !""  ( "- &1$(# "# !$$!1')  )5'$" #1$" )5'"  "##$ $"## 8)&&1 ##%5! $  ##$ "$())#&$) "$,,,,,02,,,,  " - $$$ ##$ " #) $ ##$#!$ &"' ) $ $   ? '((& && ) " &"' !$ #))- $$$##$ $"$ &1#!"())#&$) "-55$" ##'#   .2 ; %5! + (($)" ('1#!" " )$1"#$"# " " %($ ( "- $"    " &(!)3'## ""( "&#18") "-(& $$ ""#$&!$"$%&#"&)# ($#$ $" '#&#1+ %&#"&)# " ('1#! '#)  """# (" # "  - !$ #)). $ &1#&#1 &"' ) ". ())#&$) " && $%%"'!  &#1)   %<<'1#1 ("# %(($ - "  + )5'" $  ( "-$ ! "!  #$  '-+ $  -($#1$ "  /,,,, && !'+ ++! "#.0'((&&#1 . )$$ "!$ #))(&.2'((&." #)"&"' ) 1(&*.*'((&- $%%"'!'((&&&!5$-) "( "-$"%(($"!$  "$%&# ""#$&!!!  %&#1$" ##'#   .2; %5!  $"  5 ($!  ") $ -5'&! " %5! " #& %&#1 "5$# " #) &+ - (& () &#1 %-&1)   ("#$  "&#1%(($"!$ $)"#1$%&#.((&1())#&$) "'! "# -" #)  ("&&'-( "-$7"$2.*.9+  @=1*2$44$%.2( $""#$3(# "# "5"! "!$"$%&#$. # -##'  (# "#  '#)& (& !$ #"  "#$&! (# "#  "5")" -5")& ! )""(& "5")&. $#$  "5")  !!")&+ # !$& (& (# "# " '#&#1. !3 !$# $1- &#1 (# "#  "5") " - '$  (# "#  "5")  !!")  (''$ &#1 !! "+  "!$" @ = ? $  (& $%%"'! $%&#  ""&5"#1 $%&#" '#&#1 $%&#%(($ (# "#  ) " -# ""#1 $%&#%(($$ $%&# )55'"#1' #))+  $ -($#1$(# $3."-&#!$&!# !5$-) ")  (&!$1#   "((1#1 -($#1# $#$"%-&1"#1&& (  ( "- !"###$#3 =$$# $'#$1) $-( "-$""#$3- # !5$-) ".

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