Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-09-63459/4 AI generated

2-09-63459/4 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus

Case Number 2-09-63459/4
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-09-63459/4 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

         

        !"  

#"$!%"   !!&'((                 )*#+,----$!%"& .$+# +$&("                ,$#!!(+      /"+("($! 0%+ ) )1"2,$#!!(+('"3)         

"$!%/' +((.+(3  #1!1. 044#3+ !"+!(5 $!  )

   #%"33/"+("($! 0%+ ) )1") 7 &'+ ) )/"+("($! 0$"$2,8$$"%+36%$+9 $#!!(+) 7 &'+ ) )/"+("($! 0$"$1++1+., :+&$&+1++1+"3 *71  *'%+('"3. ! ,  $#!!(+  )(!1&;#+  $"(+ *'%+('"3 7+&+(+)

"((+3$!%"!"+1++1+&7+31$)      /"+("($! 0&("$""3 7 ) )$(3) 7 &'+ ) )/"+("($! 0 $"$&("$"" 8$$"%1++39 $#!!(+)

7!1 !" '""&+  $"(+ 7+&+(+ "; )  )   "3 &("$"" 1++1+<=,,,+"(7%"3"")  

     /"+(" ($! 0 1'+; +3 *+!!($;"  *71 !!$".  !" $7!+&&+. $"+3 &+ %+ & $"+ 1++ $"" &>>3"&+ #" $!%" !" 1+$" 1$ &+. #" +($!(($!%". $" ""# $;" 1'+3$

89 %(33$+# +$"&(".$"+$;"+!%(3&++"(+)

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

!%" !( $!%"("3 $!  $!%" $+# +$" 1& , *71 !!$"  %+ $7!+&&+ 8 ,9. %!+3 &.  $"+ $!  $!%" &77#"3 7% $ $+# +$"+1.!($!%"'+"%+ !"#%"33)  +13" $!!  +3  &77#" $+# +$" 1" (3&+ $!%"" !( $! $7!+&"3 =,7"3$!##@)&7#+,89)!( $!  3+$ $ 1"(3&+$!%"") ! .$$!%"!( &77#("3$+# +$" 1&+7% .+!7%$!%"$+# +$"1("3) 

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

=@,*$!%"((+;$!%"!&"+1++1+&7+31$  !") 

=,,$!%$((;%+&("$""3*!!.$$% "$!"%+) !%". #%"33%+. 7; =,,"&("$""3$! $(3)  1 =,2,&77#;$!%"% !" !"$+(3$$$!  %61+13&("$""3.$"+% +;$!%"&77#"3 $&("$""3(+&$+# )   !( !("3 $!  17  &'+ &("$""( %+13" +&+ ""3 #+++'+1,$#!!(+(+(+(3 &$"3"'+";+, $#!!(+)  !; $!  &("$""3 ""#" $+(3$1 %(3+ '""&+ $"(+ 7+&+(+ &("$""3 1++1+ "&+ < = ,,  , (7%"3 "")   !( +("3 &("$""3(+&$+#  &("$""+3'(3133!$"&(3+38@9 

=3,@,.$!%!(&("$""3&("!+$!%"$""3 $!%"17+3 $""3. $" ""# $!%"$""3 !( #+++'+1. $" !( (+(   7;+1&+ $""3) 1

=,*,.";#+++'+1""3%+(+(#+++'+1"""#"'";+1++  %+((.$"+3"+!(7%"3+++)!!3"#13";$! % $"$ 17  &'+ %+%+(3 #13 &("$""( #+++'+1 %+13" +&+ ,  $#!!(+)  1 =,*,!($!%"17+3$""3&("!++(3  ('" $""3)

=,2 ,.$!%.$"+&("!+(*;&("$""3 !"$+(3$&77#1 $!%"%(3+ $!% $(3& + &("!+ +(3("3 *+("+ +(3  $""3. &'+; $!%" $""3 17  *'% (3"3  1 +$" "". $" ""# ;#+++ +"

89 $%; *+("+ +(3  $""3 + &("!+ +('"3&+ *++#&77#3) ;#++++")*&;#+@&77#"(#,2*+("++(3  ('" $""3 +&("!++('"3&+*++#&77#3$!%!(+1++ %+(($"(+, $#!!(+&$+&+('"1$"" $#!!(+)  !!3" 7%"3 (+( $"( $!  + ! %  +(3  &("$""3 1"17++3 +("3!;$!%" =,2 ", $#!!(+% +(3 *'% (3"$ 1 +$"$ $""$) 

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

!%"(+$?