Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-10-7359/4 AI generated

2-10-7359/4 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus

Case Number 2-10-7359/4
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-10-7359/4 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

         

        !"  

#"$!%"   !!&'((                 )*#+,,,,$!%"& -$+# +$&("                 .- $#!!(+      / $+0 1+(( %+ )  )  0" 2 - 3 $#!!(+ ('"4)          %  /$+01+((-#+#+$!!4,,,,,,,-"$!% 5' +((-+(4 +0#(#- /5"+("($!6 $! ) )-++$"$!!4,,,,,,,,,,,-"$!%,,,,, ,,,,)    #%"44 /$+01+((%+) )0") 7 &'+) ) /$+01+(($"$2 8(+"%+49%$$9&&(4 $$:$#!!(+ 3(+) 7  &'+ )  )  / $+0 1+(( $"$ 0++0+ -  ; *70 "& *'%+('"4-! .- $#!!(+)0<#"#+$"(+*'%+('"47+&+(+)

"((+4$!%"!"+0++0+&7+40$)      /$+01+((&("$""4 7) )$(4) 7 &'+) ) /$+01+(($"$&("$""8$!&"%+4 0++$9&&(4:$#!!(+)

7!0 !" '""&+$"(+7+&+(+"<) )"4&("$"" 0++0+=>+"(7%"4"""&"&&)  

     / $+0 1+(( 0'+< +4 *+!!($<"  *70 !!$"-  !" $7!+&&+- $"+4 &+ %+ & $"+ 0++ $"" &??4"&+ #" $!%" !" 0+$" 0$ &+- #" +($!(($!%"- $" ""# $<" 0'+4$ %(44$+# +$"&("-$"+$<"+!%(4&++"(+) ) )0'+<+4 #"$!%",,,,$!%"&  !"*$ -$"+&

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

!%" !( $!%"("4 $!  $!%" $+# +$" 0& 2 *70 !!$"  %+ $7!+&&+ 8 . :- %!+4 &-  $"+ $!  $!%" &77#"4 7% $ $+# +$"+0-!($!%"'+"%+ !"#%"44)  +04"$!!+4 &77#"$+# +$"0"(4&+$!%""!($!  $7!+&"4  >    7"4 $!## )&7#+  82:) !( $!  4+$$0"(4&+$!%"") ! -$$!%"!(&77#("4$+# +$"0&+ 7% -+!7%$!%"$+# +$"0("4) 

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

>2" !"&+)+ !"4$"""<%+ >2 $!% !"#%"4&+(+($! "<% $"$07 &'+2 - 3$#!!(+ #04 >.7"0++0+-;*70"&*'%+('"4-!  .- $#!!(+%++&+-!)0<#"#+$"(+*'%+('"47+&+(+) 

>2.3*$!%"((+<$!%"!&"+0++0+&7+40$  !") 

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

>43-$!%!(&("$""4&("!+$!%"$""4 $!%"07+4 $""4- $" ""# $!%"$""4 !( #+++'+0- $" !( (+(   7<+0&+ $""4) 0

> *-"<#+++'+0""4%+(+(#+++'+0"""#"'"<+0++  %+((-$"+4"+!(7%"4+++)0 >22*!($!%"07+$

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

>"$#!!(+% +(4 *'% (4"$ 0 +$"$$""$)  + !"4$!%"+<-$"($!%"!" 7+% &("$""$! $(4(+( #04 >27"0'+<$!%"% !" !"$+(4$ &77# $ $!  %90+04 &("$""4- $!  + ! &("$""4 ""#" 0"07++4 +("4- "< $!  )  )  07  &'+ / $+0 1+(( $"$ &("$""(#+++'+0$#!!(+ % +(4 $"""&&$#!!(+-$!$$"  &("$""   $#!!(+) !  "<  !" '""&+ $"(+ 7+&+(+ "4  &("$"" 0++0+ = >    + " (7%"4 "" "& "&&)    

!%"(+$@