Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-09-67781/5 AI generated

2-09-67781/5 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus

Case Number 2-09-67781/5
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-09-67781/5 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

          

        !"  

#"$!%"   !!&'((                 )*+#, ----$!%"& .$,# ,$&("                    / !0",,,(%,**1"2 $#!!(,('"0 2$#!!(,          %  /

3!,4 +".,(0 #,$("5

   #%"00 / !0",,,(%,**1"* 7 &',** / !0",,,($"$2 8,"%1,,06$9$#!!(,*

"((,0$!%"!",1,,1,&7,01$*      / !0",,,(&("$""0 7**$(0* 7 &',** / !0",,,($"$&("$"" 86$"%9$#!!(,*  

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

 849 $7 !,&0 17 +!! ,  :#,,$, 1', 1,$" 1$&,. 1',: $  ,0 !" $7!,&&,   +71 !!$"* ",  !" %, &(" '".  $!  , 1("0 7% $!%" 1', , ,&"("0 ,"(,. ": $  ,0 $',$   1&,&, '+"1,,&,$ 1 ,$* (":,!&,+:&(":,! 0"7"07%  7#,&,$ & 7%  $ $ &("!,&,(". &, &,$  &(":, !:. $',,&$ 8 = 9*    !""# "$" #% "# &'# &$##%#$(## 

!%" !( $!%"("0 $!  $!%" $,# ,$" 1& ) +71 !!$"  %, $7!,&&, 8  49 %!,0 &.  $", $!  $!%" &77#"0 7% $ $,# ,$",1.!($!%"',"%, !"#%"00  ,10" $!!  ,0  &77#" $,# ,$" 1" (0&, $!%"" !( $! ,,$,$"$7!,&"0)*&7#, 84 9*!($! 0,$$1" (0&, $!%""* ! . $ $!%" !( &77#("0 $,# ,$" 1&, 7% . , ! 7%$!%"$,# ,$"1("0* 

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

=) +$!%"((,:$!%"!&",1,,1,&7,01$  !"*, !"0$!%""((,: =) +" !"!& ",1,,1,&7,01$* 

=  $!%$((:%,&("$""0+!!.$$% "$!"%,* !%". #%"00%,. 7: =  "&("$""0$! $(0*  1 = ) 4&77#:$!%"% !" !"$,(0$$$!  %61,10&("$""0.$",% ,:$!%"&77#"0 $&("$""0(,&$,# . $" ""#  =   ) $!% , $!%0  =    4 7". $", &("$""0&77#$$,(0$ = ) 7"0$!##*   !(!("0$! 17 &',%,10",&,""0#,,,',1 $#!!(,* 

=0 4 .$!%!(&("$""0&("!,$!%"$""0 $!%"17,0 $""0.$" ""#$!%"$""0!(#,,,',1.$" !((,( 7:,1&,$""0*  +!! $("0&("$""!(%,10",&,11 =0 44 ..=2 %,%,((""0#,,,',1 $#!!(,*  , !"0$!%",:.$"($!%"!" 7,% &("$""$! $(0(,( #10 = ) 47"1',:$!%"% !" !"$,(0$ &77#$$! %61,10&("$""0.":$! **17 &', / !0",,,( $"$&("$""(#,,,',1%,10",&,"&& $#!!(,*   

!%"(,$<