Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-09-71228/5 AI generated

2-09-71228/5 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus

Case Number 2-09-71228/5
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

#  #6 36+"+++ 3&+ #!+   +%+ #6 3+#!)  !$!  # $

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-09-71228/5 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus: #  #6 36+"+++ 3&+ #!+   +%+ #6 3+#!)  !$!  # $

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text















  



 

 

 !





"!# $!





 %&''

 













    







()*"+,,,,# $!%-#+"+#%'!

  



 

  



 





.-/#" '+



   

 012'# +++' $+ )  )  3! - 

#" '++'1!33++3+'&!1)

 

    





$  012'# +++'- "+"+# 1 ,,,,,,,,-

!# $++3+ +''-+'1 +"+ %!4

# ))-++#!# 1,,,,,,,,,,,,-!# $,,,,,

.5,,,,)

  

"$!11012'#+++'$+))3!)

6 %&+ )  )   012'# +++' #!#   78#+ !$ #$#1

8$##8%%'1+9#" '+'+)

6 %&+ )  )   012'# +++' #!# 3++3+ *&$+'&!1-   .- /

#" '+.)1%2"+ #!'+*&$+'&!16+%+'+:;.6!1

%66"7 !" * #*'+'"+%66"<=9-#!+1%+" $#%#!+.-

/#" '+)

!''+1# $! !+3++3+%6+13#)

 

 



012'#+++'%'!#!!16))#'1)

6 %&+ )  )   012'# +++' #!# %'!#!! . / 7# % !$

##13++#8%%'19#" '+)

6 3 !&!!%+#!'+6+%+'+!2)) !1%'!#!!

3++3+ : ; .   + ! '6$!1 !!- #!+1 %+ " $#% #!+ . /

#" '+)







  



 012'# +++' 3&+2 +1 *+ '#2! . *63  #!-  !

#6 +%%+- #!+1 %+ $+% #!+ 3++ #!! %>>1!%+ "! # $! !



7(9

3+#! 3# %+- "! +'# ''# $!- #!!!" #2! 3&+1#

$'11#+"+#!%'!-#!+#2!+ $'1%++!'+)

) ) 3&+2 +1 "! # $!,,,,# $!% !*#-#!+

% 3!!- %+ +  ! %+ !#- + +'+!1 %&!3

*&$!)  3&+2 +1 &!% %&!3 *&$! % !- #!+? 9 $+

3%6%+*!$! +$+#  +%!1#6%!!3+++#!+++#+#!#+"

3!8'1%+49# $!+!'++%!%6%+*!$! +# $!#! +%!1

#  3&+ % +'1 #6 +++ #!+ ++#+#! #+" 3! 8'1%+ 3&+

# $!+!'+4 .9  ! + 3&+'!1 1! # $ $)  3&+2 +1

 !#6 +%%+(*63 #!'+'#!+ !!2

#6  +%1 36*  +  2"++#+ 3&+ 3+#! 3#%+- 3&+2 #

+1 ! #6 +%%+   *63  #!) !+  ! $+

%'! &!-  #  + 3'!1 6$ # $! 3&+ + +%!'!1

+!'+- !2 # +1 #&+#  3%+%+ &*!3++%+# 3+#)

'!2+ %+*2%'!2+ 1!6!16$6"+%+#

% 6$ # # %'! +%+'!- %+ %+#  %'!2+  2-

#&++%#7 ;59)



 

!""#

"$" #%

"#

&'#

&$##%#$(##



$! ' # $!'!1 #  # $! #+"+#! 3% ( *63  #!  $+

#6 +%%+ 7 /9- $ +1 %-  #!+ #  # $! %66"!1 6$#

#+"+#!+3- '# $!&+!$+ !"$!11)



+31! #   +1  %66"! #+"+#! 3! '1%+ # $!! '

#  ++#+#! #6 +%!1 /)32"!"+  7 .(9)  ' #  1+# #

3! '1%+ # $!!) - # # $! ' %66"'!1 #+"+#! 3%+

6$-+ 6$# $!#+"+#!3'!1)



;(-.# $3&+2# $!$ !$+ !"$!11

$+31!%6"+!1 !1&+!+#!*&$'1!1!!-#!+# -#

# $! '%66"'!13%+6$-+ 6$3'!1-++#!+$+ +%+

#  #6 36+"+++ 3&+ #!+   +%+ #6 3+#!)  !$!  # $

+!1@#++136+1# *  %#3&!#'+' !3&+2!$!$

# $!+!'+ *+1%) $! +2-  + +' # ++  ; (  / %6"+!1

 !%+36+3+1 !+1)



+  !1 # $! +2-  $+ ' $+31! %6"+!1 !!   !1

&+!+#! *&$'1!1 '+' # $! $'12  ; (  -  .-  / 6!

"31 !) ;((((6+1"31+2# $! !

*&$'13 8#'&+!+#!*&$'1!)



+31!# $&%++1'+)))5)6"%#!%88+*+'!-

%+ # $ %88 %88 #  #!2- #   # $!!   *+'!

%#6$*631#!%012'#+++'#!+@# "+)*+'!81+'+%!

* () ()/ # $ +#  # $!!!1$#!!%#+1'+'$&+!

'&!1 #  %# 6++##!  6$ !%+) *+'!# $ + %#

!%+ 6$*631 + #!! /)#!!*63  3++% %# 6$*63 /)5))

'"+%66" +/-=) +6+'!1 %*+'!++# $!!+'&!# $)



.7(9

 8 *+'! 8 ().)) +! )) ' #  *+'! !'3

3&'3! # ##! -  #" '+- %+ *&$+  3&'3! ' .- / #" '+ 

+'"+3&'3!/5-.#" '+)+ !1 2012'#+++'$+))

3!36%&+-#" '+3++3+*&$+ 3&'3!- .-/#" '+

.)1%2"+#!'+*&$+'&!16+%+'+:;.6!1%66"7

 A+'"<=-$#%66"-=*639)



 '$+31!&+!+#!*&$'1'!1$+%6"+!1 !+1-3++1:

;14.454(44*-54.44.4/5-

%+1# $# $!!2@# "*+'!8#++#7@# "+'!#+'9 3!%+

++#! 7@# "9 "$+ '&!1 # %'1 ++#! 7 @# "3&'+#!9 3!- %+ !'2

*+'!- %+ ! @# "+'! #+' %882 @# "3&'+#! % %'1! 3&+

#!3! % 3&+ !2 '!- @# "  # $!!2 !% '&!1  

#'1%'&!16+%6%+"+++# )*+' '*+'!* 6+%+## $!!+#-

#!!!"*+'!* # $!!13&+31 #+'1#%66"!1*+'!3&+6!1

1!) $!! !2 6+ 33 *+'! 3&+ 1! '+'- #!+ 3&'+# '

# $!! "+##!'!1- 3&+2 3&!1 '&!1 # $!! 6+%+  "$+ # $!!

6+%+ 3++3+%+ # "" '&!1 3++3+) 3 : ; .   3&+2 "$+

# $!! 6+%+ 3++3+%+ # "" 3&!1 '&!1 3&'+#! 3++3+!+'"+

73++3+9- "3 # $!! +'&!3# %!!!%+ #!'+ # $ 6+%+'+) ++3+

%66"#  # : ; ( 6!1 +'"+%66"- %+ +'1!2 + *" '+

) !+ *+'! '  '6$!1 #&"% +'"+%66" #!+ 1!6"' 3++3+%66"-

 #3++3+%66"#*+'!'6$!1+'"+%66")



 '$+$+31!%6"+!1!! !1&+!+#!*&$'1!1'+'

$ *  +!1 @#++1 36+1 !2 !1 #  *  %#3&!#) +

 !1 #!!!2 $+  ; (   # $  ! "$!1%+ '+'

#  !2 $ #!# 36 %&+ 3&'3! -  #" '+ '+' "31

;.56!3++3+*&$+'&!1- .-/#" '+.)1%2"+

#!'+ *&$+'&!1 6+%+'+ : ; .   6!1 %66" 7  !" * #*'

+'"+%66"<=9-#!+1%+" $#%#!+*&$+'&!1- .-/#" '+!!)



 ; (5   *  # $ !''+2 # $! % ! + 3++3+%

6+13# !)



;5# $#''2$+%'!#!!1* -##$!# !$+)

$!-"$!11$+-62 ;5!%'!#!!1# #'1)



3 ;( .%66"2# $!$ ! !#+'1##

# $83+31%'!#!!1-#!+$+2# $!%66"!1#%'!#!!1

'+%#+")  '  '!1 %66"  ! #+'1# #  $83+31

%'!#!!1)  2# 36%&+%'!#!!1!%%./#" '+-

%+ # '2 $+31! +%+  !!1 "+++&+3! . #" '+  %##6!

#++"%'! 31! +%+ !!1 "+++&+3! / #" '+)  ' +'!1

%'!#!!+1&'1311 #!%'1+17-9)



 ;1 .  -  # $ ' %'!#!!1 %'! + # $!#!!1 

# $!36+1 #!!1- #!!!" "+++&+3 ' # $!#!!) 3  ; (( *  '

# $!36+##!!#%##6!#++"%'!#!!1!$!-#!+%##6!#++"%'!

31!6+%66"!"$!1% ;(.*.!-36"3!1-#!+$+ '



(7(9

%'&!1+!1$+%#!+8##!!*6"#++"%'!&!) 1!"31

!2# 36%&+$%'!#!!'"+++&+3# ##!./#" '+)  '

 '!1 36 %&+ 3++3+ %'!#!!1  # $!$'1+ &!!%+ #!'+

6+%+'+:;.6!1%66")



;# $%6"+2# $!%'!#!!1#+'1#%66"%+ '!1++#!

31! ! %'!#!!1 #+'1#%66"%+ $'1+-  $83+%+ #!!!3

%'!#!!1!2!1%'!#!!1!!"!#+'1#3$'1+&!!%+

#!'+6+%+'+3++3+:;.+!'6$!1!!)



+ !1# $!+2-#!'# $! !6+$%'!#!!# #'1

'+'"31 ;(.6!3&+2# $!$ ! !

#+'1#%66"## $83+31%'!#!!1-!2# ))36%&+

 012'# +++' #!# %'!#!! . / #" '+)  !2  !

&!!%+#!'+6+%+'+!1%'!#!!3++3+:;.+!

'6$!1!!-#!+1%+" $#%#!+./#" '+)









$!'+#?