Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-09-48917/6 AI generated

2-09-48917/6 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Põlvas

Case Number 2-09-48917/6
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

!9;7 ))::3937")3 33+ DC 2;0  2 *8  *33 ) (88  ) + ') (''3) +   3 # ## 9 3* ::#)7 83  ) )  )::+      ) 3*'3(+(38 3 )  (''3) #) * ) )"  3+  ( %=('(88*)'*(3* *(''3))')))*83"  +8(*3)(')3'3(88 )88) 83 * "  * # ) (8   : '3 3" & (   (3  :+  ) 3 '3 F3 ; )8 $00    #  ::)  (" *  E3 (3 '3 ):: ) " * (8 (3 '3 ))  3 " *  ) (8 '3) 3  3 B $!"%!"$%%-"" )33 9#3  /%,/ 7+ )  '3 F3 ; )8$00)3>>3)) 2%!$2+/.+(3)) -.;20+(8()))$ 200+/.9)33(33 $.;!2/+;/ 7" (3 )3>>3 3( )) (' '3 * +'3)(8" )3>>33())* '3 )::3  )3(3 2$;!2/+;/ "  ('3 3 # *8 ( *88))  2/$%-;+2- +  ) : :  (+ 33#*8(*88))3('3(88* (88:C;!)'"83*#3(83((88+ '3 )3*  # '3 )3) * ) 3  )   3 #*8(*88))"3#33"8(* (3 '3  (88 3) () *8+  )  3 ( '3" )    '3  ) ):: 3 (8 '3 '" 3 *+ ) ( (88(83'*(8(+ (3 '3 (88  /%%%% + )   )::3"    ( #*8*88(88*((88(2/$%-;+2-,;00-;+; 9 ()::3)8)72 .$--+0/+)** DC 2;0 (8*)'"  ) (8*'3)3  * )::3+ )  #'*3 # ::)+(3 DC2;0.83" 8*'3)32!.% '3B ""%2"$%%0""(*9.07+)8((*3: '39)8$007(8*'3)2!.%"::3 //2. '3B"%$"%0"$%%-""(*9.!7"*3(83)::, * ( (8*'3)3  )'  "    * # )3 3 D2;0.*(8*)'"  3 ) (3 9 #  -7 8(  3('*  " 1" " '3  F3 ; @ $+2    () 3 ) #8( 3 %0"%0"$%%-""*3()3)#8($-"%;"$%%-"")

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-09-48917/6 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Põlvas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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

             

                !"#$% %""&'()*+&'( ' $  

   $,%-,./- 0  

  "1"""&".!2/%2 '3  

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

$9;7 )33#'*3)('8*#3))8"     !    (3  ')3 * * * 0"%!"$%%0"" # " $%%0$//0" # )  (  ?@  ; @ $+2  + ))8 $00+ 8 <? $2;0 ;/! 2/ 93#3 (7"  *  # :3)+ *8 8 ) # (3 )3+  : * # ;"% "$%%/"" :    *+ : 3 * ) # ::)  3 ) # ) ( ('())!/// +0;"#*8(*88(88# ::)2/$%-;+2-)8)" ,"1""((''33 /%%%%   8)"  ( # *8 *88(88 * ( (88(2/$%-;+2-,;00-;+; 9()::3)8)7A

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

29;7  3  (') 3 )) #) " #  ('*:()3*3+)3()(3"  !# !    +8(*33*)(C,.%2 "

)  83+  # ' (' * 33 3  )" *  * (3 (8*33 ) ' * 3) * )"* !" $"$%%-""(3)'*3) * )"   /"%2"$% %"" # (3 * 3) * ) * 3 # (  3 ) 83(3 3  *) 2%"%2"$% %"" &3 )3 83(3   3  + )'  3 * )('3"  +#'*33*3)" 

D C 2;   #  3* )3) ('* # )883)::*3)97*3)('*+('* ))))" #  )E 9#  %,$.7 '3+  #3 ')3 0"%!"$%%0"" #$%%0$//093#3#7+)*3*3 *('*(3*(, ?@ ;@$+2"# )E 9#  $!,2-7 8+  #3  ')3 ) )  %-"%;"$%%0""))3(#+))33#)( *88(88 # 8* '# * 33 ))   (  #)" (3*+#3##*)3  )3+  83 )  3  %-"%;"$%%0"" *3 #"3+33" &   (3  : *  ( ((')  9  !/7 '3+  * 3 #)3'3%-"%;"$%%0""*:"  #:3)9$-,207#2" ('*)' )33*#3(" (39!%,!07(3+* *(3#())"&((3 :+*#(3#()) '83+)'*:# ;"% "$%%/"":9::)3 !-7"&3(3+#::)''##3" 

D C 2;0     # ::)  # ('* :() 3* ' 3+ )3 3* 3  )+ ' )  *  E) 3  + ) 3   3 * 3 )"  D C 2;0  $  3 3) 8('*##8::)3*883)))+) ( ) # (  * )3 ))3+ )  3 ) )3)3" DC,2;0283+*88#8 # ::) 3* )3+  ) #( '  )3  :() '3  )88) (3 ) (88  3* ) " D C 2;0  .   # ('*  :() 3*::)33+(8*(3*+::)#'*3 3*(3*3"

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

()$-"%."$%%/""*2,$, ,22,%/3+ 3*'3()3 DC2;02*8))::+ (3(88")(88BC;!(88+)

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

((3 $-"%;"$%%-""(*9#./78('3 )8 $00  3 ) #  ( $/"%!"$%%-""  $-"%;"$%%-""  20; " *   3 ((83 3 ) " *33()::#3 DC2;0 .)'*)'20;**(8*"

;9;7  *'*33$./! +-;*()%/"%$"$%%/""G %0"%0"$%%-"" *   * '3  3 ((8"   ' * +   ( '3 ('    (''3)(*3  3" 3 *  '3 3)  *+  *   9( 3 )7 3#3:'3 "'3)'*'*33$./! +-; *83)"    * *  (8* )'   2-!-2 +!.    #) ('(  !/ // +0; + 3 )  20; +  ( )::3  / /2. + ( (8*'3)3  2!.%   ( # *8 *88(88 * (88(2 .$--+0/" 

3)*88*'!0/0 +.;)*8833*() % "%$"$%%/",$!"%;"$%%-""  22 % -+!%  *  3   ( ):: *()%/"%$"$%%/,%0"%0"$%%-""$./! +-;"  C 02 *.*)3(')'#( )88 )3 * ) (" 3 * 8  +)3)3)#3)" *3)88 3)3##*)(" 

(  C,  ;2      3)  (3 #3 )3('33+*)3('33) ('*8)38('#33" 33('33)*833()+# #'*3 )3  *3 ('3  3) "   *  '(3(.$%0/2+!%9*')37+ #  '( # #'*3 *3 ) ((   * '3 3) + )  '( " * '  #) ('(+ 3 )+  )::3+ ( (8*'3)3+ 3 3 * ( # *8 *88(88 *(88 (   33 -. = " '*8-.=*3'(*3*:*88*33" (*'33)(9/0=7*8)3* )3/0=*3**)3 2=*3"  C 0.    (' #  '3 * 33  ) )  )3  3)88) 3 3( 3 *  2% #8( *333*')"