Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-09-59519/4 AI generated

2-09-59519/4 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus

Case Number 2-09-59519/4
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

 ;1 8<  3  3    ) , < "#  2 "#   4* 00 )*& ,

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-09-59519/4 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus:  ;1 8<  3  3    ) , < "#  2 "#   4* 00 )*& ,

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text













   







 





! "# 





$

%&&

 













    







'()!*++++"# $,"*!*"$& 

  



 

  



 





-..-','"!&*



   

/ ++++ *&&*0! #* ( 

(  0     -..-', '

"!&*&% 1(

 

    





# / ++++ *&&*0!, !*!*"1 ++++++++,

 "#21 ++++3

"(

(,**" "1+++++++++++, "#+++++-

++++(

  

!# 11 /++++*&&*0!#*(

(0 (

4 $%* ( 

(  / ++++ *&&*0! " " -. .-' 5&*"6$$&1 "$  #

"$1&*"6$$&1"#"7"!&*'&*(

&&*1"#  *00*$4*10"(

 

 



/++++*&&*0!$& "  14(

("&1(

4$%*(

( /++++*&&*0! " "$& "  85* #017

"!&*(







  



/ ++++ *&&*0! 0%*2 *1 )*&"2  . )40 " ,   

"4*$$*, " *1 $* #*$ " * 0 "  $991 $* !  "#   

0*"  0" $*, !  *&"&&"# , "  ! "2  0%*1"

#&11"*!*" $& ," *"2 *#&1$** &*(

(

(0%*2*1 ! "# ++++"# $ )"," *$

0  ,$** $* ",**&* 1$% 0)%# (

0%*2*1% $$% 0)%# $ ," *:7#*0$4$*) # 

*#*"*$ 1"4$ 0*" ***"*" "*!0 6&1$*37

"# * &* *$ $ 4$* ) #  * "# "  *$ 1 " 0%* $

5.7

*&1 "4 *** " * **"*"  "*! 0  6&1$* 0%* "# * &*3 .7

  * 0%*& 1 1  "# #(  0%*2 *1  

"4*$$*  - )40 "  &*& " *    2 "4 *$1

04) *  2!"* 0%* 0*"  0"$*, 0%*2 " *1  

"4*$$*')40" ( * #*$& % ,

"*0& 14#"# 0%***$ & 1* &*, 2"*1"%*"

 0$*$* %) 0$*" 0*"( & 2* $* )2 $& 2*

1 4 14#4!*$*"$4#""$& *$*& ,

$*$*"$& 2*2,"%**$"5 

;'8<7(





  !""# "$" #% "# &'# &$##%

#$(##



#  & "# & 1 " "#  "*!*"  0$ - )40 "   #*

"4*$$* 5 -7, #*1 $,  " * " "#  $44! 1 4#"

"*!*" *0,&"# %* #* !# 11(



*01  "  *1  $44!  "*!*"  0  &1$* "#   &

"**"*" "4*$ 1.($4!*5.7(

&"1*""0 

&1$* "#  ( , " "#  & $44!& 1 "*!*"  0$* 4#, * 

4#"# "*!*" 0& 1(





 ; -8  , . "# 0%*2 "#  #   #*   !# 11

#*01  $4!* 1   1 %* *"  )%#&1 1  , " * ", "

"#  & $44!& 1 0$* 4#, *  4# 0& 1, ** " * #* *$*

""404*!*0%*" **$*"40*" (

 # "#* 1

="**1 04*1 " ) $"0% " &*&   0%*2   #  #

"# * &* )*1$( #  *2,  * *& " ** 

 ; -8   $4!* 1

 $*04*0*1 *1(



*  1 "#  *2,  #* & #*01  $4!* 1     1

%* *"  )%#&1 1 &*& "#  #&12 

 ; -8  ,  .,   4 

!01 (





;----4*1!01*2"#  )%#&106"&%* *" 

)%#&1 (



*01  "# &*$* ()$2!*  *$ & 1 "!!*$&*" 61"" 

#(& !*.0")!*1*"+++++-$ 0*"""

0*"0* (($*8*$ & 1"!!*$&*"61"" &*$*# *

 ( & !* ' 0" )!*1*" +++++ - $  0*" " "

0*"0* ($2&*$ 1$ "!!*&!#&*& 1

 &0 *" * "  $*" #1 "  1  "$$ &$" !01, $*1

"  8   &* !0 "  )  & 1(

* *$* " * "

0%&0  # -..-', ' "!&*( 0 

 ;  1 1 0* %*  

"#  &*& &0()$2!*($*8*$ & 161""  

&#%* &% 1"* 1!04**""  $*(* 1* /++++

*&&*0! #* ( 

(  0  -..-', ' "!&*  $*"(

 & $ &% 1

)%#&1$*" "#  *& 1 4!"*!1 61""  )!"*1, "$$ &$"

!0 5<,'7(

.5.7



>

 ;1 8<  3  3    ) , < "#  2 "#   4* 00 )*& ,

"  ! "#   !*"" $*& & 0% #  &0 "#   4*$ 4$*& 0%*

$*"#& 4*$*&, #  4*$* 00*$*&(  * 0%&*" & "#   !*"" & 1,

0%*20% 1&% 1"#  4*$*&*&!#*"#  4*$*00*$*"!!

&% 100*(



&#*#*01 $4!* 1   1%* *" )%#&1 1&*&#

)* 1="**104*1 2 1")$"0% "(

2 

;

-8  $*(* 1"  2#* 

;-8"#

 !# 1$*&*&" 2#" "04$%*-..-','"!&*(





;-<')"# &&*2"# $ *00*$4*10"

 (





;<"#"&&2#*$& "  1),""# " #*(# ,

!# 11#*,42 

;< $& "  1""&1(0 

;

8-   . $44!2 "#  #     "*&1" " " #60*01

$& "  1, " * # *2 "#  $44! 1 " $& "  1 &*$"*!, "  !



 ; 8<  - "# * "#1 

 ; 8<   . 4 , " * $& "  1

$44!""*&1" 

;8-4 1"!!(

&& 1"04$%*

$& "  &#*01 *$*  1!*%*08"!&*5,87(





;1.',"#&$& "  1$& *"# "  1"# 04*1

"  1,"  !!*%*0&"# "  (0 

;.),. 2!*%*0 

 1 #* &*& !*%*0   !  % 2 *0 #*&&, " * 1  *   &4# 1

***(

)"& 1$& "  &#*01 *$*!01 

;..

,3

;<4 #*#*&&  1!*%*08"!&*(



* 1"# *2," &"#  4*#$& "  ""&1&*&

!01 

;8- .4 0%*2"# #  "*&1"

$44!""#60*01$& "  1,"*$& "  1"*&1"$44!$*

0 04**1 *& 1,  2 " ( 

(  04 $%* / ++++ *&&*0! " "

$& "  &!*%*08"!&*(





# &*":