Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-09-44328/7 AI generated

2-09-44328/7 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus

Case Number 2-09-44328/7
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

0 @ >3   5 21  +5   +5 + ' )*' )*'!)  6*%*#

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-09-44328/7 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus: 0 @ >3   5 21  +5   +5 + ' )*' )*'!)  6*%*#

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text













  



 

 

 !





"!# $!





 %&''

 













    







()"**+,,,,# $!%-#*"*#%'!

  



 

  



 





..-+.#" '*



   

 /#%''$*((0!12+-#" '*'&!3(

 

    





$  /#%'' - "*"*# 3 ,,,,,,,,- !# $

#"* . *''- *'3 "*' "%- *'3 "44 *

5

# ((-**#!# 3,,,,,,,,,,,-!# $,,,,,,,+

+,,,,(

  

"$!33 /#%''$*((0!(

6%&*(( /#%''#!#12+7#!!!$*3#$##8%%'3

8#9#" '*'*(

6%&*(( /#%''#!#00*-2:)60)&$*'&!3- ..-+.

#" '**!%*00*!3)60# $()%;"*#!'*)&$*'&!3

6*%*'*-#!*3%*" $#%#!*..-+.#" '*(

!''*3# $! !*00*%6*30#(

 

 



 /#%''%'!#!!36((#'3(

6 %&* (  (   /#%''  #!# %'!#!! + 1 78# !$ 8$#3

#!!#8%%'38$#9#" '*.'*(







  



 /#%''  0&*; *3 )* '#;!  )60  #!-  !

#6 *%%*- #!*3 %* $*% #!* 0 #!! %<<3!%* "! # $! !

0*#! 0# %*- "! *'# ''# $!- #!!!" #;! 0&*3#

$'33#*"*#!%'!-#!*#;!* $'3%**!'*(

((0&*;*3 "!# $!,,,,# $!% !)#-#!*%

0!!-%* * !%*!#- **'*!3%&!0)&$!( 

79

0&*;*3&!%%&!0)&$! % !-#!*=+9$*0%6%*)!$!

*$*#  *%!3#6%!!0*#!***#*#!#*"0!8'3%*59

# $!*!'* *%!% 6%* )!$! * # $!#!  *%!3 #  0&* %

*'3 #6 *** #!* **#*#! #*" 0! 8'3%* 0&* # $!*!'*5 9

 ! * 0&*'!3 3! # $ $(  0&*; *3  !

#6 *%%*  + )60  #! '*' #!*  ! !; #6  *%3

06)  *  ;"#* 0&* 0*#! 0#%*- 0&*; # *3 !

#6 *%%*)60 #!( !* !$*%'!&!-

# *0'!36$# $!0&***%!'!3*!'*-!;#*3#&*#

 0%*%* &)!0%*# 0*#( '!;*  %* ); %'!;*

 3!6!36$6"*%*#%6$##%'! *%*'!-

%*%*#%'!;* ;-#&**%#7 >+219(



  !""# "$" #% "# &'# &$##%

#$(##



$! ' # $!'!3 #  # $! #*"*#! 0% + )60  #!  $*

#6 *%%* 7 +.9- $ *3 %-  #!* #  # $! %66"!3 6$#

#*"*#!*0- '# $!&*!$* !"$!33(



*03!# *3%66"!#*"*#!0!'3%*# $!! '# 

**#*#!#6 *%!3(0;"!"*+79( '# 3*##0!'3%*

# $!!( -## $! '%66"'!3#*"*#!0%*6$-* 6$

# $!#*"*#!0'!3(



 > 2  +-  # $ 0&*; # $! $  ! $*  ! "$!33

$*03! %6"*!3   !3 &*!*#! )&$'3!3 !!- #!* # - #

# $! ' %66"'!3 0%* 6$- *  6$ 0'!3- ** #!* $*  *%*

# #606*"*0&*#!* *%*#60*#!(!$! #$*!3

4#**3 06*3 #  )  %#0&!# '*'  ! 0&*;  !$! $

# $!*!'* )*3%( $! *;-  * *' # **  > 2  . %6"*!3

 !%*06*0*3 !*3(



*  !3 # $! *;-  $* ' $*03! %6"*!3 !!   !3

&*!*#!)&$'3!3'*'# $!$'3; >2+--.6!"03

  !(  >    6*3 "03 *; # $! ! )&$'30

8#'&*!*#!)&$'3!(



*03! # $ &%**3 ) 3 1('!"* 2 #"3"0)*'!- %* !

0&*%3* #  $  #!)!  #!3 '!*3- !3 ''3  *!3

# ' "!'3!6"%*#!!+.(#!!)60#( *03!*%**! '# 

#!!3#"33*!%..-+.#" '*-%*$ '"0'!3*'"# ##!

!%%1-#" '*( "3"0)*'!83*'*%!))**3) 3# ##!*'"*%66"

*?') ' "*0#!! *; "-%**#+:(*!+1(1(2

+(( ' #  00*0&'0! $  ++2- . #" '*( *  !3 '&!;

 /#%''$*((0!12+-#" '*!%*-%*)&$*0&'0! '..-+.

#" '*-*'"*31-#" '**!+((*'&!0#%!!!'!300*!*'"

++2-.#" '*(6$!3 >12 ;$# 06%&*00*-2:

)60 )&$*'&!3 * !%* 00*!3 )60 # $  ()%;"*  #!'*

)&$*'&!36*%*'*(  ' %'&!3)&$'3%*## $!*'!36"#*") 

79

0$ &%*!3 #"3"0)*'!- 83*'*%!- #  *!3 %#'&! 

# ' "!'37.9(



 '$*03!&*!*#!)&$'3'!3$*%6"*!3 !*3-03@>3

.55215+-5-+5+++)+-15+++5++-(



@ > +  +-  ' #"33*)*' )*'- %* 8# **# # $!!; '3% * **#!

#6!!"$!%%-#"33*# $!!;!%#"33**'"*)*'!&))%*

#"33**%#%( "33*)*'!%#0&*; #%#6$)603*8##%*'-

*'0&*%!!;*4*''"*%*(



0 @ >3   5 21  +5   +5 + ' )*' )*'!)  6*%*#

# $!!*#( $!! !; 6* 00 )*'! 0&* 3!( !* # $!! 6*%*

6$)60 ' #*'3# %66"!3 0&* !'; 0&!$ %!- !; # $!! 6* 

6$)60-#!!!" # $!! "*##!%*' ' 0&!$!'0# $!!6*%6%*'

0&*%*# $'6*%*'-$!6*%*00*%*'(0@>+++)+-1#!*

0&'*# '# $!!"*##!'!3-0&*;0&!3'&!3# $!!6*%*-'3)*'!

0&*<3)*'8"$*# $!!6*%*00*%*# ""'&!300*(



 ' $* $*03! %6"*!3 !!   !3 &*!*#! )&$'3!3 '*'

$) *!34#**306*3!;!3# )  %#0&!#(  ;

>2+! !%*(* !3#!!!;$* >2+

# $ !"$!3%*'*'# !;$#!#06%&*# ##!

12+-#" '*'*'"03 >126!00*-2:)60)&$*'&!3- 

..-+. #" '* * !%* 00*!3 )60 # $  ()%;"*  #!'*

)&$*'&!36*%*'*-#!*3%*" $#%#!*..-+.#" '*(



>1+)# $!''*;# $! %!*00*%6*30#

 !(



>+1+# $#'';$*%'!#!!3) -##$!# !$*( $!-

"$!33$*-6; >+1+!%'!#!!3# #'3(



0 >+2+%66";# $!$ ! !#*'3### 

$80*03%'!#!!3-#!*$*;# $!%66"!3#%'!#!!3'*%#*"-

#!!!"  > +21   # $ * # $3  > +21  +  6!- #!*

%'!#!!3%66"##*'3# >+2+6!3# ""(



 %'!#!!3 '*%#*" # $ ' $ #'3'!3 %'!#!!' $*03!

*%* !!3 "*&*0! +  #" '*- &*!;*#!!3 2- . #" '*  ) *#!!3 1

#" '*(  '*'!3%'!#!!*3&'3033 #!%'3*3(



>3++-# $ '%'!#!!3%'! *# $!#!!3# $!06*3

#!!3- #!!!" # $!#!!3 ' "*&*0- #! ' '*'  6;*0%* #!!3( 0

>+)+-!;"*&*0!!3$*'*'"*&*0!!!"!&!;*0

$*''-#!*3!* '6$!3***( 3!"03!;# $#!#

06 %&* $*$*'3 "03 %'!#!!' "*&*0 $*03! *%* + 

#" '*(

0 >+) '# $!06*##!!#%'! *) *#!!3-%* '#'!3

  %'!(  '  '!3 #  06 %&* %'!#!!' ) *#!!3 1

79

#" '*("03 >+)6!- ;# $!)&$'3!#$) *#!!

%&*;# $#!#06%'!#!!') *#!!3!%%1#" '*(



0  > + ) + ' # $!06*3 #!!3 %'! * *'3  '&!

#!!3( >+2.+-# $-#!*%'! *');%'!#!!3 !#*'3#

%66"0 # $!$'3* # $ #'3% * %'! * *'3'!3 )*'!* *'3

#!!3- %&*; # $! #!!3 06 )&$'3!3  0*#! !!- #!!!" ;"*

*! #$; )*'!* *'3 #!!3 * %'! * *'&!3%*

)"%66"3( ;"* *! ()%;"*  %66"! '" +2 )*'!* *'3 

'&! #!!3 * %'! * *'&!3%* )"%66"3 # $ ' *0

$*''#!'*+#" '*%#*%*'&!0#!!.#" '*( 3!6$!3

 ; # $!  > +2. ! 2- . #" '* $ *'3 )&$'3!#  0*#!#

#!!#(



* !3# $!*;-#!'# $! !6*$%'!#!!# #'3'*'

"03 >+2+6!0&*;# $!$ ! !#*'3#

%66"## $80*03%'!#!!3-!;# ((06%&* /#%''

#!# %'!#!!' "*&*0 +  #" '*- ) *#!!3 1 #" '*  $ *'3 #!!

!%%2-.#" '*-# ##!%'!#!!+1-.#" '*(





$!'*#=