Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-09-63452/4 AI generated

2-09-63452/4 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus

Case Number 2-09-63452/4
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

         

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-09-63452/4 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus:          

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

         

        !"  

#"$!%"   !!&'((                 )&*#+,,,,$!%"& -$.# .$&("                 -$#!!(.      /".(" ($! 0 %. )  )  1" ++-  $#!!(. ('"2)          %  /".(" ($! 0- #.#.$!!2 ,,,,,,,,- "$!%/' .((-.(2  #1!1- 033#2. !".!(4 $!  )  ) - ..$"$!!2 ,,,,,,,,,,,- "$!% #.#. $!%,,,,,,,,$5,,,,,,,12,,,,&$!(2)    #%"22/".("($! 0%. ))1") *  &'. )  )  /".(" ($! 0 $"$  ++ 6(. "% 5%$2 5$.7 $#!!(. (.) * &'. ))/".("($! 0$"$1..1.-+ 8.&$&.1..1."2 9*1  9'%.('"2- !  -  $#!!(.  )(!1&:#.  $"(. 9'%.('"2 *.&.(.)

"((.2$!%"!".1..1.&*.21$)      /".("($! 0&("$""2 * ))$(2) * &'. ))/".("($! 0$"$&("$"" 6$!&"%1..27 $#!!(.)

*!1 !" '""&.  $"(. *.&.(. ": )  )  "2 &("$"" 1..1.;<+++."(*%"2"")  

     /".(" ($! 0 1'.: .2 9.!!($:"  9*1 !!$"-  !" $*!.&&.- $".2 &. %. & $". 1.. $"" &==2"&. #" $!%" !" 1.$" 1$ &.- #" .($!(($!%"- $" ""# $:" 1'.2$

67 %(22$.# .$"&("-$".$:".!%(2&.."(.)

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

!%" !( $!%"("2 $!  $!%" $.# .$" 1& + 9*1 !!$"  %. $*!.&&. 6 7- %!.2 &-  $". $!  $!%" &#"2 *% $ $.# .$".1-!($!%"'."%. !"#%"22)  .12"$!!.2 &#"$.# .$"1"(2&.$!%""!($!  ..$.$"$*!.&"2 ) ("#.+67)!($! 2.$$1"(2&. $!%"") ! -$$!%"!(&#("2$.# .$"1&.*% -.!*% $!%"$.# .$"1("2) 

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

<@+" !"&.). !"2$""":%. <@+ $!%  !" #%"2&. (.( $!  ": %  $"$ 1*  &'. ++-  $#!!(. (.( #12  < @ *" 1..1. - +  8 . &$&. 1..1."2 9*1  9'%.('"2- !  -  $#!!(.  )(!1&:#.  $"(. 9'%.('"2*.&.(.) 

<?+9$!%"((.:$!%"!&".1..1.&*.21$  !") 

<++$!%$((:%.&("$""29!!-$$% "$!"%.) !%"- #%"22%.- *: <++"&("$""2$! $(2)  1 <+@+&#:$!%"% !" !"$.(2$$$!  %51.12&("$""2-$".% .:$!%"&#"2 $&("$""2(.&$.# )   !( !("2 $!  1*  &'. &("$""( %.12" .&. ""2 #...'.1+$#!!(.(.(.(2 &$"2"'.":. $#!!(.)  !: $!  &("$""2 ""#" $.(2$1 %(2. '""&. $"(. *.&.(. &("$""2 1..1. "&. ; < ++  + (*%"2 "")   !( .("2 &("$""2(.&$.#  &("$"".2'(2122!$"&(2.26?7 

<2+?+-$!%!(&("$""2&("!.$!%"$""2 $!%"1*.2 $""2- $" ""# $!%"$""2 !( #...'.1- $" !( (.(   *:.1&. $""2) 1

<+9+-":#...'.1""2%.(.(#...'.1"""#"'":.1..  %.((-$".2".!(*%"2...)!!2"#12":$! % $"$ 1*  &'. %.%.(2 #12 &("$""( #...'.1 %.12" .&. + $#!!(.)  1  < + 9 + !( $!%"1*.2 $""2 &("!. .(2   ('"  $""2) <+@ +-$!%-$".&("!.(9:&("$""2 !"$.(2$ &#1 $!%"%(2. $!% $(2& . &("!. .(2("2 9.(". .(2 

67 $""2- &'.: $!%" $""2 1*  9'% (2"2  1 .$" ""- $" ""# :#... ." $%: 9.(". .(2  $""2 . &("!. .('"2&. 9..#&#2) :#... ." )9&:#. ? &#" (# +@ 9.(". .(2   ('"  $""2 . &("!. .('"2&. 9..#&#2 $!% !( .1..  %.(($"(.+$#!!(.&$.&.('"1$"" $#!!(.)!!2"*%"2 (.( $"( $!  . ! %  .(2  &("$""2 1"1*..2 .("2 !: $!%"

<+@ " $#!!(.% .(2 9'% (2"$ 1 .$"$$""$) 

 < +@@   $!% $!%" &*#.: &("$""2 $.(2$&#&. !("2 ..$" 12" " &("$""2 $.(2$&#&. %(2.-  %51.&. $"""1 &("$""2 ": "2 &("$""2 ""#" $.(2$1 %(2. '""&. $"(.*.&.(.1..1.;<+++."(*%"2"")1;< +++#%.$!%""*.&.1..1.&.$!##1'.:1'"2 ('"21'(.$" 1..1.".(#.61..1.7-#1$!%"".('"1$&"""&.$"(.$!%*.&.(.) ..1.&#$!$;<*"2.(#.&#-&..(2":.9#!(. )  . !"2$!%".:-$"($!%"!" *.% &("$""$! $(2(.( #12 <+@+*"1'.:$!%"% !" !"$.(2$ &# $ $!  %51.12 &("$""2- $!  . ! &("$""2 ""#" 1"1*..2 .("2- ": $!  )  )  1*  &'. /".(" ($! 0 $"$ &("$""(#...'.1+$#!!(. % .(2 $"""&& $#!!(.-$!$$"  &("$""   $#!!(.) !  ":  !" '""&. $"(. *.&.(. "2&("$""1..1.;<+++."(*%"2"")  

!%"(.$>