Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-09-63456/5 AI generated

2-09-63456/5 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus

Case Number 2-09-63456/5
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-09-63456/5 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

         

        !"  

#"$!%"   &!' #                 ()*+#"#(,#"$!%"- .$'# '$-/"                (0.$#!!/'      1"'/" /$! & %' ) )  *" (. 2 $#!!/' /,"3)          %  1"'/" /$! &. #'#'$!!3 (2 . "$!%1, '//.'/3  #*!*. &44#3' !"'!/5 $!  ) ).''$"$!!366666666666."$!%66666766 66666,666666666)    #%"331"'/"/$! &%' ) )*") 8 -,' ) )1"'/"/$! &$"$(9$$"%$""3/'':$#!!/' 2/') 8 -,' ) )1"'/"/$! &$"$*''*'.( ;'-$-'*''*'"3 <8*  <,%'/,"3. ! (0.  $#!!/'  )/!*-+#'  $"/' <,%'/,"3 8'-'/')

"//'3$!%"!"'*''*'-8'3*$)      1"'/"/$! &-/"$""3 8 ) )$/3) 8 -,' ) )1"'/"/$! &$"$-/"$"" 9$$"%*''3: $#!!/')

8!* !" ,""-'  $"/' 8'-'/' "+ ) )  "3 -/"$"" *''*'=>((('"/8%"3"")  

     1"'/" /$! & *,'+ '3 <'!!/$+"  <8* !!$".  !" $8!'--'. $"'3 -' %' - $"' *'' $"" -??3"-' #" $!%" !" *'$" *$ -'. #" '/$!//$!%". $" ""# $+" *,'3$

9: %/33$'# '$"-/".$"'$+"'!%/3-''"/')

) )*,'+'3 #"$!%",#"$!%"-  !"<$ .$"'- *"".-'!' !"-'"$.!''/'"3-, "*<,% ")   *,'+'3,"--, "*<,% "!-!".$"'@(:%'*- 8-'<"%" !'%'$! !'-"3$8-""*'''$"'''$'$"$'# *"7/3-'5: $!%"'"/' '-"- 8-' <"%" !' $!%"$" !'-"3 $!  *,' - '/3  $8 ''' $"' ''$'$" $'#  *" 7/3-' *,' $!%"'"/'5 :  !" ' *,'/"3 3" $!% %)   *,'+ '3  !" $8!'--'  ( <8* !!$" /'/ $"'  !" "+ $8 !'-3 *8 <!! '  +#''$' *,' *'$" *$-'. *,'+ $  '3 !" $8!'--'2<8* !!$") "' !"%'-/",". $! '*/"38%$!%"*,'''-"/"3'"/'."+$ '3$,'$   *-'-' ,<"*''-'$ * '$) /"+' !-' <+ -/"+' ! 3"8"38%  8#'-'$-8% $$-/"!'-'/". -'-'$-/"+'!+.$,''-$ 9 >(20:)    !""# "$" #% "# &'# &$##% #$(## 

!%" !/ $!%"/"3 $!  $!%" $'# '$" *- ( <8* !!$"  %' $8!'--' 9 0:. %!'3 -.  $"' $!  $!%" -88#"3 8% $ $'# '$"'*.!/$!%",'"%' !"#%"33)  '*3"$!!'3 -88#"$'# '$"*"/3-'$!%""!/$!  ''$'$"$8!'-"30) /"#'(9 :)!/$! 3'$$*"/3-' $!%"") ! .$$!%"!/-88#/"3$'# '$"*-'8% .'!8% $!%"$'# '$"*/"3) 

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

>0(" !"-')' !"3$"""+%' >0( $!%  !" #%"3-' /'/ $!  "+ %  $"$ *8  -,' (. 2 $#!!/' /'/ #*3  > 0 8" *''*' . (  ; ' -$-' *''*'"3 <8*  <,%'/,"3. ! (0.  $#!!/'  )/!*-+#'  $"/' <,%'/,"38'-'/') 

>2(<$!%"//'+$!%"!-"'*''*'-8'3*$  !") 

>(($!%$//+%'-/"$""3<!!.$$% "$!"%') !%". #%"33%'. 8+ >(("-/"$""3$! $/3)  * >(0(-88#+$!%"% !" !"$'/3$$$!  %7*'*3-/"$""3.$"'% '+$!%"-88#"3 $-/"$""3/'-$'# )   !/ !/"3 $!  *8  -,' -/"$""/ %'*3" '-' ""3 #''','*($#!!/'/'/'/3 -$"3",'"+'( $#!!/')  !+ $!  -/"$""3 ""#" $'/3$* %/3' ,""-' $"/' 8'-'/' -/"$""3 *''*' "-' = > ((  ( /8%"3 "")   !/ '/"3 -/"$""3/'-$'#  -/"$""'3,/3*33!$"-/3'392: 

>3(2(.$!%!/-/"$""3-/"!'$!%"$""3 $!%"*8'3 $""3. $" ""# $!%"$""3 !/ #''','*. $" !/ /'/   8+'*-' $""3) *

>(<(."+#''','*""3%'/'/#''','*"""#","+'*''  %'//.$"'3"'!/8%"3''')!!3"#*3"+$! % $"$ *8  -,' %'%'/3 #*3 -/"$""/ #''','* %'*3" '-' ( $#!!/')  *  > ( < ( !/ $!%"*8'3 $""3 -/"!' '/3   /,"  $""3) >(0 (.$!%.$"'-/"!'/<+-/"$""3 !"$'/3$ -88#* $!%"%/3' $!% $/3- ' -/"!' '/3/"3 <'/"' '/3 

9: $""3. -,'+ $!%" $""3 *8  <,% /3"3  * '$" "". $" ""# +#''' '" $%+ <'/"' '/3  $""3 ' -/"!' '/,"3-' <''#-88#3) +#''' '" )<-+#' 2 -88#" /# (0 <'/"' '/3   /,"  $""3 ' -/"!' '/,"3-' <''#-88#3 $!% !/ '*''  %'//$"/'($#!!/'-$'-'/,"*$"" $#!!/')!!3"8%"3 /'/ $"/ $!  ' ! %  '/3  -/"$""3 *"*8''3 '/"3 !+ $!%"

>(0 "( $#!!/'% '/3 <,% /3"$ * '$"$$""$) 

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

!%"/'$@