Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-09-64523/4 AI generated

2-09-64523/4 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus

Case Number 2-09-64523/4
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

 = 0  ).  $!% +'/, $!%" %  !" %/  !" #%"33 %/+3" &6#/"3   !"3 '/"/$" ;'% (3"3 "". $"/ $! . $ $!%" !( &66#("3 +&/ 6% . / ! 6% +("3. // $"/ %/ !/&/ $! $6+6/#///+'/$"/!/&/$6+/$"* "%"!$% /"3 A$//3 +6/3 $!  ;!! !&$+'"$ (/(  !" +'/,  "%" % $!%"/"(/ ;/3&* !%" /,.  / /( $ //  = 0   &6#/"3  !"&/+6/+/3 !"/3*  /  !"3 $!%" /,.  %/ !( %/+3" &6#/"3 ""   !"3 '/"/$";'% (3"3(/($!%"%(3, =0). .6"#+3    !"*  =    6/3 #+3 /, $!%" !" ;'% (3+ !8$('/"/$";'% (3"*  /+3"$!%'&//3/!,///3--- $! *;&,#/ //"&/  6#&$";/("3. &/ $!%  / !,///3--- $!%"" ;$$"& $!  $!&&"(/$/!!(/---* ! $!%""3"3--- B+'/$";3++/"3 #+ '/ "&* ;/(" $/((/ $!  !& $/# .   $!%"", 6/& ;/(" %"&"$ /$ !+/3 &!,//A!(/--- $"&/ /(/&"/*  / !,///3---!!+"@*)*@$! +('"3;'%/"&&  .0$#!!(/ 2 1"/(" ($! $!! '/" ('"3 $'#+('"3/3* +  / !,///3--- ;/("  ;/(" %""$ /$ !+ &!,///3--- $"&/ /(/&". $"/ $!  / " #+/3 ('"$!% 6%;6+$. $!%"", $!  "& 6% $ "&

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-09-64523/4 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

         

        !"  

#"$!%"   !!&'((                 )*+,#"#)----$!%"& .$/# /$&("                 .0$#!!(/      1"/(" ($! 2 %/ *  *  +" 0.  $#!!(/ ('"3*         

"$!%1'  /((./(3  #+!+. 244#3/ !"/!(5

)--------&$!(3*    #%"331"/("($! 2%/**+"* 6  &'/ *  *  1"/(" ($! 2 $"$  0 7$"" "% /3 8%$$8&&(39$#!!(/ (/* 6 &'/**1"/("($! 2$"$+//+/.):/&$&/+//+/"3 ;6+  ;'%/('"3. !  . 0 $#!!(/  *(!+&,#/  $"(/ ;'%/('"3 6/&/(/*

"((/3$!%"!"/+//+/&6/3+$*      1"/("($! 2&("$""3 6**$(3* 6 &'/**1"/("($! 2$"$&("$"" 7$!&"%+//39 $#!!(/*

6!+ !" '""&/  $"(/ 6/&/(/ ", *  *  "3 &("$"" +//+/<=)) )/"(6%"3""*  

     1"/(" ($! 2 +'/, /3 ;/!!($,"  ;6+ !!$".  !" $6!/&&/. $"/3 &/ %/ & $"/ +// $"" &>>3"&/ #" $!%" !" +/$" +$ &/. #" /($!(($!%". $" ""# $," +'/3$

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

!%" !( $!%"("3 $!  $!%" $/# /$" +& ) ;6+ !!$"  %/ $6!/&&/ 7  9. %!/3 &.  $"/ $!  $!%" &66#"3 6% $ $/# /$"/+.!($!%"'/"%/ !"#%"33*  /+3"$!!/3 &66#"$/# /$"+"(3&/$!%""!($!  //$/$"$6!/&"3))* ("#/)7 9*!($! 3/$$+"(3&/ $!%""* ! .$$!%"!(&66#("3$/# /$"+&/6% ./!6% $!%"$/# /$"+("3* 

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

=0)" !"&/*/ !"3$""",%/ =0) $!%  !" #%"3&/ (/( $!  ", %  $"$ +6  &'/ 0.  $#!!(/ (/( #+3  = 0 6" +//+/ . ) : / &$&/ +//+/"3 ;6+  ;'%/('"3. !  . 0 $#!!(/  *(!+&,#/  $"(/ ;'%/('"36/&/(/* 

=@);$!%"((/,$!%"!&"/+//+/&6/3+$  !"* 

=))$!%$((,%/&("$""3;!!.$$% "$!"%/* !%". #%"33%/. 6, =))"&("$""3$! $(3*  + =)0) &66#,$!%"% !" !"$/(3$$$!  %8+/+3&("$""3.$"/% /,$!%"&66#"3 $&("$""3(/&$/# *   !( !("3 $!  +6  &'/ &("$""( %/+3" /&/ ""3 #///'/+)$#!!(/(/(/(3 &$"3"'/",/$#!!(/*  !, $!  &("$""3 ""#" $/(3$+ %(3/ '""&/ $"(/ 6/&/(/ &("$""3 +//+/ "&/ < = ))   ) (6%"3 ""*   !( /("3 &("$""3(/&$/#  &("$""/3'(3+33!$"&(3/37@9 

=3) @).$!%!(&("$""3&("!/$!%"$""3 $!%"+6/3 $""3. $" ""# $!%"$""3 !( #///'/+. $" !( (/(   6,/+&/ $""3* +

=) ;). ",#///'/+""3%/(/(#///'/+"""#"'",/+//  %/((.$"/3"/!(6%"3///*!!3"#+3",$! % $"$ +6  &'/ %/%/(3 #+3 &("$""( #///'/+ %/+3" /&/ ) $#!!(/*  +  = ) ; ) !( $!%"+6/3 $""3 &("!/ /(3   ('"  $""3* =)0).$!%.$"/&("!/(;,&("$""3 !"$/(3$ &66#+ $!%"%(3/ $!% $(3& / &("!/ /(3("3 ;/("/ /(3 

79 $""3. &'/, $!%" $""3 +6  ;'% (3"3  + /$" "". $" ""# ,#/// /" $%, ;/("/ /(3  $""3 / &("!/ /('"3&/ ;//#&66#3* ,#/// /" *;&,#/ @ &66#" (# ) 0 ;/("/ /(3   ('"  $""3 / &("!/ /('"3&/ ;//#&66#3 $!% !( /+//  %/(($"(/)$#!!(/&$/&/('"+$""$#!!(/*!!3"6%"3 (/( $"( $!  / ! %  /(3  &("$""3 +"+6//3 /("3 !, $!%"

=)0"$#!!(/% /(3 ;'% (3"$ + /$"$$""$* 

 = )00   $!% $!%" &6#/, &("$""3 $/(3$&66#&/ !("3 //$" +3" " &("$""3 $/(3$&66#&/ %(3/.  %8+/&/ $"""+ &("$""3 ", "3 &("$""3 ""#" $/(3$+ %(3/ '""&/ $"(/6/&/(/+//+/<=)) )/"(6%"3""*+<= )) )#%/$!%""6/&/+//+/&/$!##+'/,+'"3 ('"3+'(/$" +//+/"/(#/7+//+/9.#+$!%""/('"+$&"""&/$"(/$!%6/&/(/* //+/&66#$!$<=6"3/(#/&66#.&//(3",/;#!(/ *  / !"3$!%"/,.$"($!%"!" 6/% &("$""$! $(3(/( #+3 =)0) 6"+'/,$!%"% !" !"$/(3$ &66# $ $!  %8+/+3 &("$""3. $!  / ! &("$""3 ""#" +"+6//3 /("3. ", $!  *  *  +6  &'/ 1"/(" ($! 2 $"$ &("$""(#///'/+)$#!!(/ % /(3 $"""&&$#!!(/.$!$$"  &("$""   $#!!(/* !  ",  !" '""&/ $"(/ 6/&/(/ "3&("$""+//+/<=)) )/"(6%"3""*  

!%"(/$?