Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-09-54061/4 AI generated

2-09-54061/4 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus

Case Number 2-09-54061/4
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-09-54061/4 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

          

        !"  

#"$!%"   &!' #                 ()*#"# +#"$!%", -$'# '$,."                    /.$%'(( ( ()"  - $#!!.' 0'.1))'')'.+"1  2-$#!!.'          %    /.$- #'#'$!!1 - "$!%

!#.',0 '..-'.1 3!."!.,00',4 $!  ( ( - ''$"$!!1 55555555555- "$!% 555555555556555+55555555+5555555554 $!  ( ( - ''$"$!!1 55555555555- "$!% 555555 56555555555555+555555555(    #%"11/.$%'(( ( ()"( 0  ,+' !'1# ( (   ( (    /.$ $"$   76$1 .'$6,,.16$"%$""1.'$6,,.1$$8$#!!.' .'( 0  ,+' !'1# ( (   ( (    /.$ $"$ )'')'  9  :+%'.+"1  2-$#!!.' (!$!!*#'$".':+%'.+"10','.'(

"..'1$!%"!"')'')',0'1)$(      /.$,."$""1 0!'1#(( ( ($.1( 0  ,+' !'1# ( (   ( (    /.$ $"$ ,."$""   7$$'"%)''18$#!!.'(  

       /.$ )+'* '1 :'!!.$*" 2 :0) !!$"-  !" $0!',,'- $"'1 ,' %' , $"' )'' $"" ,;;1",' #" $!%" !" )'$" )$ ,'- #" '.$!..$!%"- $" ""# $*" )+'1$ %.11$'# '$",."-$"'$*"'!%.1,''".'( (( ( ()+')1'1 #"$!%"+#"$!%",  !": $ -$"',)""-,'!' !",'"$-!''.'"1,+ ")

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

!%" !. $!%"."1 $! '1 $!%" $'# '$" ),   :0) !!$"  %' $0!',,' 7 28 %!'1 ,-  $"' $! 1 $!%" ,00#"1 0% $ $'# '$"')-!.$!%"+'"%''.+"1 !"#%"11  ')1"$!!'1 ,00#"$'# '$")".1,'$!%""!.$!  ( (  ''$'$" $0!',"1 (!$!!*#'  7 28  $!  ( (  $0!',"1

>2 0"1$!##?( ."#' 78(!.$! 11'$"1$ )" .1,' $!%""( ! 1- $1 $!%" !. ,00#."1 $'# '$" ),' 0% -'!0%$!%"$'# '$")."1( 

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

! 1$!%""'1,,$#@'$"" =( (?$".' =(=( (

".).":'.":!'."'.#',00# 9.'.$! 1$!%""'1", % '.#''$"' =( (?(:'." 0#1$!%""1!'1.''$! (( $"'$! ( (,""1.'.:'."!"1,$'1!'% +'"1*'#'1.'' $! (($"'$$! ( ($!.!1%  ""#( ! 1!,$!%""'0'."1.'. #'$$"'1 ,$#@'$" " ",' $!$$":- 0 ", '.#',$1 .'. .",$1 =( (=(,% .+"1,''"."1$! 1.":'." "$$'."1)+.)"(  %!'$! '1:'."#$!##'66,'

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

"' :'." !.  .0%"1 $+#, '.#',00# $"' 1" 0#. )'')',00#- !$ )'')',00#$:'.".0%"1'.#',00#(  A> -$!%$"','"''$":)10',$!%""!'1#-)+'*)+"1  .+"1$!%""0''$$")+'!'0','$+'')+.'$6%')+''6%)+',+. .'( "','"''$"$!%"")1:'."0',$!%""6%'-''1$-.1!. !'1#)+.'$"1(  !.%'%')1",0#'"1""  !"1+'"'$":+% .1"1.'.%  :!!'"1@$''1)0'1"*"1$! :!!!,$)+"$(  !* > ? " !",'(' !"1$"""*%' >? $!%  !" #%"1,' .'. $!  "* %  $"$ !'1# )0  ,+' )+.)"  -  $#!!.' .'. #)1  > 2? 0" )'')'  9  :+%'.+"1-!  2-$#!!.' (!$!!*#'$".':+%'.+"10','.'(

 78 

>= :$!%"..'*$!%"!,"')'')',0'1)$  !"(' !"1$!%""..'* >= :" !"!, "')'')',0'1)$( 

>  $!%$..*%',."$""1:!!-$$% "$!"%'.'. )) > 2-$"'!"!.%"1!'1#)+.'$$! $% "$-)")1 $! 1 ,."$""1  ,"' !'1#( !%"- #%"11 %' !'1#)+.'$ $! $% "$- 0* >1  4 2",."$""1!'1#$!  $.1(  ) > ? 2,00#*$!%"% !" !"$'.1$$$!  %6)')1,."$""1-$"'% '*$!%",00#"1 $,."$""1.',$'# (  !.!."1$! !'1#)0 ,+'%')1"','""1#'''+') $#!!.'7=8( 

>1 2= -$!%!.,."$""1,."!'$!%"$""1 $!%")0'1 $""1-$" ""#$!%"$""1!.#'''+')-$" !..'. 0*'),'$""1(  :!! $."1,."$""!.%')1"',')) > 22 -->  %'%'..-!  2-$#!!.'""1#'''+') $#!!.'(  ' !"1$!%"'*-$".$!%"!" 0'% ,."$""!'1#$!  $.1.'.#)1 > ? 20")+'*$!%"% !" !" $'.1$ ,00# $ $!  %6)')1 ,."$""1- "* $!  ( (   ( ( !'1#)0 ,+'/.$$"$,."$"".#'''+')%')1"',' ",, $#!!.'(   

!%".'$<