Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-09-67609/4 AI generated

2-09-67609/4 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus

Case Number 2-09-67609/4
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-09-67609/4 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

         

       ! "#    $%!                 &&'()! !&*! "# +,"%!%"+-                .&/"!-%     

0 %- -" $#%0' '( "!-%-* 1'          # 0 %-  -" $, !%!%"1 &2//.,  "#0*. %--,%-1 !((, $33!1%

 %-4 "0' ',%%" "155555555555, "#55555555 55555*555555555'    !# 110 %- -" $#%0' '( ' 6 +*% 0' '  0 %-  -" $ " "   7"   #  ""1 8#""8++-18#"9"!-%' 6+*%0' '0 %- -" $" "(%%(%,&/:%+"+%(%%(% 1 ;6(  ;*#%-* 1,  . &/ "!-%  2'-(+)!%  " -% ;*#%-* 1 6%+%-%' --%1"#  %(%%(%+6%1("'     

0 %- -" $+- "  160' '"-1' 6+*%0' '0 %- -" $" "+- "  ./7"+ #(%%19 "!-%' 6(   *  +%  " -% 6%+%-%  ) 0' '   1 +- "   (%%(%< =&&.&% -6# 1  '  

    

0 %-  -" $ (*%) %1 ;%-")  . ;6( " ,    "6%++%, " %1 +% #%+ " % (%% "  +>>1 +% !  "#    (%"  (" +%, !  %-"--"# , "  ! ")  (*%1" #-11"%!%" +- ," %") %#-1+%% -%'

7?9 0' '(*%)%1 ! "# *! "# + ;"," %+ (  ,+%% +% ",%%-% 1+* (;*# ' (*%)%1* ++* (;*# + ," %@&9#%(+6+%; #  %#%"%+ 1"6+ (%%%" %%%"%" "%!( 8-1+%49 "# % -% %+ + 6+% ; #  % "# "  %+ 1 " (*% + %-1 "6 %%% " % %%"%"  "%! (  8-1+% (*% "# % -%4 .9   % (*%- 1 1  "# #'  (*%) %1   "6%++%  &? ;6( "  -%- " %    ) "6 %+1 (6; %  )!%%"% (*% (%"  ("+%, (*%) " %1   "6%++%2;6(" ' % #%+- * , "%(- 16#"# (*%%%+ - 1% -%, )"%1"*%"  (+%+% *; (%%+%" (%"' - )% +% ;) +- )% 1 6 16#6!%+%"+6#""+- %+%- , +%+%"+- )%),"*%%+"7  =&29'    !""# "$" #% "# &'# &$##% #$(##  #  - "# - 1 " "#  "%!%"  (+ & ;6( "   #% "6%++% 7 .9, #%1 +,  " % " "#  +66! 1 6#" "%!%" %(,-"# *% #% !# 11' 

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

%(1  "# *+%%1   % )%%%1- 1  " &?'")!% ? 6!+" ;%- , +% "#   % )%%%1- 1 "#   ;"" + " "++ -%"%-%- '  "#   1 1 -  B(*% " ;1  (( % 1 !( *%  +' ;%-  "%--%" + "%!,   "#  ) 6%+;%-  # + " %"(%1+)%%A-%- " +%%-%+ %'  %)%%%1- 1( 2'&'2"(-* 1;*#% ++.&/"!-% $ 0 %-  -" " *%  -* 1 "*!(-* 1%1' (   % )%%%1- 1 ;%-   ;%-  #  " %" ( +)%%%1-  " +%%-%+ ," %"% !(%1-* "#6#;6(","#  )"  + 6#"  +  ++ (%%(% ,&/ : % +"+% (%%(% 1 ;6( '

.7?9

 - !(- 1 ;!%1% &2'&' " -% '&&'  (%%(% /.,  "!-%'

-* )"(%%(% +% ++.&?"!-%'% 1-* )0 %-  -" $#%0' '( "!-% +%,+%;*#%(*-( -.&/"!-% (%%(%1 . &? "!-%' 6# 1   = . ) #  " (6 +*% # " "(%%(%,&/:%(%%(% 1;6(" -%;*#%(*-(  +%-%' - + -* 1 ;*#-1+%" "#  %- 1 6!"%!   % )%%%1- 1  " (# *+% 1 ;%- , 81%-%+ , 6!"%!1 " % 1 !(, (%%(% !( -%--* 1( +%%7&/9' 

-#%(1 *% %" ;*#-1- 1#%+6!% 1 %1,(%%1< = 1&42&4&4&&&;&,4&&.&,+%1"# )"#  6% (( ;%-  (*% 1 , "  ! "#   !%"" +%- - (* #  -( "#   6%+ 6+%- (*% +%"#- 6%+%-, #  6%+% (%%(%+%-'  % (*-%" - "#   !%"" - 1, (*%) (* 1 -* 1 "#   6%+%  !#% "#   6%+% (%%(%+% "!! -* 1 (%%(%, !( "#   %-* (" +  +%" -%"#6%+%-%' 

 - #% #%(1  +6!% 1     1 *% %"  ;*#-1 1 -%- #;% 1A"%%1(6%1 ) 1";+"(* "' )  =?&  +%'% 1"  )#%  =?& "# !# 1+%-%-" )#" "(6+*% "!-%-%-!(1  =.6 (%%(%,&/:%+"+%(%%(% 1;6( ;*#%-* 1,.&/"!-%2'-(+)!%" -%;*#%-* 16%+%-%'   =?2&;"# --%)"# + %(%%(%+6%1("  '   =&&"#"--)#%+- "  1;,""# " #%'# , !# 11#%,6)  =&& +- "  1""-1'  (  =&?&.+66!)"# #  "%-1""" #8(%(1+- "  1," %#%)"# +66! 1"+- "  1-%+"%!'

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