Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-09-67600/4 AI generated

2-09-67600/4 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus

Case Number 2-09-67600/4
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-09-67600/4 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

         

       ! "#    $ %&&                 '(& !)*"# $+",!,"$&                -.+/'"!&,     

0 ,&  &" 1 #, (  (  2  )'/+  "!&, &% 3(          # 0 ,&  &" 1+ !,!,"3 +  "#0%/ ,&&+,&3 !22+ 144!3,

 ,&5 " (  ( + ,," "3 +  "#  "6*23*$"&3(    !# 330 ,& &" 1#,((2 ( 7$%,((0 ,& &" 1" ")'/8"6$$ #"#""6$$&3 "$9"!&,&,( 7$%,((0 ,& &" 1" "2,,2,+)-:,$"$,2,,2, 3 ;72  ;%#,&% 3+  -.+ /' "!&,  '(&2$<!,  " &, ;%#,&% 3 7,$,&,( &&,3"#  ,2,,2,$7,32"(     

0 ,& &" 1$& "  37(("&3( 7$%,((0 ,& &" 1 " "$& "  /'8"$ #"#"39 "!&,( 72 %  $," &,7,$,&, <(( 3$& "  2,,2, = >))/), &7# 3  (  

    

0 ,&  &" 1 2%,< ,3 ;,&"<  / ;72 " +    "7,$$,+ " ,3 $, #,$ " , 2,, "  $??3 $, !  "#    2,"  2" $,+ !  ,&"&&"# + "  ! "<  2%,3"

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

,23 "#%$,,3 ,<,,,3& 3"(.(7!$"  ,, $,;,& 3+ $, "#   , <,,,3& 3 "#   ;"" $ " "$$ &,",&,& (  "#   3 3 &  B2%, " ;3  22 , 3 !2 %,  $( ;,&  ",&&, " $ ",!+   "#  < 7,$ ;,&  # $ " ," 2,3 $<,,A&,&  " $, ,&,$ ,(    , <,,,3& 3 2  '()(' " 2 &% 3 ;%#, $$ -.+ /' "!&, 1 0 ,&  &" " %,  &% 3 "%!2&% 3,3( 2   , <,,,3& 3 ;,&   ;,&  #  " ," 2 $<,,,3&  " $,,&,$ +" ,", !2,3&% "#7#;72"+"#  <"

/8.9  $7#" $ $$2,,2,+)-:,$"$,2,,2, 3;72(  &!2& 3;!,3,)'()(" &,())(2,,2,')+.."!&,( &% < "2,,2, $, $$-.)+/'"!&,(, 3&% <0 ,& &" 1 #, (  (  2  )'/+  "!&,  $,+ $, ;%#,2%&2  & -.+ /' "!&,  2,,2,3-.)+/'"!&,(7# 3  >/<#"27$%,# " "2,,2,+)-:,2,,2, 3;72" &,;%#,2%&2  $,&,( &$ &% 3 ;%#&3$," "#  ,& 3 7!",!   , <,,,3& 3  " 2# %$, 3;,& +63,&,$ +7!",!3", 3!2+2,,2,!2 &,& &% 32 $,,( 

&#,23 %, ," ;%#&3& 3#,$7!, 3 ,3+2,,3= >3 )5')5)5)));)+5))/)+$,3"# <"#  7,22 ;,&  2%, 3 + "  ! "#   !,"" $,& & 2% #  &2 "#   7,$ 7$,& 2%, $,"#& 7,$,&+ #  7,$, 2,,2,$,&(  , 2%&," & "#  !,"" & 3+2%,<2% 3&% 3"#  7,$,!#,"#  7,$, 2,,2,$, "!! &% 3 2,,2,+ !2 "#   ,&% 2" $  $, " &, "# 7,$,&,( 

&#,#,23 $7!, 3   3%, ," ;%#&3 3&,&# ;, 3A",,327,3 < 3";$"2% "( <  > .)  $,(, 3"  <#,  >.)"#  !# 3$,&,&" <#" "27$%,)'/+"!&,( &,& !23   > / 7  2,,2, + )- : , $"$, 2,,2, 3 ;72  ;%#,&% 3+-.+/'"!&,'(&2$<!," &,;%#,&% 37,$,&,(   >.');"# &&,<"# $ ,2,,2,$7,32"  (   >))"#"&&<#,$& "  3;+""# " #,(# + !# 33#,+7<  >)) $& "  3""&3(  2  >).)/$77!<"# #  ",&3""" #62,23$& "  3+" ,#,<"# $77! 3"$& "  3&,$",!(

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