Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-09-47244/5 AI generated

2-09-47244/5 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus

Case Number 2-09-47244/5
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-09-47244/5 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

         

       ! "#    $%!                 &'( !)*! "# +,"%!%"+(                &-"!(%      . %( (" $#%.''/ --"!(%(* 0'          # . %(  (" $, !%!%"0 )&1&--2,  "#.*2 %((,%(0 !//, $33!0%

 %(4 ".'',%%" "055555555555, "#555555555'    !# 00. %( (" $#%.''/ ' 6 +*% .' '  . %(  (" $ " " - - 7/%%  # /%%0 """8++(0 8#"9"!(%' ((%0"#  %/%%/%+6%0/"'      . %( (" $+( "  06.''"(0' 6 +*% .' '  . %(  (" $ " " +( "   2 - 7"+  # /%%09 "!(%' 6/ *  +%" (%6%+%(% :.'' 0+( "  /%%/% ; <))2)% (6# 0  '  

     . %(  (" $ /*%: %0 =%(":  2 =6/ " ,    "6%++%, " %0 +% #%+ " % /%% "  +>>0 +% !  "#    /%"  /" +%, !  %("(("# , "  ! ":  /*%0" #(00"%!%" +( ," %": %#(0+%% (%' .''/*%:%0 ! "# *! "# + ="," %+ /  ,+%% +% ",%%(% 0+* /=*# ' /*%:%0* ++* /=*# + ," %?)9#%/+6+%= # 

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

%/0  "# *+%%0   %  " )'' =%( , +% "#   %/*%(0"#  0""++ (%"%(%( %0'"%((%, (*  :=%( # + "%"/#( " +%"%!#%(("%!'  "#     0 (    + *% // % 0 !/'  " #( %0((0 +' %%+%% ("% 0!/0  +  ++ &- "!(%'   % 88=%(%+  = '2 6!% % = /# /%%/%%(!%" """  =% 0 , ) A  +  ++ =6/' 6/ (* : # "/%%/% ++&"!(%'%!!%( 0 %(* 0 0=%(   (//*(/ (%( %/ (* 0""*!/(* "/ #' %  0 (* : . %(  (" $ #% .' '  /  - - "!(%  +%, +% =*#%/*(/ (&-"!(%/%%/%0&"!(%' (+(* 0=*#(0+%" "# %( 06!"%! %"/#*+% 0=%( ,6!"%!0"% 0 !/,/%%/%!/ (%((* 0/ +%%'

279 

(#%/0 *% %" =*#(0( 0#%+6!% 0 %0,/%%0; <0 &)41)4)4)))=),&4))2),+%0"# :"#  6%// =%(  /*% 0 , "  ! "#   !%"" +%( ( /* #  (/ "#   6%+ 6+%( /*% +%"#( 6%+%(, #  6%+% /%%/%+%('  % /*(%" ( "#  !%"" ( 0,/*%:/* 0(* 0"#  6%+%!#%"#  6%+% /%%/%+% "!! (* 0 /%%/%' #% "#   6%+% /%%/%+% "!! /*%: /* 0 (* 0 /*(%"  /%%/% %(!% 7/%%/%9, !/ "#   %(* /" +  +%" (%"#6%+%(%' 

(#%#%/0 +6!% 0   0*% %" =*#(0 0(%(# =% 0@"%%0/6%0 : 0"=+"/* "' :  < )  +%'% 0"  :#%  <)"#  !# 0+%(%(" :#" "/6+*%--"!(%'   <&1)="# ((%:"# + %/%%/%+6%0/"  '   <)&)"#"((:#%+( "  0=,""# " #%'# , !# 00#%,6:  <)&) +( "  0""(0'  /  <))2+66!:"# #  "%(0""" #8/%/0+( "  0," %#%:"# +66! 0"+( "  0(%+"%!'

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