Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-09-14537/18 AI generated

2-09-14537/18 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus

Case Number 2-09-14537/18
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-09-14537/18 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text



 



        !"#$%&'"  

(#$ )$!   ))*#''                 +) #)),(%($ )#$*-. (-% %*'#%$!                    / )0$%!'+1+"!#$ 2 ())''$0!+ 33 ())'           - / )0$%!'. (!#( ))0 . !$ )# 4((!#( )!%#  #   . &)!#0(!!.!'0-'0($!5)!#6 )!#-+1+.! $ ))0.%$ )# +    ($%00 / )0$%!'+1+"!#$+ 4%-*!#+1+ / )0$%!' !$ ! 27 )%* 8'0"!#$#  !!0 !#! 8'09 ())'+      / )0$%!'*'#%$! $%$0-4##+1+ '0+ 4%-*!#+1+ / )0$%!' !$ !*'#%$! $%$37 $$!#$#9 ())'+  

    

)#$)#!$! &% ",  &4" -)) !$%. %#! )#!$! 4###)*#*!!#. $0 *## %-* $ " $$ *::0$*!% )#!$! "% $%# ##" !#*!!#. !#0 &%%#!))' ,$! (#$ ' )'' )#$%+ &%%#!))' ,$! "0 ! %'00 (-% $!*'#%$!!. $ ,$!!#)#%#!%%%'0*!#!#$'%+    !""# "$" #% "# &'# &$##%#$(## 

)$! )' )$!#'$0 )!#-# )#$% (-% $%# "!#*  &4" -)) !$% %#!  4###)*#*!!# 7#% 9. )#0! !*!. # $ )!#- )#$% *44(#$0 #4#- ! (-% $%#"!#.)' )#$%$!#!%-)#!$!($%00+ )!#-"#, (-% $! "!#$!! )#$%-'$0 !7#%9+

;7 9  !#"%# !<%", (-%0"-&-'0")!"4%--4## )!#- !"#$% &'"!#)#!$!!#.!%#$*#''!#+ 

!<%.  )!%#. $ )!#-"#, )#$%!##$0"%0$!!-'$0 !. ($%0, )$!+ $ !"#*')'!##$0 )#$%"%0$!!."# !"%0$! #)* $!!+ $ )!#- "%0,   !"#*! )#$% %*'#%$!!. %'0, )$! !- )#$!#$'#&0*#+ 

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

7 9 

!<32%#$''!#, )$!)*%%#$!%##!#""#*##40#" !  !"#$% &'" )#!$!+ % !-)%$0% )$! #$''!#, ! < 32 %       !"#$%&'")#!$!)*%%#$!%##!#""#*##40#" !+ 

! < 3 %   '', *'#%$!! $%$0 &))%. %% -$ ! )#!$! ##+ )$!. ($%00!.-4#, !<3%*'#%$! $%$0 )!#- '0+ 

!< )!#- !"#$%&'")#!$!#*! )((%*44(, )$! !"#$% &'"! )#!$!! %! ! *'#%$! $%$0 -)#$!%  8"#"# *'#%$! $%$0 (%! !$$($!+ -&))%# '#$0*'#%$! $%$)'"%0$!!#*!%#!$#$0(%"3 ())'.*%%"4%-*!#*!#- )!#-%##)#%,+ 

! <0  2 % .  )!%# )' *'#%$! $%$0 *'#%$!)!%!# )#$ $%$0 - )#$"4%!0 $%$0. $!-$$(! )#$ $%$0 )' (%". $#!-)' '' !- %4,"#*! $%$0+!#"%# !< %&.% #$%,(%"$#!$0%#''(%"$ !$$($!!%#$,#!"%!-''!#. $!0$!!)%##'4#$0#!#+ -&))%# '#$0 *'#%$! $%$ )' "%0$! !#*!% "!#"%# !<   % . 6  < 3 %  !#*!%''%##!$#$0(%"3 ())'+  %!-)%$0% )$!%,.# $' )#$)#!$!-4#-*'#%$! $%$ )!#- '0 '' ("!#0! ! <      *44(, )$!  !"#$% &'"! )#!$!! %! ! *'#%$! $%$0-)#$!% 8"#"#*'#%$! $%$0(%!!$$($!.#$%, )!#-%#+ 1+"4%-*!# / )0$%!' !$ !*'#%$! $%$'(%""%0$!!#*!% !$!3 ())'+      )#$' @