Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-09-17932/5 AI generated

2-09-17932/5 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus

Case Number 2-09-17932/5
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

  

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-09-17932/5 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus:   

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

  

      !"#$%&!   '"#(#    (()"&&                 *## "$'#("#)+,'+$$)&"$#                    -'&"$&! " .+($ .! "#!$&!# / ,0'((&&#1  2/'((&           +-'&"$&! " .,' "'((133333333  #("4'' "'( $" '## 0'#5 ( "+ +($ ., ' "'((1 33333333,  #(" &%'#*    '#$11-'&"$&! " .+($ .! "#* 4$+) "+($ .$"-'&"$&! " . # '!$1# (&"($&'0// 6 718&/9! 1($)"#" 1 :))&1 " ;'((&+0 &"* <4""+# ("#$&1"4") ""!8&#&0*%'$$") )44'#  +($ .$##$#!"%&(&"(1' ")& "8''11 #"# " ++($

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

90; )&"$# #$#$"!! ">?$"  $#  ""&4"#1#$"#  *  

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