Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-09-25822/2 AI generated

2-09-25822/2 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Põlvas

Case Number 2-09-25822/2
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-09-25822/2 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Põlvas: . " 8"2 +& &"  6+#2.  $'!"&$&)   #" "&!.,  6+#2., 1 " & 2   ..1    "  %  22 $&'&$&",'6&%!&&"&)  2"# .,&"  2 .  22 $&'&$&",'6 & %!&&"&1 6'! 6&&!. % "#  6 8"2 +& &"  6+#2.  $'!"&$&)  :  ; 49  ( "# 2 6&2  "#  % 8" &&" -2 2.3 2.$ & &&" -2 3!# $$,+&2.,-2312 "#  %& $"$ $ !# $$ ,+& $ $ &&"&  $ "   $ ",&.&) :  ; 5 "# 2 !%&"!.&&.&6&2 "!.&&.&6&21 $& $ $2.  ,+& " ,   , "!.&&.&2. 22% ,+& "#  % 2.$ !%& "!.&&& ,+& 2 ) :  ; 5(9  ( "# ,+&% "!.&&.&2. $"2 , "!.&&.& 6 #  "!.&&.&6&2 !%&$",&&,& + 8?.8"2 # 1" &!%&2'&&"  ,+&&,&&,& ,'#$"$8"&'!2,$""!.&&.&2.2 2.2 . !%& .   ,'#$ "#2'. '&2., '# 6 . '',  $$  $&"",. 18%'#" $" $'$& "!!6&2 82+ %" ,+ $&) : ;79('%1"#   %'&,,6&2 ,+&. ) : ;'%1" &"#  '&$&"22'# .'#,+&" &2 $''!, 6&2   1  % "#   '&  '# "1 " & 6&2  ,+&  .& 21'&$&'#6',,+&%$''!,+ .) : ;(((6("#1" &,+2&"2"#  !&"" 2 .1,+&%,+ .2+ . "#  '&$&) : ;(("#1" &,+2&"!&" %!#$"$&"#  1,+&%,+ . 2+ .'&$&) :  ; ((  ( 6 9  '%1  !#& "#   '&$& ,&&,&$& "!! ,+&% ,+ .2+ .,+2&" ,&&,&) :  ; ((4  ( &$2  &2   ',.1  !#& "#   '&$& ,&&,&$& "!! ,+&% ,+ . ,+2&" 1 !, "#   &2+ ," $  $& " 2& "# '&$&2&1 2+ . ,&&,& &2!& -,&&,&3) &&,& $''!" ""',. ;5' .&2!&$''!1$&&2. %&6!2& )  :  ; 5  ( "#1 " & "#    % ,, .  ,+& 6&2   . &2!&1 2 &2!&$''!" 6 " 6  !6 "62 6+#&!<&22!&$&6!&2&. "#., ,&&$2 &2!&$''! 22 &  () 2 !&() &1" &. ,+&6&2 &2'# .&&&)

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text



  

       ! "#    $%&'&        ()  )*+,         

)    -!&!&"./ 000000001 2.&2 '!&2&$&/   ) 1  "#/ 000000000 00 00000 00000003 #& )  ) -&&" "./000000000001 "#/00000000000000000 000000000000003, (4515"!2&'&2., ,&&,&-6!2.&26+#&2+ .3,'$+&$&"     ((771("!2&       ()  )     () &!# ..) ()('$+& ) ) ) &" "(45-8"."$"8$$2."" # "". "#""8$$2. 2&3 "!2& 5 2& ,+1 &2!&  ,&&,& -&  " 2&)9))3"") ()'$+& ) ) ) &" ",&&,&: ;(4(& ' . $''! -)  !6 "62 6+#&!<&22!&$&6!&2&. "#., ,&&$2 &2!&$''!1 $& &2. % 7= 3  4)9)9)  " 2& $6+#&2+ .((771("!2&'&&"  $&2&) ) 22&. &,&&,&$'&.,") 4) >'$2 "  . ) )"2.) 4)(' $+& )  )  )   & " " ( -""&  # ,&&.3 "!2& $2 "  ."") 4) ) )6%$2 "  . $,&&,&,++& . ;((4+&"(&   2'# .    $2 "  .  !  "&2.", #2.& +  $&" 2&'&$&2&)    #" ,&"  ," !  "#  *+, "# $ "2& " .  ()))"(9)

)  )  ,+&% &. " !  "#  *+, "# $   "'&$$&  (5 6', " )  &    % "' &$.



-53 ,'6 & %!&&"& ,+& ,&"  ,"$&1 ,+&% " &.   "'&$$&6'," )

. ' .'#'!&$&"6%$2 %&$'#"" $2 &$&2 1 $& $&"  $2 %& %1 "+& &$ "% ) %  6+#2.$&" ,+& !&&&+&,   $&" ,+& "%  &2, & 6 .  "+!,.$&"1 $& 2  . $2 %& $&1 22% "#  $+&&"  '# 6'! $2 %& 2.$&   #2.$&1 " & 2&$ .  & 2 . & . 6+#2.$ ,+&'#6&"2.$&$'!&)          4)9))  & . #&,.  "# +$&&. #  " ))7)  ,'&"2 6&2 2!744((1$& #2.&"2  $$( "!2&1&2!&$''!(5=$&+66'#()9)(()) 6&2  "# 6&.& " $ 2  6+#&  &2!& & "  () " 6',  $$5(41"!2&)   & '&2 . $ 6&2 '!&. "#  & 2+ "#1 $&+  # & ")())6&2 88$&2&22+ .&,+2,  $&#&$ ()(()))

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

2$2 ." $2.&.""'&$ .  ;.4(( )



4-53  #  &%1  #&  % !# ..     ;. 4    57  (  1"1""# 2$''!2 .,$&'#1&'#-)()  &"3,2 ."# 2.#&2 . $&,+&$&""  2&2 #& 2 #&,.  $'!& .     . +& &"  6+#2. .)

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



5-53    ; 497   ,+&% ,&&,&2+ . " 6+#&2+ . &. #& &1  " ,&&,&1 $& &  #& &$& " , &2+ ," $  2 .1 ,'$+&$& "#  $& "&2.  $$21 ,&. '&&"  ,+& & 6!2.&2 6+#&2+ . " 2& 6+#&2+ . '&$&2&) "+& ,+&% ,&&,& 2+ . &1  "#  $+&"  ,' "&2.  $$2 " 2&   $&2&  .& 6!2.&2 6+#&2+ .)  . .   2 #& +& &"  6+#2. . #&,.  $'!& .  .)

 6% "  $ # (4 515 "!2&1 $& 2 ((771( "!2& $21(41"!2&&2+ ,"$  2 . $&2!4(71 "!2&,&&,&& )9))) '&2.,"  %",'$+&$&,&&,&51=4)9))" 2& $6+#&,+-((771("!2&3'&&"  $&2&: ;((4(&  ' .$''!) : ;((4(& ' .,&&,&$''!#&&$&&19= 2&2()7))2=)     ; (74  (  5 ',. $  # 1   $22 . "#  &% $2 "  .   $2 & ,# "#   ,+& $2  +6, $''! ) 2 "  .   2'% "#  1 $&&. $2 "  . "& $2 &6%"2.$)  2#&!# ."1&& %'#$2 "  .'&&" ""2.   ;(9( ) ',&,&&#&2.-#&#&2.32  ;(5(;(44("#((771( "!2&)  ,  ;(75(+&"4 "# $''!%# "&2." " " #8,&,. $2 "  .1 " & # &% "#  $''! . " $2 "  .2&$"&!)

 2 2 . $2 "  . ,&. !&&&+&,   ( "!2&   ,'$+&$& "-4153)  ;(4("#2$2 "  .$2 &"# "  ."# ,'&. "  .) $ 6!!#,& ) +&" "# "# "  . 2 !&&&+&,1 " 2 2&2  '%&,$&"  .)

26+#2. .# !&&&+&, 1)("!2&1,'$+&$&)    ; 59  ( 6  "#  22&% "#  $   & ,&&,&$ '&.," )    $%&'& # 2&"