Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-09-35391/5 AI generated

2-09-35391/5 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus

Case Number 2-09-35391/5
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

%+ % '! 9&$+   #" '+* !% +'" , #" '+3 !% 1++1+

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-09-35391/5 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus: %+ % '! 9&$+   #" '+* !% +'" , #" '+3 !% 1++1+

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text













  



 

 

 !





"!# $!





 %&''

 













    







()!!&"!# $!%*#+"+#%'!

  



 

  



 





,-#" '+



   



"

+++'!

'# '!.

$+

/+'

+" 0' 11!,-#" '+'&!.)

 

    





$  " +++'! '# '!.* "+"+# .

-2,2* !# $ #"+ 22  +''* +'.

#++# '# 3

#  /+' +" 0' 1* ++#!# . 2((-*

!# $+++'''1.&"!%# '.)

  

"$!.."+++'!'# '!.$+/+'+" 0' 11!)

4 %&+ /+' +" 0' 1  " +++'! '# '!. #!#  ,-

5# %+!$+.#!!#6%%'.1++7#" '+)

!''+.# $! !+1++1+%4+.1#)

 

 



"+++'!'# '!.%'!#!!.4/+'+" 0' 1#'.)







  



"+++'!'# '!.1&+8+.9+ '#8!941 #!*

! #4 +%%+* #!+. %+ $+% #!+ 1++ #!! %::.!%+ "! # $!

!1+#!1#%+* "!+'# ''# $!*#!!!"#8!1&+.#

$'..#+"+#!%'!*#!+#8!+ $'.%++!'+)

/+'+" 0' 11&+8+. "!# $!&"!# $!% !9

#*#!+%1!!*%+ + !%+!#* ++'+!.%&!1

9&$!)  1&+8 +. &!% %&!1 9&$! % !* #!+; 7 $+

1%4%+9!$! +$+#  +%!.#4%!!1+++#!+++#+#!#+"

1! 6'.%+3 7 # $!+!'+ +%!% 4%+ 9!$! + # $!#!  +%!.

#  1&+ % +'. #4 +++ #!+ ++#+#! #+" 1! 6'.%+ 1&+

57

# $!+!'+3 7  ! + 1&+'!. .! # $ $)  1&+8 +.

 ! #4 +%%+  2 941  #! '+' #!+  ! !8

#4  +%. 149  +  8"++#+ 1&+ 1+#! 1#%+* 1&+8 #

+. ! #4 +%%+  ( 941  #!) !+  ! $+

%'!&!*# +1'!.4$# $!1&+++%!'!.+!'+*

!8 # +. #&+#  1%+%+ &9!1++%+# 1+#) '!8+

 %+98%'!8+ .!4!.4$4"+%+#%4$

##%'! +%+'!*%+%+#%'!8+ 8*#&++%#

5 <(,-7)





  !""# "$" #% "# &'# &$##%

#$(##



$! ' # $!'!. #  # $! #+"+#! 1% 2 941  #!  $+

#4 +%%+ 5 7* $ +. %*  #!+ #  # $! %44"!. 4$#

#+"+#!+1* '# $!&+!$+ !"$!..)



+1.! #   +.  %44"! #+"+#! 1! '.%+ # $!! '

#  ++#+#! #4 +%!. ,)!!+5,7) '# .+##1!

'.%+ # $!!) * # # $! ' %44"'!. #+"+#! 1%+ 4$* + 

4$# $!#+"+#!1'!.)



 < 2,  *  # $ 1&+8 # $! $  ! $+  ! "$!..

$+1.! %4"+!.   !. &+!+#! 9&$'.!. !!* #!+ # * #

# $! ' %44"'!. 1%+ 4$* +  4$ 1'!.* ++ #!+ $+  +%+

# #414+"+++1&+#!+ +%+#41+#!)!$! #$+!.

0#++. 14+. #  9  %#1&!# '+'  ! 1&+8  !$! $

# $!+!'+ 9+.%) $! +8*  + +' # ++  < 2,   %4"+!.

 !%+14+1+. !+.)



+  !. # $! +8*  $+ ' $+1.! %4"+!. !!   !.

&+!+#! 9&$'.!. '+' # $! $'.8  < 2,  *  *   4!

"1. !)



<22224+."1.+8# $! !9&$'.1 6#'&+!+#!

9&$'.!)



+1.! # $ %'. $ '&!. #  1! !%%  ,- #" '+) &!.

 1!%+!# '

='$1$&%+!.'&! 1!%+9+')

'

=# &%++.+'"'+1$'.!)' 1%8"+-9+'!)).%8"+-

+# '! !#" '+%+##941#+'"+,#" '+'!

9"+ .+#) # $!!'!!%%+'"++%#%$+%)'!"+#,)

 ''&!.'!.# 9+'!!##+'!.1&'1!+#1+."+%+*#!+.#  '

4'!.$'&!.4$9'!)+!)!!+(1&'8$# ,-#" '+*

%+ % '! 9&$+   #" '+* !% +'" , #" '+3 !% 1++1+

(2#" '+399"$1#" '+3'&!.&+! 1!%+!'1.#!!.#" '+)

+ !.+"+++'!'# '!.$+/+'+" 0' 11!,-

#" '+'&!.)



57

 '$+1.!&+!+#!9&$'.'!.$+%4"+!. !+.*1++.><.

(3,-3(,339**-33(3-2*3-3,)



><-2*# $1&+81&!. %'&!.1&'+#!'&! #!&!%'.

9+'! ! "1+#!' 1&+ + 6 + ++#! 5'&!.  1!%+'7) &!.

 1!%+ !8 !! 1&!. '+ %) > < -   48* 

'!9+'!# $!!86#++#5'!'.7'.%+++#!5'!7"$!%%1&+

'.15'7*'!# $!!8+%#%%"$!%%1&+%

%++#+%# !%#1+.+)><.(3(,*39*

*-# $ '9+'9+'!9 4+%+## $!!+#'+'# $!!!84+11

9+'! 1&+ .!3 #!!!" # $!! "+##!%+' ' 1&!$ !'1 # $!!

4+% 4%+' 1&+ %+# $' 4+%+'* $! 4+%+ 1++1+%+') !+ 1&'+# '

# $!! "+##!'!.* 1&+8 1&!. '&!. # $!! 4+%+* #$! $61+%+  "$+

# $!!4+%+1++1+%+# ""'&!.1++1+)1><.(3,

'99"$19+'!'4$!.9+'!"+##!'!.9+'!9 # $!!%##$!!.

9+'!9  9+'! %44"!. "$!%% '+' %'.!  #!1! '!. '!

!8 %# +'"+) !! '!9+'! # "" !8 +'"+ %# 6#' !$!* #!+  '

# ##!9+!.)



 '$+$+1.!%4"+!.!! !.&+!+#!9&$'.!.'+'$

9 +!.0#++.14+.!8!.# 9  %#1&!#)  8 <

2,! !%+)+ !.#!!!8$+ <2,# $

 !"$!.%+'+'# !8$#!#14%&+,-#" '+)



<2-(9# $!''+8# $! %!+1++1+%4+.1#

 !)



<-# $#''8$+%'!#!!.9 *##$!# !$+) $!*

"$!..$+*48 <-!%'!#!!.# #'.)







$!'+#;