Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-09-33205/4 AI generated

2-09-33205/4 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus

Case Number 2-09-33205/4
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-09-33205/4 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

          

       ! "#    $ %&&                 '()  *%! "# $+"*!*"$&                    % && , -#* )). "!&*&% ,) "!&*          % && , -+!*!*",//////// "# % &012!& +*&, &3*&4 " )  ) + **" ", ///////////+  "# //////// /////////"5//////., /////$"&,)    !# ,,% && , -#* )). *) 2$%* ))% && , -" "!., "&&!////////////  6 7,3&".%*!., "&&!//////////////  1&" 8. #5#""5$$&,5#"9"!&*) &&*,"#  *..*$2*,.")      % && , -$& "  ,2(:;   ))"&, ))$& "  , '0;  % && , -"&,)  

     % && , - .%*3 *, <*&"3   <2. " +    "2*$$*+ " *, $* #*$ " * . "  $==, $* !  "#    .*"  ." $*+ !  *&"&&"# + "  ! "3  .%*," #&,,"*!*" $& +" *"3 *#&,$** &*)

)).%*3*, ! "# %! "# $ <"+" * $ .  + $* *   $*  "+ * *&* , $% . <%# )  .%*3 *, % $ $% . <%#  $ + " *> '9 #* .$2$*< # *#*"*$ ,"2$ .*" ***"*" "*! . 5&,$*49"# * &**$ $2$*< # *"# " *$ ,

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

*.,  "  *,  $22!  "*!*"  .  &,$* "#   & " **"*"  "2*$ , ') *8'9) &",*"".  &,$* "#  ) + " "#  & $22!& , "*!*"  .$* 2#+ *  2#"# "*!*" .& ,)    ? :@  '+  "# .%*3 "#  #   #*   !# ,, #*.,  $2!* ,   , %* *"  <%#&, ,  + " * "+ " "#  & $22!& , .$* 2#+ *  2# .& ,+ ** " * #* *$* ""2.2*!*.%*" **$*"2.*" )  # "#* , A"**, .2*, " < $".% " &*&   .%*3   #  # "# * &* <*,$) #  *3+  * *& " **   ? :@   $2!* ,  $*.2*.*, *,)  # *3+#*&#*., $2!* ,   ,*%* *"  <%#&, ,&*&"  3* !# ,$*)   ?::::"#.%*3"#  < # <%#&,.<!, ,5"& %* *" <%#&, $2!"*$*) 

*.,  "# %$**, <, ')$*  !3*"!,,*<*& + $* "# &,* # " "!,*  "!&*)  * 2*& , <*&  "!!"+ $*%  * # " #* , .%&.   $* "# &*& #* " <*&  55$*)() *"".%&. * & ,+$*% 5#5" %$* , !3*"!,,*<*& )  .%&.  #  &   "!&*+ $* <%#*.%&.  &   "!&*  "%!.&% ,,  "!&* 8 "!&* & <<!#.+ '("!&*&..*"!&*&*&!9)* ,&% 3% && , -#*

)  )  .  .2 $%*   "!&*)  & $ &% , <%#&,$*" "#  *& ,"<*,!3*"!,,*<*& +", ,#* ,80'9) 

&#*., %* *" <%#&,& ,#*$2!* , *,+.,B ?,4 @0'4(:'4'''<')

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

&#*#*., $2!* ,   ,*%* *" <%#&, , &*& # < * , A"**, .2*,  3  , " < $".% ")  3  ?:@'  $*)* ,"  3#*  ?:@  ' "#   * !# ,$* &*& "  3 # " " .2 $%*"!&*)   ?:0('<"# &&*3"# $ *..*$2*,."  )* ,"#  &&*3  ?:0('<  $  *..*$2*,.")    ? '0  ' "# "&&3 #*$&  "  , <+ " "# "   #*) .   ? '0  ' "&&., #* * !# ,$* "!! "&&., <, $& "  , .%!, ,+ " * "#  *  $& "  *, .%!,* #* !# ,$*   .%* * 2 $& "  *, 2**"  .%* * < &,* "&,)

 :8:9 # +!# ,,#**(:;  +23#$& "  ,(:;   ""&,"$& "  ,'0;  #"&,)  .   ? '@:  ' .%*3 &% , !  "#  $& "  , !#* "*&,"$22!$* #&,* *, . "  ,      <2. "   "  ,  "## ,#&,*%  $*)    # &*">