Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-08-90360/3 AI generated

2-08-90360/3 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus

Case Number 2-08-90360/3
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

  58,  /&!- /&+8 # $!! "+##!%+ # "" #!- "-+ /&+ #  #&+#+

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-08-90360/3 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus:   58,  /&!- /&+8 # $!! "+##!%+ # "" #!- "-+ /&+ #  #&+#+

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text















  



 

 

 !





"!# $!





 %&''

 













    







()*!!+&"!# $!%,#+"+#%'!

  



 





   

  



 

&!''!-

.$+ * */!0(0#" '+'&!-*

0#" '+

 

    





&!''!-

.,"+"+# -11111111!# $

23"+&"!+'',+'-"++' #%4

#  *  * , ++#!# - 11111111111, !# $

111111 1111 ! 1111111#3 111111

/-1111%# '-*

  

"$!--&!''!-

.$+ * */! +*

5%&+ * *&!''!-

.#!#"/-!# ' '"((06

7-8'#/&+"/-!# ' '"(00((9'#)(:##!$

3$#-'+#3%%'-3#;#" '+*

!''+-# $! !+/++/+%5+-/#*

 

 



&!''!-

. %'!#!!- 5 ) < !! *  *  #'-  *  *

%'!#!!-(<!!&!''!-

.#'-*







  



&!''!-

. /&+8 +- =+ '#8!  =5/  #!,  !

#5 +%%+, #!+- %+ $+% #!+ /++ #!! %>>-!%+ "! # $! !

/+#! /# %+, "! +'# ''# $!, #!!!" #8! /&+-#

$'--#+"+#!%'!,#!+#8!+ $'-%++!'+*

* */&+8+- "!# $!&"!# $!% !=#,#!+

% /!!, %+ +  ! %+ !#, + +'+!- %&!/

=&$!*  /&+8 +- &!% %&!/ =&$! % !, #!+? (; $+

/%5%+=!$! +$+#  +%!-#5%!!/+++#!+++#+#!#+"

/!3'-%+4;# $!+!'++%!%5%+=!$! +# $!#! +%!-



:);

#  /&+ % +'- #5 +++ #!+ ++#+#! #+" /! 3'-%+ /&+

# $!+!'+4 ;  ! + /&+'!- -! # $ $*  /&+8 +-

 ! #5 +%%+()=5/ #!'+'#!+ !!8

#5  +%- /5=  +  8"++#+ /&+ /+#! /#%+, /&+8 #

+- ! #5 +%%+   =5/  #!* !+  ! $+

%'! &!,  #  + /'!- 5$ # $! /&+ + +%!'!-

+!'+, !8 # +- #&+#  /%+%+ &=!/++%+# /+#*

'!8+ %+=8%'!8+ -!5!-5$5"+%+#

% 5$ # # %'! +%+'!, %+ %+#  %'!8+  8,

#&++%#: @(A;*



 

!""#

"$" #%

"#

&'#

&$##%#$(##



$! ' # $!'!- #  # $! #+"+#! /% () =5/  #!  $+

#5 +%%+ : ((; $ +- %,  #!+ #  # $! %55"!- 5$#

#+"+#! + /, ' # $! &+! $+ /&'/!  +'-!/ /++/+ '&!-

 !"$!--*



+/-! #   +-  %55"! #+"+#! /! '-%+ # $!! '

#  #5 +%!-  @   ( 5!- # "" (0*%+ *  ' # 

-+##/!'-%+# $!!* ,## $! '%55"'!-#+"+#!/%+

5$,+ 5$# $!#+"+#!/'!-*



 @ )A  (,  # $ /&+8 # $! $  ! $+  ! "$!--

$+/-! %5"+!-   !- &+!+#! =&$'-!- !!, #!+ # , #

# $! ' %55"'!- /%+ 5$, +  5$ /'!-, ++ #!+ $+  +%+

# #5/5+"+++/&+#!+ +%+#5/+#!*!$! #$+!-

B#++- /5+- #  =  %#/&!# '+'  ! /&+8  !$! $

# $!+!'+ =+-%* $! +8,  + +' # ++  @ )A  0 %5"+!-

 !%+/5+/+- !+-*



$!+8,$+ '$+/-!%5"+!-!! !- +&+!+#!

=&$'-!-'+'#!!!8 + !"$!-%+*



@))))# $/&+8# $! !=!$!=&$'-/ =++"-!-3#'

&+!+#!=&$'-!%5"#+%+*



+/-! # $ &%++- = - (* !!+  '!=+'!, %+ # $ $

' #  0 #" '+*  + 5+'!- =+'! # ""#, %+&! + $

#  $ +!- /&'/! !%+ # $ '+' $ + #  =+'! 33%+*

/&'/!5$#+!'!-,%+&!3$3# "8+#"-++-+=+'!*

 /&'/! $  ' 0 (0 #" '+, %+ =&$+/&'/! '  0 #" '+ 

#&"/'&!-()0#" '+ '+'"+/&'/!,A)#" '+ '=="$/00#" '+ '

+'/++/+/&'/!*+ !-'&!8&!''!-

.$+ * */!/5

%&+ 0 (0 #" '+*  ' % '&!- =&$'-%+# # $! +'!- # =+-

'!=+'!, #  -!- $ +!- : 0;*  ' # $! +'!- /-!

$+'&!-/5$'-%+#,%+# $ '# /&'/!$A0#" '+:(;*

C @ ) # $ ' "8+#"-++-+=+' #"-++-+=+', %+ % %'-!/&+

#!/!!/#"-++-+'-''8/&+# $!!8'-%"8+#"-+++/&+'!*



:);



$!+8,= /$(*!!+&%+!-'!=+' '"8+#"-++-+=+'C@

) 5$'-!*  '-+ '! % %'-!/! "%, #  ' "8+

/&&+!-!5$'-!*



 '$+/-!&+!+#!=&$'-'!-$+%5"+!- !+-,/++-C@-4

A(4(4(((=(4((*



C @ ) # $ ' "8+#"-++-+=+' #"-++-+=+', %+ % %'-!/&+

#!/! !/ #"-++-+'- ''8 /&+ # $!!8 '-% "8+ #"-+++ /&+ '!*

/C@-A(4(4(!8# $!!5+//=+'!/&+-!*

!+ # $!! 5+%+ 5$=5/ ' #+'-# %55"!- /&+ !'8 /&!$ %!, !8

# $!! 5+  5$=5/, #!!!" # $!! "+##!%+' ' /&!$ !'/

# $!! 5+% 5%+' /&+ %+# $' 5+%+', $! 5+%+ /++/+%+',

/C@(((=(,#!+/&'+# '# $!!"+##!'!-,/&+8/&!-'&!-

# $!!5+%+"$+# $!!5+%+/++/+%+# ""'&!-/++/+*C@((

  58,  /&!- /&+8 # $!! "+##!%+ # "" #!- "-+ /&+ #  #&+#+

-! /&+ =+'! !'/+- &+!#+/$'-+-, %+- 8 3$ #!-, #!+

-!/&+=+'!+!'+++*



C @ )(  ( # $ /&+8 #"-++-+'- %#' / #"-++-+ =!$!

#"-++-+=+'!"8+%#/++/+!&!3>-3#'!$!,#!+"8+ '5++#!/&+

+/++/+!/5$%# %3#+5"'/ %##"-++-+'- ''-'!-

"8+ -!! /5$% #$'5- 5+'-/ 5$ =!!-!55/ !%% !%+# # 

/-!,385$ #! %#!%5%+# ""=+'!3

'&!8# !/&!%+* !'/C@A(!8%'-!/&+#!/!'!-

'!%#+'"+*



C @ ((  ( # $ /&+8 /&!- "$+ # $!! 5+%+ /++/+%+ # ""

'&!- /&'+#! /++/+!+'"+ :/++/+;, "/ # $!! +'&!/# %!!!%+ #!'+

# $ 5+%+'+* !+ =+'! '  '5$!- #&"% +'"+%55" #!+ -!5"'

/++/+%55", #/++/+%55"#=+'!'5$!-+'"+%55"*



C @ )( 58,   "8+#"-++-+=+'! ' -! 5! "8+ #$!#

#&"/#-!/# ##!=3$+'*



+++# $! '()*'!"+# $! !'"((+'!-"8+#"-++-+=+'!

"+##!%+ 5"+, !'-- ! = (0,  "8+#"-++-+=+'! 33%+ !$!#

&%+!- =="$/+ # ##!= ' 3$+', #!' C @ )(0  ( "!"+8 %%'-/

"8+#"-++-+=+'! 5+%+ /++/+%+ 5"+* +%!- &+ + '5  /&+%!

'&!- "8+#"-++-+=+'! # "" 5+%+ /++/+%+ =="$/+*  -! !'/

!8$'&!# =="$/+A)#" '+/5%&+%+#5"$!-%*



 '$+$+/-!%5"+!-!! !- +&+!+#!=&$'-!-

'+' $ =  +!- B#++- /5+- !8 !- #  =  %#/&!#* 

 8 @)A(! !%+*+ !-#!!!8$+ @)A

 ( # $  ! + "$!-%+ '+' #  !8 $ #!# /5

%&+)(#" '+*



@)(=# $!''+8# $! %!+/++/+%5+-/#



):);

 !*+ !-# $!!''+8 @)(=! ! %

!+/++/+%5+-/#*



 @ (  ( # $ #''8 $+%'! #!!- = , # #$!# ! $+*

/  @ (  ( #''/- $+ + "$!-%+ # "" #''/- = -

%'!#!!- /&"- -, #!+ # $! +   %'!#!!+- /&"-+ $+

"$!-%+ !! /&+ + 5 %'!#!!+- 5++#! /&+ + =  '-+ #'-*

$!,"$!--$+ +)<!!,58$%'!#!!-)<!!

# #'-# %'!#!!-(<!!$#'-*



/  @ (A)  ( /&+8 '&!- "! # $! %'!#!!- "$+

#+'-#%55"%+ $'-+ +-!/ #!!-  ! !  =5/  #!  #!!-

 !# $$!-$'-+&!!%+*







$!'+#?