Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-09-24517/4 AI generated

2-09-24517/4 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus

Case Number 2-09-24517/4
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-09-24517/4 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

          

        !"  

#"$!%"   &!' #                 () ""*'+#"$!%", -$'# '$,*"                     %'))."/-/$#!!*'  '*0"..''.'*+"0) 11/1-11$#!!*'          %    - #'#'$!!0 1(  - "$!% 22'( #"-'*0  3' ''$4 $! ))-''$"$!!055555555555-"$!%555555 55555555555555555+555555555)     #%"00 %')).") 3 ,+')) $"$/62$0$""'"%$$7$#!!*' /*') 3  ,+' ) )     $"$   ),'  $"*' , $#0''0'",,- ! 11/1- 11 $#!!*' 3''$" ",'*' .''.' - 1 8 , $#0''0'",,)

"'0$!%"!"'.''.',3'0.$)       ,*"$""0 3))$*0)  

        .+'9 '0 :'!!*$9" ( :3. !!$"-  !" $3!',,'- $"'0 ,' %' , $"' .'' $"" ,;;0",' #" $!%" !" .'$" .$ ,'- #" '*$!$!%"- $" ""# $9" .+'0$ %*00$'# '$",*"-$"'$9"'!%*0,''"*') ) )  .+'9 '0 #" $!%" +#" $!%",   !" : $ - $"' , .""- ,' !'  !" ,' "$- !' '*'"0 ,+ ". :+% ")   .+'9 '0 +", ,+ ". :+% " !,!"- $"'< 7 %' ., 3,':"%"!'%'$! !',"0$3,"".'''$"'''$'$"$'#  ."2*0,'47$!%"'"*'',", 3,':"%"!'$!%"$"!',"0 $!  .+' , '*0  $3 ''' $"' ''$'$" $'#  ." 2*0,' .+'

 67 $!%"'"*'4 (7  !" ' .+'*"0 0" $!% %)   .+'9 '0  !"$3!',,':3. !!$"*'*$"' !""9 $3 !',0 .3 :!! '  9#''$' .+' .'$" .$,'- .+'9 $  '0 !" $3!',,'  1 :3. !!$") "'  !" %' ,*" +"-  $!  ' .*"0 3% $!%" .+' ' ',"*"0 '"*'- "9 $  '0 $+'$   .,',' +:".'','$ . '$) *"9'!,':9,*"9'! 0"3"03%  3#','$ , 3%  $ $ ,*"!','*"- ,' ,'$  ,*"9' !9- $+'',$ 6 =1 /7)    !""# "$" #% "# &'# &$##%#$(## 

!%" !* $!%"*"0 $!  $!%" $'# '$" .,  :3. !!$"  %' $3!',,' 6 (7- %!'0 ,-  $"' $!  $!%" ,33#"0 3% $ $'# '$"'.-!*$!%"+'"%' !"#%"00)  '.0"$!!'0 ,33#"$'# '$"."*0,'$!%""!* $!  ''$'$" $3!',"0 ) ""*'  6 7)  !* $!  0'$ $ ." *0,' $!%"") ! - $ $!%" !* ,33#*"0 $'# '$" .,' 3% -'!3%$!%"$'# '$".*"0) 

 =    - ( $!% .+'9 $!%" %  !" %'  !" #%"00%'.0",3#'"0  !"0+'"'$":+% *0"0""-$"' $! -$$!%"!*,33#*"0.,'3% -'!3%.*"0-'' $"'%'!','$! $3.3'#'''.+'$"'!','$3.'$") "%" !$% '"0>$''0.3'0$! :!!!,$.+"$*'* !" .+'9 "%"%$!%"'"*':'0,) !%"'9-''*$'' =  ,3#'"0 !",'.3'.'0 !"'0)  ' !"0$!%"'9-%'!*%'.0",3#'"0""  !"0 +'"'$":+% *0"0*'*$!%"%*09 = -(-3" #.0  !") 

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

"*. @ = (    "9 , *0" .+' $"." *"0 *" ,$ '*#')  !*%'%'.0",3#'"0""  !"0+'"'$":+% *0"0*'*

 =     $!% $"""9 %'  !" #%"0,'  $!  "9 % $"$.3 ,+'/-/$#!!*'*'*#.0 =(/ 3"  ),'$"*',$#0''0'",,-!11/1-11$#!!*'3''$"",'*' .3 ,+'.''.'-18,$#0''0'",,) 

 = /1   :  $!% "'9 $!%" !, " ' .''.',

 67 3'0.$ !")' !"0$!%""'9 =/1:"  !"!,"'.''.',3'0.$) 

=/$!%$9%',*"$""0:!!-$$% "$!"%')

!%"-#%"00%'- 39 =/",*"$""0$! $*0)  . = .+'9% *+"0 #"$!%",*"$""0#%' $'*0$,33#,' %*0' '0". $""0 !" " ( :3. !!$"  $""0 !"$!%%"0 +"",')   

!%"*'$<