Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-09-3710/5 AI generated

2-09-3710/5 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus

Case Number 2-09-3710/5
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

  + 8 /  8    ! -6 (*& !! 0! 1 #" ,& 

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-09-3710/5 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus:   + 8 /  8    ! -6 (*& !! 0! 1 #" ,& 

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text















  



 

 

 !





"!# $!





% &"

 













    







'(&)*))# $!(+#&"&#(,!

  



 





   

  



 

''$& ' '-!./.+/#" ,&&,0!-

-&&-&,*!0'

1#" ,&

 

    





''+&&#!# 0)))))))))))+!# $)))))

))))))))))+&,0&( +0 #0&23" 

 45","&0+6-7/ &,,8

#  ' ' + &&#!# 0 )))))))))))+ !# $ )))))

)))*))'

  

"$!00''$& ' '-!'

6 (*& ' '  ' '  #!# ./. 9###3((,0 #!! !$ #$#0

#!!#3((,03$#:#" ,&/,&'

6 (*& ' '  ' '  #!# -&&-& 7*$&,*!0+   1   #" ,&  /'

,!"&  #!,& 7*$&,*!0 6&(&,& ; <    6!0 (66"+  

!" 7 #7,&,"&(66"=>'

 !,,&0# $! !&-&&-&(6&0-#'

 

 



''(,!#!!06 ' '#,0'







  



''-*&2&07& ,#2!76- #!+ !#6 &((&+

#!&0 (& $&( #!& -&& #!! (??0!(& "! # $! ! -&#! -#

(&+ "! &,# ,,# $!+ #!!!" #2! -*&0# $,00 #&"&#!

(,!+#!&#2!& $,0(&&!,&'

' '  -*&2 &0 "! # $! )*)) # $!(  ! 7 #+ #!&

( -!!+ (& &  ! (& !#+ & &,&!0 (*!-

7*$!'  -*&2 &0 *!( (*!- 7*$! ( !+ #!&@ : $&

-(6(&7!$! &$&#  &(!0#6(!!-&&&#!&&&#&#!#&"



9:

-!3,0(&8:# $!&!,&&(!(6(&7!$! &# $!#! &(!0

#  -*& ( &,0 #6 && #!& &&#&#! #&" -! 3,0(& -*&

# $!&!,&8 :  ! & -*&,!0 0! # $ $'  -*&2 &0

 ! #6 &((&176- #!,&,#!& !!2

#6  &(0 -67  &  2"&&#& -*& -&#! -#(&+ -*&2 #

&0 ! #6 &((&  / 76-  #!' !&  ! $&

(,! *!+  #  & -,!0 6$ # $! -*& & &(!,!0

&!,&+ !2 # &0 #*&#  -(&(& *7!-&&(&# -&#'

,!2& (&72(,!2& 0!6!06$6"&(&#

( 6$ # # (,! &(&,!+ (& (&#  (,!2&  2+

#*&&(#9 </.:'



 

!""#

"$" #%

"#

&'#

&$##%#$(##



$! , # $!,!0 #  # $! #&"&#! -(  76-  #!  $&

#6 &((& 9 .: $ &0 (+  #!& #  # $! (66"!0 6$#

#&"&#!&-+ ,# $!*&!$& !"$!00'



&-0! #   &0  (66"! #&"&#! -! ,0(& # $!! ,

# &&#&#!#6 &(!0'7"&&9:' ,# 0&##-!

,0(& # $!!' + # # $! , (66",!0 #&"&#! -(& 6$+ & 

6$# $!#&"&#!-,!0'



 < 1  +  # $ -*&2 # $! $  ! $&  ! "$!00

$&-0! (6"&!0   !0 *&!&#! 7*$,0!0 !!+ #!& # + #

# $! , (66",!0 -(& 6$+ &  6$ -,!0+ && #!& $&  &(&

# #6-6&"&&&-*&#!& &(&#6-&#!'!$! #$&!0

A#&&0 -6&0 #  7  (#-*!# ,&,  ! -*&2  !$! $

# $!&!,& 7&0(' $! &2+  & &, # &&  < 1  B (6"&!0

 !(&-6&-&0 !&0'



&  !0 # $! &2+  $& , $&-0! (6"&!0 !!   !0

*&!&#! 7*$,0!0 ,&, # $! $,02  < 1  +  +  B 6!

"-0 !'



<11116&0"-0&2# $! !7*$,0- 3#,*&!&#!

7*$,0!



&-0!# $*(&&07 0!!*,&7&,!+(&# $7&0&$ (

62&# -$,0!)))))))#&,,&!-66"!B#" ,&'5 077&&0# ##!+

-$,0!!!!"! ,1#" ,&+(&#" ,&#,0&$-$(&#!'

!!,&#!,&'!!&# 7,# , ',!0!((&,0!-#" ,&

!"$+ (& ,& #  3 )*)) &,, /' # 2"& '  !,- , # 

,!0 # ##! 1 #" ,& -$,0!! 0!+  $&, *(&# # ##!7&!0

&,&(!' ##!77# $7&0&#&,,&!(33# &(!($&('0(2"'

$&,!(&#&&#&&6&,!0#&,,&!-",0&# (,0&&#!'6$!0

 !+  #  , ,!0 -$,0!! 0!+   &(!2 ))))))) #&,,&! (33#

$0# $!!# &  (7 *&6&,!0,&,# $!!6&(&,

#!-&#!& ,(", (,&#!-$!(&*!+ ,# ,!0!!1



9:

#" ,&' ,*!2# &!!0!0!0#!+(&# ,&,"&0

,!0"$#&,,&$ &0(&'  ,# $!!0!(&#7*$&-*,-!#

&," 9-$(&#! '0(2"',!":!((/.+/#" ,&'

& !0,*!2''$& ' '-!;<0.818878

  + 8 /  8    ! -6 (*& !! 0! 1 #" ,& 

-&&-&0/.+/#" ,&+#!,&# $!!*7&#!6&(&,&;<!'  ,

(,*!07*$,0(&## $!&,!0# 7&# 0!0,*!0#&"9:'



;<.# $!2# $!!6&--7&,!-*&0!'-;

<8/872&&#,0(&&&#!-6(*&!&#!!

0!,&,#!&&&#9: ,&&&#!93,0:(&0&,!0 ( --*&!-

# $!!6&(&,+-*&23,00!&,*!0+#!&# $!!&  (+

# $!!&#&-*&#!&# $!!,2$&(6",&,,&(!0!$!-*&23,0

&,*!00!0!0#!'



;<# $ ,# $!!"&##!(&,-*!$!,-# $!!6&(6(&,

-*&(&# $,6&(&,+$!6&(&-&&-&(&,,&,--;<0

 -*&2 "$& # $!! 6&(& -&&-&(& # "" -*!0 ,*!0 -*,&#!

-&&-&!&,"&9-&&-&:+"-# $!!&,*!-#(!!!(&#!,&# $6&(&,&'

&&-&(66"# #;<16!0&,"&(66"+(&&,0!2&7" ,&

'



 , $& $&-0! (6"&!0 !!   !0 *&!&#! 7*$,0!0 ,&,

$7  &!0 A#&&0-6&0!2!0# 7  (#-*!#'  2

<1! !(&9B:'& !0#!!!2$& <1

  # $  ! "$!0(& ,&, #  !2 $ #!# -6 (*&

# ##!./.+/#" ,&,&,"-0 <.6!-&&-&7*$&,*!0+ 1

#" ,&/',!"&#!,&7*$&,*!06&(&,&;<6!0(66"

9 !" 7 #7,&,"&(66"=>:'





<1./7!!,,&2# $! (! !&-&&-&(

6&0-#'



<.# $#,,2$&(,!#!!07 +##$!# !$&' $!+

"$!00$&+62 <.!(,!#!!0# #,0'



-  < 1   -*&2 $ ,*!0 "! # $! (,!#!!0 "$&

#&,0#(66"(& $,0& &0!- #!!0  ! !  76-  #!  #!!0

 !# $$!0*!!(&'





$!,&#@