Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-09-17901/4 AI generated

2-09-17901/4 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus

Case Number 2-09-17901/4
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

"#  * '44!* , -'% 4#) %  4# -* ,) %% " % #% %'%

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-09-17901/4 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus: "#  * '44!* , -'% 4#) %  4# -* ,) %% " % #% %'%

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text













   







 





! "# 





$%!

 













    







&'%(! "# ')"%!%"'* 

  



 

  



 





++"!*%



   



!,%%,%"#%

&

&- +"!*%*( ,&

 

    





#





!,%%,%")

!%!%",

.//.)

 "# 0( . %) %*, !- -) 0 %* 

*" $1

"

&

& ) %%" ", 22222222222)  "#

2(222(22223222(2222222(222222222&

  

!# ,,

!,%%,%"#%

&

&- &

4'(%

&

&

!,%%,%"" "+5-%% #3#""3''*,3#"6

"!*%&

%,"#  %-%%-%'4%,-"&

 

 





!,%%,%"'* "  ,4

&

&"*,&

4'(%

&

& 

!,%%,%"" "'* "  .+5"' #-%%,6

"!*%&

4-   (  '%  " *% 4%'%*%  7

&

&  , '* "  

-%%-%8

9.% *4# ,  &







  





 !,%%,%" -(%7 %, :%*"7  . :4- " )   

"4%''%) " %, '% #%' " % -%% "  ';;, '% !  "#   

-%"  -" '%) !  %*""# ) "  ! "7  -(%,"

#*,,"%!%" '* )" %"7 %#*,'%% *%&

&

&  -(%7 %, !  "#  (!  "# '   : ") " %

'-  )'%% '% ")%%*% ,'( -:(# &

5/6

-(%7%,( ''( -:(# ' )" %<6#%-'4'%

: #  % #% " %' , "4 '  -%%% " % %%"%"  "%! - 

3*,'%16"# % *%%' '4'%: # %"# " %' ,"

-(%'%*,"4%%" %%%"%" "%!- 3*,'%-(%"# % *%1

.6   % -(%* , ,  "# #&  -(%7 %,  

"4%''%  / :4- "  *%* " %    7 "4 %',

-4: %  7!%%"% -(% -%"  -"'%) -(%7 " %,  

"4%''%=:4-" & % #%'* ( )

"%-* ,4#"# -(%%%' * ,% *%) 7"%,"(%"

 -'%'% (: -%%'%" -%"& * 7% '% :7 '* 7%

, 4 ,4#4!%'%"'4#""'* %'%* )

'%'%"'* 7%7)"(%%'"5 

9=>6&





  !""# "$" #% "# &'# &$##%

#$(##



#  * "# * , " "#  "%!%"  -'  :4- "   #%

"4%''% 5 .>6) #%, ')  " % " "#  '44! , 4#"

"%!%" %-)*"# (% #% !# ,,&



%-,  "  %,  '44!  "%!%"  -  *,'% "#   *

""4%' , 

9.4 ,"!!&:!%%5.6&

*

" ,%" " - *,'%"#  &)""# * '44!* ,"%!%" 

-'%4#)%4#"# "%!%" -* ,&





 9 /  ) . "# -(%7 "#  #   #%   !# ,,

#%-,  '4!% ,   , (% %"  :(#*, ,  ) " % ") "

"#  * '44!* , -'% 4#) %  4# -* ,) %% " % #% %'%

""4-4%!%%%-(%" %%'%"4-%" &

 # "#% ,

?"%%, -4%, " : '"-( " *%*   -(%7   #  #

"# % *% :%,'& #  %7)  % %* " %% 

 9 /  + '4!% ,

 '%-4%-%, %,&



%  , "#  %7)  #% * #%-,  '4!% ,     ,

(% %"  :(#*, , *%* "#  #*,7 

 9 /  )  .)  + 4 

!-, &





9////4%,!-,%7"#  :(#*,-3"*(% %" 

:(#*, &



%-,  "# ('%%, :, .&:!%% = * :%* ) '% % "

"%%!* 3'% @@@& !/& *   ''  "!*%& A, ::%%, """ ) 

""#  7*  '':%* ('%'% ++"!*%'#%'.&'%"

=&* :%* :&&"#*#(% *( ,:%*  *-'""#  

'%*( "# 4%'% " -%%-% )+ B "*,!%:4-&

%-,  %'%

% -(*7"#<:(#%-("!*%):%* ('%'% ++"!*%

-%%-%+/"!*%&% ,*( 7

!,%%,%"#%

&

&- +"!*%

 '%)'%:(#%-(*- *++"!*%-%%-%,+/"!*%&

*'*( ,

:(#*,'%" "#  %* , ":%, *    %*? %%" *,' !%!!%'%

"#)* :%* 3,%*%' ,)"% ,,#% ,&

.5/6



*#%-, (% %" :(#*,* ,#%'4!% , %,)-%%,8

9,

>1=11:)>1.>'%,"#"#  7* :%* 3"%%"

5* *,6*,'%%%" 5* 6!# ''-(%*,-5*6)* 

"#  7%'"'!# ''-(%''%%"%'" '

"-%,%&#   74%--:%* -(%, *%*" %"#  4%'%

4#:4- * "%*," '44! , -(%  *7 -( # ' )  7 "#   4% 

4#:4-1"  !"#  !%"" '%**-( # *-"#  4%'4'%*

-(%'%"#*4%'%*)# 4%'%-%%-%'%*& %-(*%"*"#  !%"" * ,)

-(%7-( ,*( ,"#  4%'%)!#%"#  4%'%-%%-%'%"!!

*( ,-%%-%&



*#%#%-, '4!% ,   ,(% %" :(#*, ,*%*#

:% ,?"%%,-4%, 7 ,":'"-( "&

7 

9

/  '%&% ,"  7#% 

9/"#

 !# ,'%*%*" 7#" "-4'(%+"!*%&





9/>=:"# %7"# ' %-%%-%'4%,-"

 &





9>"#"7#%'* "  ,:)""# " #%&# )

!# ,,#%)47 

9> '* "  ,""*,&



- 

9/.'44!7"# #  "%*,"""

#3-%-,'* "  ,)" %#%7"# '44! ,"'* "  ,*%'"%!&

 * * , " -4 '(% '* "  * #%-,  %'%   ,

!%%%(%-   "!*% *%* %*, '" ,   (% 7%   + "!*%&

 *

%* ,'* "  ,*%'"%!'* "  %,(*,-,," '*,%,5>6





9,.=)"#*'* "  ,'* %"# "  ,"# -4%,

"  ,) "  ! "# "  , * !%%%(%-) " * *%*  47%-'% "  ,& , 

!-, 7"#" "-4'(% 

9,.=1.:1. 

#%-, %'%  ,!%%%(%-"!*%&



- 

9//:*"# -4%,"  ,'* %%*,*( "  ,&



9+)/"#)" %'* %*:7'* "  , "%*,"'44!-

"# #*,% "# "*,' % '* % %*,* , :%* % %*, "  ,)

'(%7 "#  "  , -4 :(#*, ,  -%"   ) "  ! 7!%%% % 

"#7 :%* % %*, "  , % '* % %*( ,'% :%%!'44!,&

7!%%%% /&:'7!%='44! *!.:%* %%*,*( "  ,

%'* %%*( ,'%:%%!'44!,"#*%-%%#%" *%

"!*%'"%'%*( -"  +"!*%&



,  4# , *%* " * " %  # %*, '* "  , - -4%%,

%* ,7"#  

9+ +"!*%#%*,:(#*, "-%" "

"  "&





 9    "# "#  '4!%7 '* "  , "%*,"'44!'% * , %%" 

-,    '* "  , "%*,"'44!'% #*,%)  #3-%'% "  -

'* "  , 7 ,'* "  , ! "%*,"-#*,%(  '%

/5/6

" *%4%'%*%-%%-%8

9.% *4# ,  &-8

9.

!#% "#   4%'% -%%-%'% "!! -(%7 -( , *( , -(*%" 

-%%-% %*!% 5-%%-%6) !- "#   %*( -" '  '% " *% "# 4%'%*%&

%%-%'44!""8

9/4 ,%*!%'44!)'%%*, 7%:!*%

&



% ,"# %7)" *"#  4%#'* "  ""*,*%*

!-, 

9/ .4 -(%7"# #  "%*,"

'44!""#3-%-,'* "  ,)"%'* "  ,"%*,"'44!'%

- -4%%,%* ,) 7"

&

&-4'(%

!,%%,%"" "'* "  *

!%%%(%-"!*%#%*,"   ''+"!*%)""" '* "  .

+"!*%& 7 (  '%" *%4%'%*% ,'* "  -%%-%

8

9.% *4# ,  &





 9 =  )  "# 7 -%, , '* "  ,   *%* '* "  ,

"%*,"'44!'%)" %"7 #%*,37."!*%&





# *%"<