Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-09-14650/4 AI generated

2-09-14650/4 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus

Case Number 2-09-14650/4
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-09-14650/4 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

          

        !"  

#"$!%"   &!' #                 ()*'+#"$!%"* ,$'# '$*-"                    +"--". & %' /) )  0"   $#!!-'  '-."00''0'-+".) $#!!-'          +"--". &,#'#'$!!.1,"$!% +"-23#-",'-.  -4'-5 $! /)),''$"$!!.66666666666,"$!%6666666 6633666666666)    #%"..+"--". &%'/))0"!') 3 *+'/))+"--". &$"$#0."$!-!-#1 7 8.4-$0+'#0."$!-!-# (2-$(9$%$"% -'.:%$$:-.:%$;$#!!-')

"--'.$!%"!"'0''0'*3'.0$)      +"--". &*-"$"". 3(<""/))$-. /))*-"$"". <""+"--". &$-.)  

     +"--". & 0+'4 '. ='!!-$4" 1 =30 !!$",  !" $3!'**', $"'. *' %' * $"' 0'' $"" *>>."*' #" $!%" !" 0'$" 0$ *', #" '-$!--$!%", $" ""# $4" 0+'.$ %-..$'# '$"*-",$"'$4"'!%-.*''"-') /))0+'4'. #"$!%"+#"$!%"*  !"=$ ,$"'* 0"", *' !'  !" *' "$, !' '-'". *+ "0 =+% ")

 0+'4'.+"**+ "0=+% "!*!",$"'?;%'0* 3*' ="%" !' %' $!  !'*". $3 *"" 0''' $"' ''$'$" $'#  0" :-.*'5 ; $!%"'"-' '*"* 3*' ="%" !' $!%"$" !'*". $!  0+' * '-.  $3 '' $"' ''$'$" $'#  0" :-.*' 0+'

 9; $!%"'"-'5 1;  !" ' 0+'-". ." $!% %)   0+'4 '.  !" $3!'**'=30 !!$"-'-$"' !""4 $3 !'*. 03 =!! '  4#''$' 0+' 0'$" 0$*', 0+'4 $  '. !" $3!'**'  ( =30 !!$") "'  !" %' *-" +",  $!  ' 0-". 3% $!%" 0+' ' '*"-". '"-', "4 $  '. $+'$   0*'*' +="0''*'$ 0 '$) -"4'!*'=4*-"4'! ."3".3%  3#'*'$ * 3%  $ $ *-"!'*'-", *' *'$  *-"4' !4, $+''*$ 9 @(A;)    !""# "$" #% "# &'# &$##%#$(## 

!%" !- $!%"-". $!  $!%" $'# '$" 0*  =30 !!$"  %' $3!'**' 9 ; %!'. *,  $"' $!  $!%" *33#". 3% $ $'# '$" ' 0, !- $!%" +'" %' 0+-0"  '-."0 0''0' -+".  !"#%"..)  '0." $!!  '.  *33#" $'# '$" 0" -.*' $!%"" !- $! $3!'*". @13".$!##)=#''91;)!- $!  .'$ $ 0"-.*'$!%"") ! ,$$!%"!- *33#-".$'# '$" 0*'3% ,'!3%$!%"$'# '$"0-".) 

 @ A  , 1 $!% 0+'4 $!%" %  !" %'  !" #%".. %'0." *3#'".   !". +'"'$" =+% -.". "", $"' $! , $ $!%" !- *33#-". 0*' 3% , ' ! 3% 0-"., '' $"' %' !'*' $! $303'#'''0+'$"'!'*'$30'$") "%"!$% '". B$''. 03'. $!  =!! !*$0+"$ -'-  !" 0+'4  "%" % $!%"'"-' ='.*) !%" '4,  ' '- $ ''  @ A   *3#'".  !"*'03'0'. !"'.) 

!%"'4,%'!-%'0."*3#'".""  !".!'+'"'$" =+% -.".-'-$"""4!' !"#%".*') 

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

 19;  C @  $!% !- #4' $#.''.'='- $#.''.'='-, *' !* * -."0+' $"0" "0 $#.''.'-.  --4 0+' $!%""4 -.* #4'  $#.''' 0+' -") 0C@.A5(5"4$!%""3'00='-"0+'.")

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

@(=""--'4$!%" !"!*"'0''0'* 3'.0$) 

 @    $!% $--4 %'*-" $"". =!!, $ $% "$ !" %') 0 @1$--0.%'!'#%".*'$!##=!!.*-"$"". 0+#.!.,$"'$!%"' !*-"$""'.0+#.'%'#%".*'""0+' ' 3 *-"$""'. 3''$" 0+' !' =!! -.' $-.) !%", #%".. %'

 9; !' (  < "", 34 %  *-"$"".  ( < "" $!  $-.  $!  *-"$"".<""% $-.)  0  @ A   0+'4 -+". #" $!%" *-"$"". #%' $'-.$*33#*' %-.' '."0 $"". !" " 1 =30 !!$"  $"". !"$!%%".%-.' +""*')   

!%"-'$?