Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-08-83068/6 AI generated

2-08-83068/6 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus

Case Number 2-08-83068/6
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

#      " -  -7#,26 # -%%-% ,*  ,%, ,* 6 " -%%-%

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-08-83068/6 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus: #      " -  -7#,26 # -%%-% ,*  ,%, ,* 6 " -%%-%

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text















   







 





! "# 





$%!

 













    







&'(%)*! "# (+"%!%"(, 

  



 





   

  



 

$ "%- .%,, #% ' '  -  //0+)1 "!,%

,* 2'

0+1&"!,%

 

    





# $ "%- .%,,+ !%!%"2 /&11&)+

 "#3* %,,+

%,2

%-!,!+ $3 %, ,"4

" ' ' + %%" "2 55555555555+ #%-2 

"# "#555555555*55+%"-%%6%(%"#

2('

  

!# 22 $"%-.%,,#%''- '

7(*%'' $"%-.%,," "//08"  #9"2-%%%:"!,%

)1,%'

,,%2"#  %-%%-%(7%2-"'

 

 



$"%-.%,,(, "  27''",2'

7 (*% ' '  $ "%- .%,, " " (, "    0 8"(  #

-%%"9((,2:"!,%'

7- *  (%" ,%7%(%,% 6'' 2(, "  

-%%-%;

<///% ,7# 2  '







  



$ "%- .%,, -*%6 %2 =%,"6   =7- " +   

"7%((%+ " %2 (% #%( " % -%% "  (>>2 (% !  "#   

-%"  -" (%+ !  %,",,"# + "  ! "6  -*%2"

#,22"%!%" (, +" %"6 %#,2(%% ,%'

' '  -*%6 %2 !  "#  *!  "# (   = "+ " %

( -  + (% %   (%  "+ % %,% 2 (* -



81:

=*# '  -*%6 %2 * ( (* - =*#  ( + " %? /: #%

-(7(%= # %#%"%( 2"7( -%%%" %%%"%" "%!

- 9,2(%4:"# % ,%%( (7(%= # %"# " %( 2

" -*% ( %,2 "7 %% " % %%"%"  "%! -  9,2(% -*%

"# % ,%4 :   % -*%, 2 2  "# #'  -*%6 %2

  "7%((%/1=7-" ,%," %  6

"7 %(2 -7= %  6!%%"% -*% -%"  -"(%+ -*%6 "

%2   "7%((%   =7- " '  %   #%

(,  * +  " % -, 2 7# "#  -*% % %( , 2

% ,%+  6 " %2 "*%"  -(%(% *= -%%(%" -%"'

, 6%(%=6(, 6%2 7 27#7!%(%"

( 7# " " (, %(%, + (% (%"  (, 6% 6+

"*%%("8 

</&:'



 

!""#

"$" #%

"#

&'#

&$##%#$(##



#  , "# , 2 " "#  "%!%"  -( #%2 (+  " % "

"#  (77! 2 7#" "%!%"  % -+ , "#  *%  #%  

!# 22'



%(!%2+(%,2 2#=,7%2 2"2!%555555555*55,

"#  =%   =  2 #% 7# (>>2 (% 8 ):' #-%" !%!%

,2( , "  "# (7!% 2 %   7=  8 :' # "!2,%"  *%,2%

"# " %  2!% 55555 55 5*55  1/:' * , @%%=!A" !% *! 

=%%",,- "#''2!%5*55555555555555( 

-%%6%(%"# , 2( 8 10:'

 6 " (, 2" (,%2 -%"" 

"7%((% 8 11:'  , "# (77! 2  #%(!%2 -%" 

"7%( 2 -2(% (%" 2,, /' (7!% ) 8 1):' -%" 

"7%((%6"# !-2 

</&07 (, 2" (,2%2

" "7%( "'

 , " 2%" " -  ,2(% "#  ' +

" "#  , (77!, 2 "%!%"  -(% 7#+ %  7# "#  "%!%" 

-, 2'# %6+%%,"%% 

<1&0(7!% 2 (%

-7%-%2 %2'% 2#,26 

<1&/++0+0/7%2!-2

#% '



#  %6+  #% , #%-2  (7!% 2     2 *% %" 

=*#,2 2,%,"  6 !# 2(%'





 < 1&  /+  "# -*%6 "#  #   #%   !# 22

#%-2  (7!% 2   2 *% %"  =*#,2 2  + " % "+ "

"#  , (77!, 2 -(% 7#+ %  7# -, 2+ %% " % #% %(%

""7-7%!%%%-*%" %%(%"7-%" '

 # "#% 2

A"%%2 -7%2 " = ("-* " ,%,   -*%6   #  #

"# % ,%=%2('



 < 111 1   -*%6 "#    = #  =*#,2-  =%%!2 2 9",

*% %" =*#,2 (7!"%(%'



%-2 "#*(%"

 %'(% (6%%%2, 

=%, +(% 

 %"#  ="" (""(( ,%"%,%, 



81:

,%,""#  2 2" =2B, *%! ! (--

% 2 !-'  "    % 

 = ="  2 " = B , %2+ " %2 7%

,,2   (+ !%"" 2  = -# *(% 2 =%,  %,%( %'

%  '

,-(6!%  , " -*,-  

   %   (( 0+ 1& "!,%' (

"%!2=%, "%,,%%2=2+"#  -27%(=%, # ( "%"-

  (6%%%2,  " (% %,%( %' - 92%,%(  "#   "

 ( !-2 /0 =7- "  ,,2 %(% ,%, " , "#  2 ("(%

-%%-%(% "!!  ( -%%-% + /0 C ("(% "  -  (( % ("(%

-%%-% 2=7-+" %2(%-7#(" %"!,%' %

- #,* 2

"-  ((0+1&"!,%+(%%,2 -2-%%-%2'

,!-, 2-%%-%

=!%2% ' ,-(6!  " ,% '2(6!    (( &/+ "!,%'  2

#      " -  -7#,26 # -%%-% ,*  ,%, ,* 6 " -%%-%

 (% ((0&+1&"!,%'% 2,* 6 $"%-.%,,#%''- 

//0+)1 "!,%  (%+ (% =*#%-*,-  , 0+1& "!,% ,%, -%%-%2  0&+ 1&

"!,%



,#%-2 *% %" =*#,2, 2#%(7!% 2 %2+-%%2;

<2

&/4/4/4///=/++<&/+<///+(%2"# 6"#  7%

-- =%,  -*% 2 + "  ! "#   !%"" (%, , -* #  ,-

"#   7%( 7(%, -*% (%"#, 7%(%,+ #  7%(% -%%-%(%,'  %

-*,%","#  !%"" , 2+-*%6-* 2,* 2"#  7%(%!#%"#  

7%(%-%%-%(%"!!,* 2-%%-%'#%"#  7%(%-%%-%(%"!!-*%6

-* 2 ,* 2 -*,%"  -%%-% %,!% 8-%%-%:+ !- "#   %,* -"

(  (%" ,%"#7%(%,%'



 , #% #%-2  (7!% 2     2 *% %"  =*#,2 2 ,%,

#=% 2A"%%2-7%2 6 2"=("-* "'

6



<1&/  (%'% 2"  6#% 

<1&/

"# !# 2(%,%," 6#" "-7(*%//0+

)1"!,%'





<1/="# ,,%6"# ( %-%%-%(7%2-"

 '% 2"#  ,,%6 

<1/=  (

 %-%%-%(7%2-"'





<//"#",,6#%(, "  2=+""# " #%'# +

!# 22#%+76 

<// (, "  2"",2'



- 

</&1/(77!6"# #  "%,2"""

#9-%-2(, "  2+" %#%6"# (77! 2"(, "  2,%("%!'

,, 2"-7(*%#%-2 %(%  2!%%%*%-0"!,%+

(, 2" (,%2 "7%((% (%" 2 2,22 " 2    2 !%%%*%- /

"!,%  (""7  "%%!(,  -2  %(%   2 !%%%*%-  "!,% ,%,

%,2(" 2 *% 6%(""7 "%%!(, #%(, 0"!,%

81&+00:'





<2//+"#,(, "  2(, %"# "  2"# -7%2

"  2+ "  ! "# "  2 , !%%%*%-+ " , ,%,  76%-(% "  2' -



</)=/+ 6!%%%*%-  2#%,%,!%%%*%-  ! * 6%-%%

#%,,+ " % 2  %   ,7# 2 %%% ,%, -- 

 < /1 = 0 , 



181:

76%-(%"  2-7,2(%" 2 2,22-*%#" -*%-2(%

"  2'





</11=&"#,"# -7%""  "(""7 "%%!(, "  2 # +" %

(""7 "%%!(, -2 7%(77! !# 2( 

<1= +-7

!- 2+" %#%,(,* 2% 2#%(" %9"" =7!"%%!(, *== '



2 7# 2(*%6"# "#" "-7!-2 

<2//+

4 < /1 = 04 /11 = & 7  "# "  , !%%%*%-  #%-2  %(% 0 "!,%+

!%%%*%-   -2(%  -7,2 (%" 2 2,22 / "!,%  (""7 

"%%!(, "  2 (("!,%'



- 

</11=/,"# -7%2"  2(, %%,2,* "  2'



</&0/+1"#+" %(, %,=6(, "  2 "%,2"(77!-

"# #,2% "# ",2( % (, % %,2, 2 =%, % %,2 "  2+

(*%6 "#  "  2 -7 =*#,2 2  -%"   ' 6!%%% %  "#6

=%, % %,2 "  2 % (, % %,* 2(% =%%!(77!2' 6!%%%

%  1'=(6!%  (77!  ,! /& =%, % %,2  ,*  "  2 %

(, %%,* 2(%=%%!(77!2"#,%-%%#%,," ,%/"!,%

("%(%,* -"  0"!,%'



2  7# 2 ,%, " , " %  # %,2 (, "  2 - -7%%2

%, 26"#  

</&0 0"!,%#%,2=*#,2 "-%" "

"  "'





 < /&&   "# "#  (7!%6 (, "  2 "%,2"(77!(% , 2 %%" 

-2    (, "  2 "%,2"(77!(% #,2%+  #9-%(% "  -

(, "  2 6 2(, "  2 ! "%,2"-#,2%*  (%

" ,%7%(%,%-%%-%;

<///% ,7# 2  '-;

<///

!#% "#   7%(% -%%-%(% "!! -*%6 -* 2 ,* 2 -*,%" 

-%%-% %,!% 8-%%-%:+ !- "#   %,* -" (  (% " ,% "# 7%(%,%'

%%-%(77!"";

<)17 2%,!%(77!+(%%,2 6%=!,%

'



% 2"# %6+" ,"#  7%#(, "  "",2,%,

!-2 

 < /&1 /    7  -*%6 "#  #     "%,2"

(77!""#9-%-2(, "  2+"%(, "  2"%,2"(77!(%

- -7%%2%, 2+ 6"''-7(*% $"%-.%,," "(, "  ,

!%%%*%- """  00 "!,%   # %,2 "    ((  0 "!,%+ """  

(, "    0 "!,%'   6    *  (% " ,% 7%(%,%  2

(, "  -%%-%;

<///% ,7# 2  





</&/"#6-%2 2(, "  2 ,%,-- 

</&

  6 -%2 2 (, "  2 "%,2"(77!(%+ " % "6  #%,2 96 

"!,%'





# ,%"?