Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-09-10367/4 AI generated

2-09-10367/4 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus

Case Number 2-09-10367/4
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-09-10367/4 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus: 8,.)'''$"6," 8#%"))/*',./ 6,8+,"  $!%""9')$)#%"))/*'))''$' )$!" ) $/'.'( !%"""95'//<',"/*'.",',$"'$!%""5')' 5%<5/ !, $',.$ )55#". /*' ",9 /*"% !)"+ "9 $!%"" 5'  5%<5/3$" ""#$!%""#'$$")',!,/*"%",/$!%""5') 5)', /*')'$!%,5')',+%"5')'/''/')',( "'/*,'$!,$!%""#'$$",".+ /*'9/*". ,*".$!%""5')'+ #%'$!%""5')'/''/')'$!## ,*"./''/'(  !,%'%'/.")5#'".""  !".*'"'$"<*% ,.".,',%  <!!'".?$''./5'."9".$! <!!!)$/*"$(  !9 ; 1 " !")'(' !".$"""9%' ;1 $!%  !"#%".)',',$! "9% $"$/5 )*'0$#!!,'( 

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

         

        !"  

#"$!%"   &!' #                 ()'*#"$!%") +$'# '$),"                -$#!!,'       #.''.'$%'( (/"0$#!!,',*".(          %  

#.''.'$+ #'#'$!!. 11 + "$!% 2*  ',,+ ',.  #/! /+ 2"'," ,$! &3 $! ( (+''$"$!!.44444444444+"$!%44444444 (    #%".. #.''.'$%'( (/"( 5 )*'( ( #.''.'$$"$06$"""%$!)./''$7)),. 7%$8$#!!,'(

",,'.$!%"!"'/''/')5'./$(       #.''.'$),"$"". 5( ($,.( 5 )*'( ( #.''.'$$"$),"$""16,'"%8$#!!,'(

5!/ !" *"")'  $",' 5')',' "9 ( ( ". ),"$"" /''/':;'",5%".""(  

      #.''.'$ /*'9 '. <'!!,$9"  <5/ !!$"+  !" $5!'))'+ $"'. )' %' ) $"' /'' $"" )==.")' #" $!%" !" /'$" /$ )'+ #" ',$!,,$!%"+ $" ""# $9" /*'.$ %,..$'# '$"),"+$"'$9"'!%,.)''",'( ( (/*'9'. #"$!%"*#"$!%")  !"<$ +$"') /""+)'!' !")'"$+!'','".)* "/<*% "(   /*'9'.*"))* "/<*% "!)!"+$"'>8%'/) 5)'<"%"

618 !'%'$! !')".$5)""/'''$"'''$'$"$'# /"7,.)'38 $!%"'",' ')") 5)' <"%" !' $!%"$" !')". $!  /*' ) ',.  $5 ''' $"' ''$'$" $'#  /" 7,.)' /*' $!%"'",'3 8  !" ' /*',". ." $!% %(   /*'9 '.  !" $5!'))'  1 <5/ !!$" ,', $"'  !" "9 $5 !'). /5 <!! '  9#''$' /*' /'$" /$)'+ /*'9 $  '. !" $5!'))'-<5/ !!$"( "' !"%'),"*"+ $! '/,".5%$!%"/*''')",".'",'+"9$ '.$*'$   /)')' *<"/'')'$ / '$( ,"9' !)' <9 ),"9' ! ."5".5%  5#')'$)5% $$),"!')',"+ )')'$),"9'!9+$*'')$ 6 ;- 8(     !""# "$" #% "# &'# &$##% #$(## 

!%" !, $!%",". $!  $!%" $'# '$" /)  <5/ !!$"  %' $5!'))' 6 08+ %!'. )+  $"' $!  $!%" )55#". 5% $ $'# '$"'/+!,$!%"*'"%' !"#%"..(  '/." $!!  '.  )55#" $'# '$" /" ,.)' $!%"" !, $! ''$'$"$5!')".()5#'68(!,$! .'$$/" ,.)' $!%""( ! + $ $!%" !, )55#,". $'# '$" /)' 5% + ' ! 5%$!%"$'# '$"/,".( 

 ; 1   +  $!% /*'9 $!%" %  !" %'  !" #%".. %'/." )5#'".   !". *'"'$" <*% ,.". ""+ $"' $! + $ $!%" !, )55#,". /)' 5% + ' ! 5% /,".+ '' $"' %' !')' $! $5/5'#'''/*'$"'!')'$5/'$"( "%"!$% '". ?$''. /5'. $!  <!! !)$/*"$ ,',  !" /*'9  "%" % $!%"'",' <'.)( !%" '9+  ' ', $ ''  ; 1   0 )5#'".  !")'/5'/'. !"'.(  '  !". $!%" '9+  %' !, %'/." )5#'". ""   !". *'"'$" <*% ,.". ,', $!%" %,.9  ; 1   +  +  0 5" #/.  !"( 

;11115'.#/.'9$!%"!"<*% ,./!7$,*'"'$" <*% ,."(  '/." $!% *)''. <!!. (<#'' - ,"<',"+ )' ' $!  $''#,"7)' @@@("#!1( ," "))  $#!!,'( A!!. <<''. $!$$"+  $! $!%""9,"")) <',"*)')'"-$#!!,')%' ) ( "",' -(,"<',"<(($!%!,% *'",*".<',"",/)$$!%"" )',*"$!% 5')' $!  /''/' +0 B $,.#'<5/( '/." ')' '"/*,9$! % ><*%'/*$#!!,'+<',"*)')'"-$#!!,'  /''/'   $#!!,'(  ' !".,*"9 #.''.'$%'( (/"0$#!!,' ")'+)'<*%'/*,/"!,-$#!!,' /''/'. $#!!,'(  !,!),*". <*% ,.)'$ $!%" ',". $!!<'. ,"!"  ',?! ''$",.) #'##')' $!%+,"<',"7.',')".+$! '".. %!'".( 

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

;1-<$!%",,'9$!%"!)"'/''/')5'./$  !"( 

;$!%$,,9%'),"$"".<!!+$$% "$!"%'( !%"+ #%"..%'+ 59 ;"),"$"".$! $,.(  / ; 1)55#9$!%"% !" !"$',.$$$!  %7/'/.),"$"".+$"'% '9$!%")55#". $),"$"".,')$'# (   !, !,". $!  /5  )*' ),"$"", %'/." ')' "". #'''*'/   $#!!,' ,', ',.  )$". " *'"9'    $#!!,'(   !, ',".),"$"".,')$'#  ),"$""'.*,./..!$"),.'.68 

;.-+$!%!,),"$"".),"!'$!%"$"". $!%"/5'. $"".+ $" ""# $!%"$"". !, #'''*'/+ $" !, ,',   59'/)' $"".( !!." #/."9$! % $"$/5 )*' ;.-3<3" %'/."')'"".#'''*'/$#!!,'(  / ;11<!,$!%"/5'.$"".),"!'',.  ,*" $"".(

; 0+1$!%+$"'),"!',<9),"$"". !"$',.$)55#/ $!%"%,.' $!% $,.) ' ),"!' ',.,". <',"' ',.  $"".+ )*'9 $!%" $"". /5  <*% ,.".  / '$" ""+ $" ""# 9#''' '" $%9 <',"' ',.  $"". ' ),"!' ',*".)' <''#)55#.( 9#''''"1(<)9#'-)55#",# <',"'',.  ,*" $"". '),"!'',*".)'<''#)55#.$!%!,'/'' %',,$",' $#!!,')$')',*"/$""0$#!!,'(  !!." 5%". ,', $", $!  ' ! %  ',.  ),"$"". /"/5''. ',".!9$!%" ; 0"$#!!,'% ',. <*% ,."$ / '$"$ $""$( 

 ;     $!% $!%" )5#'9 ),"$"". $',.$)55#)' !,". ''$" /." " ),"$"". $',.$)55#)' %,.'+  %7/')' $"""/ ),"$""."9".),"$"".""#"$',.$/%,.' *"")' $",'5')','/''/':;'",5%".""(/:;

1618 #%' $!%"" 5')' /''/')' $!## /*'9 /*".  ,*". /*,'$" /''/'"',#' 6/''/'8+ #/ $!%"" ',*"/$ )""")' $",' $!% 5')','( ''/')55#$!$:;15".',#')55#+)'',."9'<#!,' (  ' !".$!%"'9+$",$!%"!" 5'% ),"$""$! $,.,', #/. ; 1 5"/*'9$!%"% !" !"$',.$ )55#$$! %7/'/.),"$"".+$! '!),"$"".$',.$)55#)' /"/5''.',".+"9$! ( (/5 )*' #.''.'$$"$),"$"", #'''*'/$#!!,' % ',. $"""))$#!!,'+$!$$"),"$""1 $#!!,'( ! "9!" *"")'$",'5')','".),"$""/''/' :;'",5%".""( 

 ;  -  +  $!% 9 /'.". ),"$"". !" ,', ),"$"". $',.$)55#)'+$"'$9"%',.79$#!!,'(  

!%",'$>