Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-08-70613/5 AI generated

2-08-70613/5 · Tartu Maakohus Valga kohtumaja

Case Number 2-08-70613/5
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-08-70613/5 · Tartu Maakohus Valga kohtumaja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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text



 



        !"#$%&'"  

(#$ )$!   ))*#''                 +,'$(-($ )#$*,. (,% %*'#%$!                   

)(#(/!#$ #! !   +  "!#$ "%'"$! '$0!+ 1 .1 ())'           , 2#! !.(!#( ))033333333!$ )# )%'%4 )!#,  + . ! $ ))0 33333333333. %$ )# 333333333333333+    ($%00 2#! !+"!#$+ 5%,*!#+ 2 #! ! !$ !%0$!, )$'%* !#"%'"$!1  6"! #$# / !!0 )%* /'0 !#!7 ())' , 1 !'# , ""!  6  !!0 $$! /'0 $$!7 ())',8!'#+

$''!#0 )#$)#!$!##!#""#*##50#" !+     

2#! !*'#%$! $%$0,5##+ '0+ 5%,*!#+ 2#! ! !$ !*'#%$! $%$ 16 )%*!0"! /'07 ())'+

5!)%")#!$!,$!#$*!!#%#! $'#5#*!'#$%9+#!$0*'#%$! $%$%#""!# :; %#!!%$!!##'5#$0$%#$!!+  

    

)#$)#!$! &% "9  &5" ,)) !$%. %#! )#!$! 5###)*#*!!#. $0 *## %,* $ " $$ *<<0$*!% )#!$! "% $%# ##" !#*!!#. !#0 &%%#!))' 9$! (#$ ' )'' )#$%+ &%%#!))' 9$! "0 ! %'00 (,% $!*'#%$!!. $ 9$!!#)#%#!%%%'0*!#!#$'%+    !""# "$" #% "# &'# &$##%#$(## 

6 7

)$! )' )$!#'$0 )!#,# )#$% (,% $%# "!#* 8 &5" ,)) !$% %#!  5###)*#*!!# 6#% 7. )#0! !*!. # $ )!#, )#$% *55(#$0 #5#, ! (,% $%#"!#.)' )#$%$!#!%,)#!$!($%00+ )!#,"#9 (,% $! "!#$!! )#$%,'$0 !6#%17+  !#"%# !;888%"9 (,%0",&,'0")!"5%,,5## )!#, !"#$% &'"!#)#!$!!#.!%#$*#''!#+ 

!;88%.  )!%#. $ )!#,"#9 )#$%!##$0"%0$!!,'$0 !. ($%09 )$!+ $ !"#*')'!##$0 )#$%"%0$!!."# !"%0$! #)* $!!+ $ )!#, "%09   !"#*! )#$% %*'#%$!!. %'09 )$! !, )#$!#$'#&0*#+ 

!; % )!%#&))%= #%!!,)%$ )#!##$0"50",#'0*!#. $ "!#!&))% "#9 !%% )* !+ * !"## )' = #%! "5# #'*$!## , !%!'%' '$!#$*' )#$%0(!!(#$0 (,% $!"%0$!!+ 

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

! ; 88 %  %$!% ($%0*!% , )!#,%# #$%9 , !$ ! "5%, *!# %0$! $%$'' )$'%* !#"%'"$!1 .1 ())',""!.8 ())'+ 

! ; 8 %  &  )!%# #$''!#9 )$! )*% %#$!% ##!# ""#*# #50#" ! !"#$%&'")#!$!+%!,)%$0% )$!#$''!#9 !;8 %  &  %$!%   !"#$% &'" )#!$! )*% %#$!% ##!# ""#*#

6 7 #50#" !+ 

!;% )!%# ''9*'#%$!! $%$0&))%. %% ,$ !)#!$!##+

)$!.($%00!.,5#9 !;%%$!%*'#%$! $%$0 )!#, '0+ 

!! ; 8  %  )!%# )!#,  !"#$% &'" )#!$! #*! )((% *55(9 )$!  !"#$% &'" )#!$!! %! ! *'#%$! $%$0 ,)#$!%  /"#"# *'#%$! $%$0 (%! !$$($!+ '' )#!$! #*!# ''9 )$! *'#%$!)!%!% *!#% $ #5#, )* *'#%$! $%$0 '* (, !#*! !+ , &))%# '#$0 *'#%$! $%$)'"%0$!!#*!%#!$#$0(%" 1 ())'.*%%"5%,*!#*!# , )!#,%##)#%96#%7+ 

! ;0   % .  )!%# )' *'#%$! $%$0 *'#%$!)!%!# )#$ $%$0 , )#$"5%!0 $%$0. $!,$$(! )#$ $%$0 )' (%". $#!,)' '' !, %59"#*! $%$0+ !#"%# ! ;  - %  .  #$%9 (%"$ #!$0 %# , (%"$ !$$($! !%#$9#!"%!,''!#. $!0$!!)%!5#!##$0#!#+  , )' ! #)#%'$0 "5%, *!# )!#,%# %0$! $%$ , )$'%* !# "% !$!1 .1 ())'''""!.8 ())'+)'("!#0! !;! % . %  !5#!##$# 5!)%"! !,!'' ! 1 . 1 ())'+ !#"%# "%0$! !#*! ,% #'$0  ; 1 %  #$% '*##$%# ''%# #!$0 (%"$ 1 ())'+%#))0$#("!#0!#$%9 )!#,%#, !$ !"5%,*!# !; %. %$!%*'#%$! $%$'(%" 1 ())'+ 

!;% )!%# )$!*5(9*'#%$! $%$0 '0% !*55(*!##)#%'$0! $ "%0$! %$!% *'#%$! $%$0 '0% !*55(*! %'0!. # /"#*!% $$%$"#%# *'#%$! $%$0%##$%9#!$0*'#%$! $%$0!$$($!# '0% !#"%'0,$!#$*!!# %#! $'#5#*!'""!#:; %#!!%$!!##'5#$0$%#$!!+!#"%# :; %(%! )$!#$!#5#*!""#*! )((%"9"%$!%0,'$0 "%' $%# ""#$!'#(!! 6""!7. ("#! )$!#$! !!!'$#" ! *$$#$*!!# $' )!#5#*!'+"!*55( !%)# !:;!-8!5#!##$0'#(!!*55(.*%%% %!'0$9!#!&()#!'#!#!+  %!,)%$0% )$!%9.# $' )#$)#!$!,5#,*'#%$! $%$ )!#, '0 ''("!#0! !;8%!5#!##$#.#$%9 )!#,%#+"5%,*!# 2#! ! !$ ! *'#%$! $%$' (%" !$! 1 ())'+ )!#,% #$%9 %#! )#!$! ,$!#$*!!# $' #5#*!' #!$0 *'#%$! $%$%# ""!# : ;   %  #!! %$!! ##'5#$0$%#$!!+ 

! ;  % .  )!%# !9 "0%$!#0 *'#%$! $%$0 ,)#$!# ''  ! "0%$!#0*'#%$! $%$0 '0% !*55(*!#   

)#$' A