Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-08-65923/5 AI generated

2-08-65923/5 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Põlvas

Case Number 2-08-65923/5
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

      6' /%," ,%!0 ,%%#%!,":%)/ %))%$3 " :,"0 ) !+,#%)0 '''  #$%%,!%0" "")!" ,":%)/ )%)/ !( !% "")%:"% ,!", +%/!" !0 & (, ",">)%)#$% 868 . 0% !""%)#$" = 867668' #% )+!! !(  "")!" !#%!" 9,0%)/%#!" ( %))%(/' -" ) 66873 6'6'' 3  !", -+,/)"$ !( /"(," '  ()%! !0 !%0""")!" ""!  63 )% )%)/ !( :%0% )0 -+, !# ''' ' -" ) 63 '6'' 3  !", -+,/)"$ !( /"(," '  -""$%! !0 !%0""")!" ""!  36 )% )%)/ !( :%0% )0 -+, !# ''' ' -" ) 6783 ''' 3  !", !( -%%-%!-+,/ /"(," :"%0%, 6' = '''  3 )%'

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-08-65923/5 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Põlvas:       6' /%," ,%!0 ,%%#%!,":%)/ %))%$3 " :,"0 ) !+,#%)0 '''  #$%%,!%0" "")!" ,":%)/ )%)/ !( !% "")%:"% ,!", +%/!" !0 & (, ",">)%)#$% 868 . 0% !""%)#$" = 867668' #% )+!! !(  "")!" !#%!" 9,0%)/%#!" ( %))%(/' -" ) 66873 6'6'' 3  !", -+,/)"$ !( /"(," '  ()%! !0 !%0""")!" ""!  63 )% )%)/ !( :%0% )0 -+, !# ''' ' -" ) 63 '6'' 3  !", -+,/)"$ !( /"(," '  -""$%! !0 !%0""")!" ""!  36 )% )%)/ !( :%0% )0 -+, !# ''' ' -" ) 6783 ''' 3  !", !( -%%-%!-+,/ /"(," :"%0%, 6' = '''  3 )%'

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

        

          

  !   "#$% &%!        ' () '  *+,-            ."/%!%01 222222223 ! 1 22222222 22222 224 /% 5' ' ' .%!%01 222222222223 ", 1 22222 2222222 -,0  222222 22222222224 -! 677 )% -&,(#+%!#%!"!     863 )%    

  6' /%  ,00 !,%!", )%)/ -&,( #+%! 5' ' ' %  !! 86 .!"%!"!0 !"%!4 )%  !")% -+,3  .!!0 ,#9##")0 !4 )%  !")% -%%-%!" )%)/ 8 .!"%!"9##")0 -%%!4 )% ,"::" -% .!%!!")+0"!4 "!' ' 5&  ,0# %  /% 5' ' ' -! 7 )% -&,(#+%!#%!"!' ' 5& #")",!,0 %  )0 6; ( 5' ' ' )0 8; ,!"!'

      !! " !" -,%, "-!    *+,-  #( )!","% 0 '6''  ",, 6'

*,"0 -+%-0  !!" :"," "!%0 :",,!%)"$!"  %)/)) ,"  :&"- (!,3 ,"! !!" :",,)0%," &"%#"#%!"!3 %0 #%" %,("# % -%%"  #<<0#%!", "!%#"!" !#"   !!" -,%, "-!"/"#%!"!' :",,!%)"$! -+%0!" , ")00 %(,%! #")",!"!3 % "$!"! "% ," !",," , ")0#%! %!)/%,' "0!"! !&"!0 & ( (&/%#%!"! :"$ #")",!$% ,"( "/"# & ( "!",  #")",!%#%)/3 #%,," "/"#%!"!  #")",!$% ,"$3 "",+%/" "!%# "$!"' "$!" :+ (")0#%!"! -+% %%/%,+%- !#%!"! -+% "$!"! "!%)"- !",,%!" :0!" +-,0#%!"!3 #%! ) !"0 #")",!$% ,"#%!"/3 ))$  ! #+%!,% & ( :&! #")",!$% )0#%!"

  .4 ,!" , ")0#%!3 % )%#"0 ,! "% ,)0 "!%0 :+ (")0#, -+% & ( :%")0#%!" ""!#&/%,'

     

/%-,0!" ., 4  !", !! /"( !(," !%0""")! :," - ", '''  !+,#%0 ,%%#%!,":%)/ ,!",' ":%)/ (&/%  !! /"( :# !(," ",""")! )%)/ !(  !! !0 "")!" ""! !# -!-, "!%0 -""," ( !#%!"/ -%%-%#%!" , #!# -%%-%! 36; :&"-! !# !##!'

%%#%!,":%)/! ,")"-, "!%! /"( !(," !#%!"! -"0 ) 66873 6 ( 678  !##! 6737 )%' /% "!%#%!" (! ,% !(, !# 863 )%'

) !( "% ," &%)0 ,":%)/ )+"" !",3 !",,":&! )+$ /"( !(, 677 )% -&,(#+%!#%!3 #%,,"! ) :+ %-+,/ 863 )%3 -%%-%! 3 )% ( -+,/)"-!" !%!!")+0#%!"/ !)")0 ,0 .!%!!")+0"!4 78 )%' '6''  "/% /"( /%-,0!"! :)0!" !%!!")+0"! = 78 )%  !!3 #&%0"!3 " "/"#%! ) )0 )+0" : , #%"  (3 -%0 ,":%)/(&/!" ,"::" -%/ ., 84' 6'6''  -!!"! #&%! /"(3 " -"0 ) "!%0 !+,! ,":%)/ %)/%#!"/ ( !( :, !0 "")!"," ., 774'  !  

!( -%0,"$ /%," -! ., 6673 7643 !"! :&! ,":%)/ !+,#%#%! !!  %/,!!" ( ",">)% !", (, "% !)03  9,"!  ,":%)/ ' -+% 8'6''  9,"!' *"," !",," ) "# #()0!,% ,0 ,$3 ) !$ :")!%)% -%0  )% )%)/ !"" ,"$ &%",%, 222222 2222222222 "# 9,,:%0#%!,0" "!'

      6' /%," ,%!0 ,%%#%!,":%)/ %))%$3 " :,"0 ) !+,#%)0 '''  #$%%,!%0" "")!" ,":%)/ )%)/ !( !% "")%:"% ,!", +%/!" !0 & (, ",">)%)#$% 868 . 0% !""%)#$" = 867668' #% )+!! !(  "")!" !#%!" 9,0%)/%#!" ( %))%(/' -" ) 66873 6'6'' 3  !", -+,/)"$ !( /"(," '  ()%! !0 !%0""")!" ""!  63 )% )%)/ !( :%0% )0 -+, !# ''' ' -" ) 63 '6'' 3  !", -+,/)"$ !( /"(," '  -""$%! !0 !%0""")!" ""!  36 )% )%)/ !( :%0% )0 -+, !# ''' ' -" ) 6783 ''' 3  !", !( -%%-%!-+,/ /"(," :"%0%, 6' = '''  3 )%'

""/ ) "",#&/%0 +")0%"/ -!03 " /"( ) !)0 !(," ,%%#%!,":%)/ ,!", !%0""")!  '  ()%! ( -""$%!  63 )% ,!"!'

  .4 5&",%, "% ," !( -&%",3 "  ,+:"! ,%%#%!,":%)/ ' -+% 8'6''  !",," 9,"!9,"#%!"/3 ,":%)/,%!"  !!" :0#%!" !"%! ! #&&- & !!3 ) 

"")!" !#%!" 9,0%)/%#!" : 8'7  !", ,"!  :%0)0 ,":%)/ 9,"!9,"#%!", /!# /"(,"  0% )%)/ !",," /!# (&#%!" , !# !0 "")!" ""! )% "")!" !#%!" ,+:"#%!")%' ) !( "% ," ,":%)/ ,+:")0 )+"" !",3 !%%! :"$  !00 "")!" ""! /"(," #!# -!-, "!%0 -"","' ",00 :+ (!", "% ," !( )" +")0  !( -,0! '6''  ., 7843 #%,," /"( ) ,%!)0 # 6'6''  -!!"," ., 774'

? @ 8 ,/ 6 !&"!$3 "  !! ,"$ &% -!-, ,":%)/," -+% !"0!","' ? @ 66 ,/ 6 : 6  !",3 % -+,/)% )  !! %)03 -+%$ -+,!,0( )+0  !!" &%#%!' ? @ 6 ,/ 6  !",3 % -+,/)% %$   #!#%!"  !!3 -+%$ -+,!,0( )+0 !",," &%#%!'

/"( :, '''  !(," !0"0 -+,)+0"! )& $3 " !(, ,% !0 -"! ) 6687 -%0 3 .637834 )%' ""/ !"%!/ '''  :%0% !( #!# '  ()%! ( -""$%! !0 #$%%,!%0" "")!" ""! /"(," 8638 .783A364 )%' !(,,3 "! )""!", !! !( #$%%,",">)%  %3 "% ," &"!,"-, ( , & !!3 !"! !%0""")!" !#%!" ""! -!$ ,":%)/ (&/% /"( ""! %), !('

 "% ," !( +")0)03 " )0  !!" %#%)" ,"! ,)0 -$)0- ? @ 6 #+"!'

) /% "!%#%!" !"%!/ ) !( /"(," -"", -+,/ '  ()%! ( -""$%! !0 #$%%,!%0" "")!" ""! 863 )% ( !( "% ," +")0)0 )0 !## !#%!3 !%%! ,"$  , )%#"0 -+,/ !(, -&,( #+%! /"( !! !0 !%0""")!" "! ? @ 8 ,/ 63 @ 66 ,/ : 6 ( @ 6 ,/ 6 ,!",'

' ? @ 66 ,/ 6 :  ( @ 66 ,/ 6 ,!", -+%$ -+,!,0( )+0  ,%!"  !!" &%#%!"/ -%%-%#%!" , -+,/)%, -%%-%!%)"!!% .-%%-%!4'  "")!" !#%!" 9,0%)/%#!" : '6  !", ) /"(, +%/! )+0 -%%-%! -"" !#%!"/ %,%)"#%!" ""!3 -%%-%! -"!!" #!"& (," (&/)"-! ,")0%:&"-! 36; !# !##! %/ !#%!"/ -%%-%0 ,")0%:&"- ""!' -" ) 6687  !", :%0% !( !# '''  63 )%' %#"0 -"! ,% '''  !# 783 )%' ""/ "% ," !( )0 -" !)0 #&&0 & (! )%)/ ) !)0 -" !#%!"/ -%%-%!!"'

) !( ) (&)0 -" ) 63 !' 36 )%3 &%",%, !#3 !%%! :"$  )0 !##, !# -%%-%! 36; :&"-! ,"! 6''' ' ""/ ) !( ,)0 -" ) 6 !#%!"/ -%%-%!"!  "# % 3 !'

/"( -"!!"  !", ) !( ,)0 863 )% !#%!"/ -%%-%!"! 7 :&"- 3 #%,," ""! ,":%)/(&/)" -%%-%! ) 36 .863 2 36 2 7 B 64 )% ., 84' !( "% ," )0 -%%-%!"-! -%0,!)0' -"!0"! !(,3 " -%%-%! %)9!% -" ) 6 !# (&#%!" ""!  :&"- ,!"! ) ($ 3 . 2 36; 2 364 )% ( !"" 9,"$ /"( :, )+!0 -%%-%!"!## )%)/ -%%#! "% ! ,/"0 9,"#&& !"! "/ " ! :+ %#+"/ -!,! ,"-!3 !%%! ,"$ !(, /"( !! -&,( #+%! -%%-%! 3 )% ? @ 66 ,/ 6 :  ( @ 66 ,/ 6 ,#)0 ,!" ,!",'



7 .4

' '6''  "!%0 /%-,0!"! )+0%! /"( !(, -+,/)"-!" !%!!")+0#%!"/ !)")0 ,  78 )% = -&,(#+%!#%! ? @ 66 ,/ 6 ,!",' '6''  :)0! /"( /%-,0! )0 !%!!")+0"! = 78 )%  !!3 #&%0"!3 " "/"#%! ) )0 )+0" : , #%"  (3 -%0 ,":%)/(&/!" ,"::" -%/ ? @ 6 ,/ 6 #+"!'

 ! ,"%$3 " )0 :)0! "% ," +%/" ,/"0 ! @ 8 ,/  : 6 /% ##%!"!3 !"! /"( ) #)0 -%0 # +%/!,%" -&%"%0'

? @ 6 ,/ 6 !&"!$3 " ,"::" - ) ,":%)/! "")& 0 ,":%)/ %)0 ,":%)/:,"  !! #!  (!0 ,":%)/:,"," ,":%)/! #&&0  !##' # :/ -% ' ,+%"  !",  ,0!" &"!,"-! (! !&"! -!-, ( 0",3 % ,":%)/:,"0 ) "",)"-,  ,"::%)0 9-%-  ( !##!3 #%0 :"$ #!# #  !! %)0 ,":%)/:,'

 "")!" !#%!" 9,0%)/%#!" :! 7'6'6 ,")"-, ) /"(, +%/! )+0 !(, -+,/)"-!" !%!!")+0#%!"/ !)")0 ,!" 9-%#%!'  "")!!0" %))%(3 #%! ) ,%%#%!,":%)/ , # !3  !", ) !%!!")+0"!! 78 )%'

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

-"!0"! !(,3 " /"( ) !)0 !(," -+,)+0" '''  ., 743 #%! "% ," :+ (!)0 /"(," ,,%! <<(+ ( !((#%!" ,3 :"," !",," ) !( :")!%)&3 "! -%%$%$ 222222 2222222222 ( !$ :")!%)% -%0  )% ! )%)/ "# 9,,:%0#%! ,")0"!!"! :"$ "# ")0%!" ", (&/)" #-,%!!3 !%%! ,"%$  !3 " ,"- ,"::" - .78 )%4 ) "",0 + "$#+%!,%, ! )%)/ !"0 ) #+%!,% ( !$"! ? @ 6 ,/ 6 ,!", -& ")00 8 )%,"'

7' ""/ ,"$ !(, /"( !! -&,( #+%! #$%%,!%0" "")!" -+,/ 863 )%3 -%%-%! 3 )% ( ,"::" - 8 )%3 !'  67 )%'

'

&"!,"- !%-%%,!( /% %)0 ! @ 63 @ 67 ,/ 6 ( @ 6 ,/ 63  ,!", ) 863 )%'

! @ 68 ,+%/"" 6 (   !", "!%$ !( #")",")0  !  !!"! -+% #")",! ,+:"-! #&&!"! #")",!,0" (!" #")",!!,%!" - ",' ")",!,0" (!"! )&"$  ! ""3 #%,,%!"0 #")",!,0 ""/% #")",!!,%!"! :"$ )0#' (0!"

  .4 , #&&$  ! %)0,! #")",!,0" ::!%),!" (!" #")",!!,%!" - ",'

) /%  ,0!" !,%!",3 !%%! ,"$ #")",!,0 ! @ 6 ,/ 6 ,!", (& !( )0 8; .67B677 2 64 ( /"( )0 6; ,!"!'

! @ 687 ,/ 6  !", -+%$ #")",!!,%)" )+0 !( , ")0)0 "!%#"!" !#"  , #")",!,0"  ,%! %)0,!#&&#%! , ")0%! !%!,0- ,0" ::!%),!" (!" ,!",  :&"- (!,3 ,"! ,0" (!"   " 0 , ")0% (+!#%!"!'

"#$% &%!

 )%