Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-08-53968/5 AI generated

2-08-53968/5 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus

Case Number 2-08-53968/5
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-08-53968/5 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

          

        !"  

#"$!%"   &!' #                 ()*+,#-#"$!%"+ .$'# '$+/"              -"//"* & %' ) )  0" 1  $#!!/' /-"*)          % -"//"* &.#'#'$!!*((."$!% 2#'#'#'$!%34#'-#"5 $!  ) ) . ''$"$!!* 66666666666. "$!% 66666666666666666666666666)    #%"**-"//"* &%') )0") 2  +-' ) )  -"//"* & $"$ #0*"$!/! /# ((  7 8*,/$ 0-' #0*"$!/! /# (((    9/$ 1  :$!+$4++/*'"%;$#!!/')

"//'*$!%"!"'0''0'+2'*0$)      -"//"* &+/"$""* 2) )$/*) 2 +-') )-"//"* &$"$+/"$""(:4$"%$%$*; $#!!/')

2!0 !" -""+'  $"/' 2'+'/' ", ) )  "* +/"$"" 0''0'<=(((/2%"*"")  

     -"//"* & 0-', '* >'!!/$,"  >20 !!$".  !" $2!'++'. $"'* +' %' + $"' 0'' $"" +??*"+' #" $!%" !" 0'$" 0$ +'. #" '/$!//$!%". $" ""# $," 0-'*$ %/**$'# '$"+/".$"'$,"'!%/*+''"/')  ) )  0-',  !" > '* $  #" $!%" -#" $!%"+   !" $2!'++'  (@ >20 !!$". '* $  $-'$   0+'+'->"0''+'$0 '$)

 :@;    !""# "$" #% "# &'# &$##%#$(## 

!%" !/ $!%"/"* $!  $!%" $'# '$" 0+ ( >20 !!$"  %' $2!'++' : (@;. %!'* +.  $"' $!  $!%" +22#"* 2% $ $'# '$"'0.!/$!%"-'"%' !"#%"**)  '0*"$!!'* +22#"$'# '$"0"/*+'$!%""!/$!  ''$'$"$2!'+"*)/!0+,#':1;)!/$! *'$$0"/*+' $!%"") ! . $ $!%" !/ +22#/"* $'# '$" 0+' 2% . ' ! 2% $!%" $'# '$" 0/"*) !%" ',.  ' '/ $ ''  = @1   +2#'"*  !"+'02'0'* !"'*)  '  !"* %/*, $!%"  =* @1  (. .  2'* #0*    !") 

!%"',.%'!/%'0*"+2#'"*""  !"*-'"'$">-% /*"* /'/$""", !"#%"*+') 

 = @1  (.  $!% 0-', $!%" %  !" 0-' !+ " %'  !" #%"** %'0*" +2#'"*   !"* -'"'$" >-% /*"* "".$"'$! .$$!%"!/+22#/"*0+'2% .'!2%0/"*) "%"!$% '"*A$''*02'*$! >!!!+$0-"$/'/ !" 0-', "%"%$!%"'"/'>'*+) 

=@@@("0-', !"02  2$'# *0!.02 #0"* "%".$"' !/ " **.  !" $""", "//"+'  2'+' $ 02 >!! ' ,#''$') 9-% /*0!+2#'$4$/-'"'$>-% /*") 

"/ !/ " **.  !" '  $""" 2'+' 02 >!! ' ,#''$'. 2, $!%"  !"02 $'# *0! +2#',>-% /*0!4$/-'"'$">-% /*") 

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

 :@;  !/%'0*"-'"'$">-% /*/"*%'+2#'"* !"'*.0''*<=*

1 (5(5(((>(5(()  <=*51 (5(5(((>(. 5((($!%!/>'/>'/">!! 2'+'$ $!%""'$. $!%"" ", 2' 00 >'/" 0-' *"5 $" ""# $!%"" #'$$"+'/ !/ 0-"% "/0 $!%"" 2'+ 2+'/ 0-' +'$!%/ 2'+'/. %" 2'+' 0''0'+'/) "' 0-/'$ !/ $!%"" #'$$"/"*. 0-', 0-"* /-"*$!%""2'+' #%'$!%""2'+'0''0'+'$!##/-"* 0''0')  !/ %' %'0*" +2#'"* ""   !"* -'"'$" >-% /*"* /'/ % >!!'"*A$''*02'*","*$! >!!!+$0-"$)' !"* $""",%' =@1($!% !"#%"*+'/'/$! ",%  $"$02 +-'1$#!!/') 

=@ (>$!%"//',$!%"!+"'0''0'+2'*0$  !")' !"*$!%""//', =@ (>" !"!+ "'0''0'+2'*0$) 

=( ($!%$//,%'+/"$""*>!!.$$% "$!"%') !%". #%"**%'. 2, =( ("+/"$""*$! $/*)0 = (1@ (   +22#, $!%" %  !"  !" $'/*$ $ $!  %40'0* +/"$""*. $"' %  ', $!%" +22#"*  $ +/"$""* /'+$'# )   !/ !/"* +22#  !" $'/*$ $!  >!! %40'0 +/"$""/ ""* #'''-'0"* (  $#!!/'  >!'$""*  $#!!/'. $!$$"  +/"$"" ( $#!!/')   !/ %'0*" '+' "/"* #'''-'0" (  $#!!/'. +$$2" 0*" '+' "/"* #'''-'0"  $#!!/'  !/ "/"*  #'''-'0" ( $#!!/' $!%" +'$ *//0*+':..(;) 

=*((.$!%!/+/"$""*+/"!'$!%"$""* $!%"02'* $""*. $" ""# $!%"$""* !/ #'''-'0. $" !/ /'/   2,'0+' $""*)   !/ '/"*%'1$#!!/'/-"*.+'>-%'0-/0"!/$#!!/' $-#0/-"** (1$#!!/')#0* =((.2".!/$2!0 %'%'//$ $#!!/'/'/00= (",/'+"%'%'//"*#'''-'0"( $#!!/')!!*"#0*",$! % $"$02 +-'+/"$""/#'''-'0 %'0*"'+'($#!!/')  0 =(@@>1!/$!%"02'$$""$+$$2"$''#+/"$""* "%".$"' +$$2"$''#+/"0*" 2'+22#"#%"*+ =@>".02  #0"*.$"'%'!/+/-"*'"*%' +$"'4$$"">2#+$$2"$''#+/" ->>") 

#" $!%" ) ""'  +22#" 2' #%"*+  = @   >  " -"//"* &0*") )0"+$$2"$''#+/"1$#!!/'/-"*: ;)   !/ '/"* (@)""'  %'0*" $!  0" + /-"* : (;)   !,02 +-'+/"$""/+$$2"$''#+/""+'""*#'''-'0 $#!!/':;)!!*"2%"*+-',$!%".#0* =(@@>12".$!  % $"$+$$2"$''#+/"$""*"++$#!!/')   !/!/"*$! 02 +-'+/"$""/>!'$""*$#!!/')0  =(1@>'',>!' '*$""*-/*+'$0* $'//'"./*$""*!/$/"*.

 @:@; $"'*$!%"0-',/-"*//*-/*+'$+""0''')#0* =(1@ 2". !, $!%" >-% /*"$ %  >!'$""  +-', $!  %  $"$ 02  +/"$""/>!'$""*"++$#!!/')    !/ !/"* 02  +-' $ #'''-'0 ( $#!!/' $!%" +'$ *// 0*+' ) '0''  +# '* $!% ' ! $!  +/"*!$"+/ 0'$" $2!'+"* /'/ $!  !/ +/"*!$"+/*'* ''$'$" $2!'+"*)  !/ %  "/"* !'+'/" . +' !/ 2"* 2,'0+) !!*" #0* ' $""" #%"*+'% !"$! $!%"+'$ *//0*+'""* #'''-'0" ( $#!!/' 02 +-'+'$)   !/ -'" '* $!%"  = (  ( >  "0*"#'''-'0"($#!!/'+'$) 

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

!%"/'$B