Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-08-22084/6 AI generated

2-08-22084/6 · Tartu Maakohus Valga kohtumaja

Case Number 2-08-22084/6
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

('  ''"'22 " $$ #64 "' "'"*  %"  22  * 34 "' $:2( 77 !(''")"%( (  ('4$7'(('($ "'/#5$'($"'/3$'($3"'/#$)"'($ 3"'$ *)*'-(%  '' )* )7"*"(  ( 3"' 0'( 77 22%$) ('  '" 7(('6#33 "' +&.$ * " ) "% (' " 0 ' 1( & 4<   ' (  "'"* " 7%-% ( -!'( %$  2 ( -( )( " ) 2'"% 1((7'%' "%' --(7( ( 77 ( "'"* *-!'&* )"!%  (%'"  (( -!'(' -'% )(0 ' 72 ( 77  !('' " "% (  -)% %-!'''-"  -!'( %1((7'%'"%+(#.$   #  $$ ($&$  (&$""(# (&)( (  ( '&0 *'"! "%%)(&(%' ( (' ($  * )"(  '"%$$0$$)$$1""'""' 7'%+(04./ -' *''-2()-! +(=./ $7'(('$$ 7'+( 6#./7"*"-2()-! +(##.$)"(  '"% (% 7'%+( 34.) $7'(('$$'"*'7(('7'+(=6.$  : >% =(*#/=#(*#/6(* ("-" %1((7'%( (' ()'-"  '2'%1((7'%'0-!'&* )"!% (!' ('  -2()*'(-("'1   ""  (' *'(  ''0'%'' '2'"% ((  )-2( ( 1((7'%'"'"* ' '" "%: >=#(*="' % )('%$ -( :  > =# (* 030 22  (' (7 (  '"%( '*'  ( "0(2% *'-" -('  '"%')(7 -)% 0) '*'"  (1 ( (7 (  '-!'((-2' '7(&''*'('   % 7(*(22$: >=#(*4 (-!'& (' -2 "%%((: >=#(* "' %  0 ' -" ( "  '"  (70   ('  -2()!'' (  ((    -(' (-2 '"%(' ('-(7$: >=#(*=( (-!'& )2 (' -2()!'-!' (( -2 "%%((: >=#(*"' % 0 '-" 0 (( ( ('"! 0"88-!' -!'(7 ("7''-' ( -!''(" -% %7(!)-""'%7!) %$   "!& (' ( )*0  " * ) " (&"% *' ) - (  1((7'%'  ( "!% "'$7'(('"'0'' '  >3 (  ' '% ) -  "! $   $7'((' $$   +( #. "2-("'"*'(+$$$$. (*'"%7( (  (' -2()!'' ) ('    22' *  "%-'% '(!'*" "'"*--7'0 ' "!% --2'  ! "%'  *( '-'% 7 '!'*" /     7"  '% 2' "%-'% ! "% '%  -2'%   '""''  "'"* (% -'%(  ( 77 ('  ( "%'  -!'('$ :( % " (  '""'"%0  " ('"!%   -"% ( 77 0 '(('  '"*' % -'-% -'% -2(' ($ '' )-( " ( 7''- ( (%%0  !'* ) '"%(  -'%  "'"*  " ((% 22'  2*'("7( %7'%"%& )!'('-'%( 

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-08-22084/6 · Tartu Maakohus Valga kohtumaja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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

        

    

     !""        ##$%  &'(!)                               * )$$+''%,,,,,,,,,,, ( ,,,,,(,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,-(% ,,,,,,,,./  )$$+''%,,,,,,,,,,,0 ( ,,,,,,,,,(,,,,,,,,,1(,,,,,-(% ,,,,,,,,. #$"- &'($$   ! "  (%%$$*'$$- (' "!% (' ($  2() !' $  $  $  $   (' (  3$)"' $$ "' 3#$&'"' $$#45+" (' '-''%1 1 "%."'"'"*( #$"- &' $$#64+1% ' 1 "%-''."'0'%' -2 ' 7(&''*'(' 7(  %7(*(2207)$$+''% ,,,,,,,,,,,. 1((7'%'  "'   2' ('  ' "' ,,$,,,,,,,, ,,,,$$/#64+1% ' 1 "%-''."'0'%' -2  ' 7( &''*' ('  7(   % 7(* (220 1  $  $ +''% ,,,,,,,,,,,. 1((7'%'  "'   2' ('  ' "' ,,$,,,,,,,,,,,,$$)#64+1% ' 1 "%-''."'0 '%' -2 '7(&''*'(' 7(  %7(*(2207) $$+''%,,,,,,,,,,,.1((7'%' "' 2' (' ' "' ,$,,,,,,,,$$  788 (' "!% #64"'(7 -''-'2'' ( $     

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

0#$'(4$$

$"3(7 1((7'%' ("7'(( '$$' ( #34"'0'')2'' ;<( $ !))&7 2'' *( (' ( - "'"** )7(  "%-'"!'*' -'''" (' *' ''" $  * '-''() " #= -'0  7( % (-% ( (  *' 6$$ ) '7 '%'( 7 & 6$$2$$( (  ('=

$' %  %('% &7''-%"'"*"2'( -%1((7'%' ' 2'' ": >6 (*  ! $ - %  ) -' "% ( (' (  ( (  -&('( (' ( & * ) ('  -2()!'' *'(-( (  #$ 7 &' 6$$ * ) "  '(0   %  2 % ('   ''"'22 -& ) -!'( (  "'"**&( (' ( ( ( "(   ()-'"*' (' $: '%' #$5$3#$#$6$$  (& -2()!'' (  # =

 +#?3?./ )- '( #$#$3#$4$$$ " ( - ('    3 =4

 +#64?3?4./  "!   * 4 4

$ - %  ) 7(  ( 7 '%'( %  '% # 

 %&*' ''  '*"! 4

$)" "%7' (" 1((7'%'  '' *  * '  ''0 ' -"  ""& 1((7'%' &7''-(-!' & *( ($ '()(% ("'"*)'"%% : >% =(*#0=#(* #003006(*7(&* )-2()!')(* ) ('( (' ( $$0 $$)$$1((7'%' ( #$ 7 &'6$$"'( 2' (' ' "' 7 '%'(#$ 7 & 6$$3#$'$$4

"'"*( #$)"'$$#64 "'0'%' -2 '7(&''*'(' 7(  %7(*(220 '*('  "'*( (7 ( +(#3.$   &$$ )!(  ) ' ""' *'$ $7'(('( $  *'   '-''() " #=  0 '(( * ( 7(  &' ( ) (!7   " (  * ) *' ) - (  1((7'%' '*'  (-2()!'' 0"* )(&*'$"* ) "(&"%*')-( 1((7'%'  ("!% "'$7'(('"'0 '' '  >3 ( ' '%)-"! $ '-''()" #=  " (  2'* !(''% 7( % -2('  ( 77  ( (  (

 3+4. ' $ :(  - ( !('% ( 77  '"*' % " @' '% $7'((' $ '"*' 7((' )2*' (A ) &  (  #$7'((' $ ( (  1((7'%' ('  '  7 '%'(  '-  %  ('  ''"'220 (' %&)* )- (%"( )-4$72 -$ * )(' "' % ( 77 * "! "'"* (&  !  *' ('  -2()!'' $

('  ''"'22 " $$ #64 "' "'"*  %"  22  * 34 "' $:2( 77 !(''")"%( (  ('4$7'(('($ "'/#5$'($"'/3$'($3"'/#$)"'($ 3"'$ *)*'-(%  '' )* )7"*"(  ( 3"' 0'( 77 22%$) ('  '" 7(('6#33 "' +&.$ * " ) "% (' " 0 ' 1( & 4<   ' (  "'"* " 7%-% ( -!'( %$  2 ( -( )( " ) 2'"% 1((7'%' "%' --(7( ( 77 ( "'"* *-!'&* )"!%  (%'"  (( -!'(' -'% )(0 ' 72 ( 77  !('' " "% (  -)% %-!'''-"  -!'( %1((7'%'"%+(#.$   #  $$ ($&$  (&$""(# (&)( (  ( '&0 *'"! "%%)(&(%' ( (' ($  * )"(  '"%$$0$$)$$1""'""' 7'%+(04./ -' *''-2()-! +(=./ $7'(('$$ 7'+( 6#./7"*"-2()-! +(##.$)"(  '"% (% 7'%+( 34.) $7'(('$$'"*'7(('7'+(=6.$  : >% =(*#/=#(*#/6(* ("-" %1((7'%( (' ()'-"  '2'%1((7'%'0-!'&* )"!% (!' ('  -2()*'(-("'1   ""  (' *'(  ''0'%'' '2'"% ((  )-2( ( 1((7'%'"'"* ' '" "%: >=#(*="' % )('%$ -( :  > =# (* 030 22  (' (7 (  '"%( '*'  ( "0(2% *'-" -('  '"%')(7 -)% 0) '*'"  (1 ( (7 (  '-!'((-2' '7(&''*'('   % 7(*(22$: >=#(*4 (-!'& (' -2 "%%((: >=#(* "' %  0 ' -" ( "  '"  (70   ('  -2()!'' (  ((    -(' (-2 '"%(' ('-(7$: >=#(*=( (-!'& )2 (' -2()!'-!' (( -2 "%%((: >=#(*"' % 0 '-" 0 (( ( ('"! 0"88-!' -!'(7 ("7''-' ( -!''(" -% %7(!)-""'%7!) %$   "!& (' ( )*0  " * ) " (&"% *' ) - (  1((7'%'  ( "!% "'$7'(('"'0'' '  >3 (  ' '% ) -  "! $   $7'((' $$   +( #. "2-("'"*'(+$$$$. (*'"%7( (  (' -2()!'' ) ('    22' *  "%-'% '(!'*" "'"*--7'0 ' "!% --2'  ! "%'  *( '-'% 7 '!'*" /     7"  '% 2' "%-'% ! "% '%  -2'%   '""''  "'"* (% -'%(  ( 77 ('  ( "%'  -!'('$ :( % " (  '""'"%0  " ('"!%   -"% ( 77 0 '(('  '"*' % -'-% -'% -2(' ($ '' )-( " ( 7''- ( (%%0  !'* ) '"%(  -'%  "'"*  " ((% 22'  2*'("7( %7'%"%& )!'('-'%( 

 +4. ( "%' ( 77  +7''. !(''   ($ * ) " (  '""'"%0   7 '& 7''( 7'"* '"*'' "'"* -'& ('"!%  (&% ) (!7 %  ((  "!%   " ($  " '"*'(  (*'"%"!% (&'  ) ( ( ( )  " (  (!7 '  !'*('  *)2*'$ * ) " )22"% (&'(  )% 0 "%  ('"!% (&' ((')'"*'7(('$ '')-("*% 7(  7 (   !'*  ) -'%  '*1(*"  '  "'"* ' '"  )  " (  (!7 ''-'%)('%$ *( & " ( (' "!% (!7 %$ 

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

 >=(*3( (""'&  (' -2()!'' *' -''-'( 2'% -* )( 2%-)('( $( '&0 #64"'(7 0' " (' '"'(220"2%-)('(0'(('  ( & (' -2()!''  ""'%-''-'(2'% -$ 

 >#=3(*# (*'(' (%' (""-%7( % " ((% -!%  % 0' ') " (('%-!% (' (*'(%' ( * -!' ')2 " (('%2' ('(-!'(' (7(  "%'"%$0(%% *' (' (0)2&  >#=3(*#( (7(  " ((%" "%  "%'"%$  "'A