Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-07-43096/14 AI generated

2-07-43096/14 · Viru Ringkonnakohus

Case Number 2-07-43096/14
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

 .3..00.!#+9.../!+%%% /C0((/## $,,%%%    .# .   1  2  .2.  .  =31 .. $"%+8D.48%D:$",,09 5"-809 72 .  ((/ B",*#!2B,+# .2..3/30(2/./#%8#$!#!%%"0 2...3.9.39./# . . ((/B&!#* 3.1.(.  (/2((/..9.3.# .  .9.3        /  399./  2      .    (. 3. (1  (/2  (/  .  .9.3.  09.  .  .9.3 3(..  2  2  3AA/3.# "$#%8#!%%8  .  2  .2  (/2 33  2  ./  .3  $%  09   2# . .   /. =//B$+-#$2B$+*#$... (/3.9." ...(/(. 3.3.#../$8#$%#!%%* .(/.3/3# /.0((/.9.29..(3./ .2/#   0     "  0"    .23%!#%-#!%%&0.1013...=./. .29../3.23./2/# 0.1.2 2%8#$!#!%%"0... 1  9/.  2  .(//  3  3 (3. .  (..    (  ...  ..# %8#$!#!%%"020.../.3/.2 /2 .(....//.0(03.... (+$8!8%# 3..0.. (.2/3..3/ 0 /../3# 0.1 .  29..    %8#$!#!%%"  0  29  (  923(.3  .90.  .2  .  .(/ /  2/: $7 0  0#!#" 9.1.=/30/.3323.$.AA09 2 .0 2.3  09 .#   .9/1 .  0  2.3  2    =/3 0//.33 .09 /#2 9..33.= 0  (33  09  /    ./  .(//   . 3  2  3. 2//..2=+$8!8%;!723.2/.9.1..2 (..2.!%%"#. (32../(.# .3. ..23.3 .229//.2 %8#$!#!%%" (+$8!8%3.=. .0.29//2 3...../  33#   2  9.3      3(.    ; "7 .3.. . .00#,#!20#,#"01.9.33../ 9/2< (0//../;+709../ ./ .  .3. > 0  0#!#*  2  0#!#&    ..  9./  .  33 (3....3./0#!#!..3.9.399./#3. 0#!#! .0#-#!20#-#";87 .3...23/%8#$!#!%%" =/2..23/(/"$#%8#!%%8# /..2=2309 3...(3/0 // (..3.9..3.#.29/ (#.2/...2.9..3.# .  ..  9./  (..#   .   .  ..   

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-07-43096/14 · Viru Ringkonnakohus:  .3..00.!#+9.../!+%%% /C0((/## $,,%%%    .# .   1  2  .2.  .  =31 .. $"%+8D.48%D:$",,09 5"-809 72 .  ((/ B",*#!2B,+# .2..3/30(2/./#%8#$!#!%%"0 2...3.9.39./# . . ((/B&!#* 3.1.(.  (/2((/..9.3.# .  .9.3        /  399./  2      .    (. 3. (1  (/2  (/  .  .9.3.  09.  .  .9.3 3(..  2  2  3AA/3.# "$#%8#!%%8  .  2  .2  (/2 33  2  ./  .3  $%  09   2# . .   /. =//B$+-#$2B$+*#$... (/3.9." ...(/(. 3.3.#../$8#$%#!%%* .(/.3/3# /.0((/.9.29..(3./ .2/#   0     "  0"    .23%!#%-#!%%&0.1013...=./. .29../3.23./2/# 0.1.2 2%8#$!#!%%"0... 1  9/.  2  .(//  3  3 (3. .  (..    (  ...  ..# %8#$!#!%%"020.../.3/.2 /2 .(....//.0(03.... (+$8!8%# 3..0.. (.2/3..3/ 0 /../3# 0.1 .  29..    %8#$!#!%%"  0  29  (  923(.3  .90.  .2  .  .(/ /  2/: $7 0  0#!#" 9.1.=/30/.3323.$.AA09 2 .0 2.3  09 .#   .9/1 .  0  2.3  2    =/3 0//.33 .09 /#2 9..33.= 0  (33  09  /    ./  .(//   . 3  2  3. 2//..2=+$8!8%;!723.2/.9.1..2 (..2.!%%"#. (32../(.# .3. ..23.3 .229//.2 %8#$!#!%%" (+$8!8%3.=. .0.29//2 3...../  33#   2  9.3      3(.    ; "7 .3.. . .00#,#!20#,#"01.9.33../ 9/2< (0//../;+709../ ./ .  .3. > 0  0#!#*  2  0#!#&    ..  9./  .  33 (3....3./0#!#!..3.9.399./#3. 0#!#! .0#-#!20#-#";87 .3...23/%8#$!#!%%" =/2..23/(/"$#%8#!%%8# /..2=2309 3...(3/0 // (..3.9..3.#.29/ (#.2/...2.9..3.# .  ..  9./  (..#   .   .  ..   

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text



   

      

                      !"#$%#!%%&'(  

    !)%*)+"%,- 

                 !  

"  #$%&'( "  !    

.!&#%+#!%%&.          

 / ' 0.1 )   

 23.%&#$%#!%%& )             0.  /   '   4/ 55555555555.666666566666 / /)

37

..2  4/55555555555. 66665)5566666 /) 37 * *  ! ) +%,(-,+((%

  ,+(& -#($./   ,      !  0      /      ,              !               /        !   ,     !

0        /       ,          0   "           

  #(0/       /         1      0/ 

  22      

        ,

 ! !  

     3+4%,#              

       1          1

          5       

  , !  

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

 " 0( (   ##  33  ",&*8%  #   (1  .2  2 *,*8%%# 20.2. 923(. ( 33*,*8%%.0( ( ",&*8%2.",&*8% (.. .0. >  8$"%%% (.. 0( (33+$!!8%2.33 $-$*%%%# 

  .  !+#$%#!%%*  399  29.   /  9.  2  2  . 0/.( /3.9.#  23%,#$$#!%%* /.90.(.0.2. 923(. 0( (33",&*8%23./29...2/#  .23"%#$$#!%%*2 .../#

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

.!&#%+#!%%&./..2.3(..2 92   0( (   33  ",&*8%    2  (.   3./  . 33$,,%%%#(3./29..2/#

 + ...0.  /./ %8#%,#!%%"$!#%,#!%%"2 "%#%,#!%%"0.(332/.2/3=#.2 . ..%8#%,#!%%"0%-#$%#!%%"./.*8%%# 0(33....%-#$$#!%%"33-%%%2$+#$!#!%%-33 ++%%%#$!#%,#!%%"0..22$+#$!#!%%-33 88%%%##0(338%%%%2.8%%%#"%#%,#!%%" 0..22$+#$%#!%%+.33+%%%2 !&#$%#!%%+0(33$%%%%# 2  ..  .. (/  .2.  %8#%,#!%%" $!#%,#!%%"  2  "%#%,#!%%" 0.    .  923(.3.       0(2/./# . .

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

. . ((/B",*#$.132/) (.. ./. 3..#2 1/.2.2 3%8#$!#!%%">%8#$%#!%%*.

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

 - .3// (3..229. /# //3.#.21.0(2/./#0 0#!#-399././.3.9.2/ 3 09 ##!#*91..  ./.3  .3.#.9/1. ./.3(3.(. ."$#$!#!%%"#2. $8#$%#!%%*#.#").3.9.23AA/3# ...9.3/.2(33+$8!8% .33.../09.3(.. 223AA/3.# .2  1 .    (    ../  09.  13(..  2  3AA/3.   =/3..(0.=./#   !      23%$#%*#!%%&2 .0129..0.1/3. 2..3.3.#

...(/23(///3...(/. /./.#.2./.02(20(2/3. 9./  1/3...9.3.#     (.  //    0.)      3.(  3  2 0 .0(2//3/3.29.3.#  

  0"   

.. /9 . 23.2//.3..   /  2  0(2/./    0.1  9./      .   .=.3#  23../.2 .0...  (  (/#  ../.3./29..2/# 

1.3.29//..1/3 338,**8%40( ( ",&*8%2.33$,,%%% 7(/.22 ..(/.# (.1 3..0(2/.2 . . .3./.B-8+#- 0 2/0(2/3..# 

.0.1 9/.391293.#  0.1  9./    . . %8#$!#!%%"  0    0.  (3./39.2.(//33 (3..3. ..=.3#.2/ 9./02(/2.(/3.#  0.1 9./.%8#$!#!%%"0(33/. . /...3...=.3# 2 3.2/   .  %8#$!#!%%"  0.  4.##!%)!!7  9.1 .  .2    

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

 2/ . .3 ./. 2  .3.  /. B$*"#$2#"B$*+B-8$B-8!B-8+B-8*#$0#$B--&2B-*%#