Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-08-57140/5 AI generated

2-08-57140/5 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus

Case Number 2-08-57140/5
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-08-57140/5 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

          

        !"  

#"$!%"   !!&'((                 )!$!!*#'#"$!%"& +$,# ,$&("              ,(-#,("#".,/($%, ) )-" 0+1$#!!(, ,(2"--,,-,('"2)          % ,(-#,("#".,/($+#,#,$!!2 33333333"$!%44,0 #"+,(2  -, !.#5 $!  )  ) + ,,$"$!!2 33333333333+ "$!% #%-,$"#,#,$!%33333333333)     #%"22,(-#,("#".,/($%, ) )-") 6  &', )  )  , (-#,(" #"., /($  $"$  0 74$2 $%$"%-,,2$!&,8$#!!(, 1(,) 6 &', ) ),(-#,("#".,/($$"$).&*#, $"(,&$#2,,2,"&&+!999+ $#!!(,6,,$""&,(,-,,-,+ :&$#2,,2,"&&)

!%"!" 6,&, 4%,2 #" $!%" 0).&*#,  %, &, &66#" )  )  $"""- .($!(!2  ; %!," #,&,( , *#,,, $#2,,2,""0 00+ $#!!(,#-2)

"((,2$!%"!",-,,-,&6,2-$)      ,(-#,("#".,/($&("$""2 6 ) )$(2)  

     ,(-#,("#".,/($-',*,2.,!!($*"0.6- !!$"+  !" $6!,&&,+ $",2 &, %, & $", -,, $"" &<<2"&, #" $!%" !" -,$" -$ &,+ #" ,($!(($!%"+ $" ""# $*" -',2$ %(22 $,# ,$" &("+ $", $*" , !  %(2&,,"(,) 

)  )  -',*  !" . ,2 $  #" $!%" '#" $!%"& 

 708  !" $6!,&&,    .6- !!$"+ ,2 $  $',$   -&,&,'."-,,&,$- ,$)    !""# "$" #% "# &'# &$##%#$(## 

!%" !( $!%"("2 $!  $!%" $,# ,$" -&   .6- !!$"  %, $6!,&&, 7 0 98+ %!,2 &+  $", $!  $!%" &66#"2 6% $ $,# ,$",-+!($!%"',"%, !"#%"22)  ,-2" $!!  ,2  &66#" $,# ,$" -" (2&, $!%"" !( $! $6!,&"2 =06"2$!##1).&*#,78) !( $!  2,$ $ $,# ,$" -" (2&, $!%"") ! + $ $!%" !( &66#("2$,# ,$"-&,6% +,!6%$!%"$,# ,$"-("2) !%" ,*+,,($,, = &6#,"2 !"&,-6,-,2  !",2)  ,  !"2 %(2* $!%"  =2   + 0+  6,2 #-2    !") 

!%" ,*+  %, !( %,-2" &6#,"2 ""   !"2 ',",$" .'% (2"2(,($"""* !"#%"2&,) 

 =   + 0 $!% -',* $!%" %  !" -', !& " %,  !"#%"22%,-2"&6#,"2  !"2',",$".'% (2"2 ""+ $", $! + $ $!%" !( &66#("2 -&, 6% + , ! 6% -("2)  "%" !$ %  ,"2 >$,,2 -6,2 $!  .!! !&$-'"$ (,( !"-',* "%"%$!%","(,.,2&) 

"(,!"22+!"$"""*"(("&, 6,&,$-6 .!!, *#,,$,+ 6* $!%" #-2  =    6"  !" -6  $,# 2-! &6#,*.'% (2-!4$(',",$".'% (2") 

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

 =    $!% $"""* %,  !" #%"2&,  $!  "* %  $"$ -6  &', 0+1$#!!(,5#-2 =096" ).&*#,  $"(, & $#2,,2,"&&+ ! 999+  $#!!(, 6,,$" "&,(,-6 &',-,,-,+:&$#2,,2,"&&) 

!%".!!#$(2"2%,&,("*4%,2 = "$!%"!" 6,&,) 

 = 9   .  $!% "((,* $!%" !& " , -,,-,& 6,2-$ !"), !"2$!%""((,* = 9."  !"!&",-,,-,&6,2-$) 

=9$!%$((*%,&("$""2.!!+$$% "$!"%,)

!%"+#%"22%,+ 6* =9"% &("$""2$! $(2)  

!%"(,$A