Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-06-21387/18 AI generated

2-06-21387/18 · Viru Ringkonnakohus

Case Number 2-06-21387/18
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-06-21387/18 · Viru Ringkonnakohus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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text



    

         

                      !"#!$#%$$&'(  

    %)$")%!*&+ 

                       ! " #$%&$' ()  * ) )  )

,%+#$*#%$$&,          

 -,*+.,/ +   

 -/.(0 +     )  )   )  ) .,  -    , *+  1,2  &$!$33"4 ,    ,  *+ 5 3  ,)'6     2)

782209:9 

,,0    ,)'6   0  1,2 !$!"$+4! ,  ,  !  ,)'6     2)

78.20  ,- ./0 1 * + '!23 2'334

  2'35 '% 4!    )                   

       2        !  6       ) )     2 -)      )   6   (    )        ,

   36                &  )    6 

  77)      

        2

 % *  

    ) 8'%42                ,

       )&   )       &

)             ) )  ) 

 ) 2 *  

    ) 85!%2$          ) &               2 *        &     (     )            2    )          0 ,)'6 0,!!#$&#%$$" , 2,0 -,*+ ,;*43!3%(2#  2,., $+#$;#%$$*(7,2.0*$#$3#%$$* 0,)7<<.7,07<<,00,0 7,,,7#. ,0,)7<< .  <2,7,  .#;#4  ,  ,  ,0  ,7   ,  $$+= .6  ,7  ,,277,# $!#$&#%$$",00 (;*43!3%70. ,0, 607(,(/,,,2%%;%$0(  ,,,,2%3$$# 

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

 * #,02,   ,7.2/(#$+#$;#%$$*., (7,2 ( ,7.7,0,2(770 .,.,2,7,.20,,22 00,)7<<.,(77,#.., $+#$;#%$$*,00 ( 7.( (,773&4;%$* 0  ,77!!%"43"#,0(,7.( (2 2(,7  ,#,0,02 , 2  77 !!%"43"77,/7.,27>0 2,7 2,,0,<,(7,2..  07> #,0 , 2,<22?4$#!0#*?4& #!#  ,2  2 ,  .( (    7,2 0  , ,0    7,,,2< 2 ,0,0.,(,   77!&"$%$4/7(, 607(,70 , ((2?!!*#&0?!"%#!#

 7 ,,20 7$+#$;#%$$*5%"#$"#%$$" ,,,7, 77,  , ,  $+#$;#%$$*  (7,2  (   ,7  .. 7 76,277+$%!!3422  ,77!!%"43"#

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

  ,  %+#$*#%$$&  ,  0    2, ,0,  7(,,  0  60 ( 77!&"$%$40(7,206,,0 2#

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

 0.,  766,,,2 22721 2$$+= 07 ,$$%=8# ,0,  607(,,2  77  !&"$%$4      ,,  ,   # ,2 77/  ,776,2$+#$;#%$$*(7,2..77 !!%"43"0  ,7 ,,20 7$+#$;#%$$*5%"#$"#%$$" 77+%3*#   0    ,2  .(02,2      ,,   (    607(,7,027#   *      07!3#$4#%$$&0 ,./06,,.,/27,0 7,202# 0  ,  62,  ,      ,0  $+#$;#%$$*  (7,2  ., 2,2#   ..  (77  (,,  ,0  2  , ,2 ( 177+$%!!3480 ,,,7 ,#,#  ,7,# 0   ,   ,  , ,  $+#$;#%$$*  (7,2  ..  .#*  , >06  77  7,,,7  ,,6,2  ,6,0# 0  ,  7,   2776,2,0.,,6,,7,,,,2 7/ .6 ,7,770   ,7.2#   ,   6( ) ) 

,, 26 , 07,022,.,/   ,  .(02,2 7,  %+#$*#%$$&  ,      2  0  ,/  ,7,2,?"3"#!.#3,<,27,72 7,(,,0,7,7,6/ ,7#  6 , 07,02,6,/,0,!!#$&#%$$" ,  2  ,0  ,  ,7,  ,,  ,  ;*43!3%    (2  1,##;8# ,%+#$%#%$$&, 620(,0.,0, 607(, !&"$%$41,##!!+8# 

,%+#$*#%$$&,2,0,0,7(,,0 60!&"$%$4# 

, , ,7,2,?;*"#!./,,72 0.(02,2# , ,72,?;;%#&76,,.(02  ,, ,,20202,,,20622,(2270,2, 06227,22722#./,.(0277 ,(,0 (,0>,, 62,#./,(,(22 <<7#7(2,(2, ,./,,2.(027# 

/,7,,7,,2 ,7,2, (, ,# 

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

/,7,20 60,2( 0 02006,2,2,,.(027,# 

, ,   ,7,  2,  ?"3" #! .#3  ,<,/   7  ,7  ,  ,  .,/  .(02,,  0    ,,2 02,7,02/0,77,7, 7,7,,2,,.(022# 

/,,2077,,, .(0227,,27,(77,.,,7 (7( 22#  ,2/7,, , , ,7,2,?";" ,<,7,/,7,,6/ ,7#  .,/  /  27  , ##  7,  ,  ,<,7 #  ,2<72,0,7# 

 +

 02 , ,7 ,2, 0  ,7,  2, ?";"?"3!?"3%?"3;?"3"#!.#3?"3+#!.#*?""&0?"+$#