Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-07-26863/34 AI generated

2-07-26863/34 · Viru Ringkonnakohus

Case Number 2-07-26863/34
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-07-26863/34 · Viru Ringkonnakohus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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text



        

        

       !"# "$ %&'   

  $( !($)%)*  

  

          

       !"#$" ##%   "&"#'# (&'#      

+$," -"$ %.//        



 .// 0       // 0   +1       2  3 44444444444 +  4444444 444 55(55 44444 3( .6 ++1     + 0   2  + 3 !- $)-))+ 03-,   //(

.6 3    31  '   7   31    )*+)), 

  &"#$" ##-  

 " #% '-'!       ./         " 

     "      ./         

       "   1  +$ " !"$ ! + 3+1//(

.88 3. 1 +. 793++88 3. 1 +" 

+$*" !"$ !.// 3+   3.+ '+. +1+ ++/+73+' 3. " +.// + 3 31/ . 3733:0'+1  7'13  ' +. +" 

  $ 1       +  #" %"$ %    +     3  +1    + 0   +  //( .  88 3. 1   $*" -"$ ! + "," )( $;,)  3+. " 

+#-" %"$ !.// '+   3.+1 ++     +88 3. 1   + . + +   1  '+  3 03 $ "##"$ )'. +3+887  "$-'7+. 1+88313 1  7+  +.  + ++3     1  ..  -       7/ + +/7+. +..<,!$ %   "

.+.// ++ +1+ +. 3 1 + 1.+ $ 7/1.// /+++ .+. ++"  +1  .  #!" ,"$ !   1   +   3   3  +   3  +. +/+3"       +  +1  .   1   +      3  +/ +3  3"  1  .  *"#$"$ !     +/7+  .+    '+  1  ++  +887  '7+. 03 + +. + . 7+9 +  /1.' +. +"19 +. +++10" 

+$," -"$ %.// '7++ .+    

+ 0   +  +88 3. 1   $*" -"$ !  +   "," )( $;,)   3+.    ++3     +887    "$-  '7+.   03  + +. 1+ ++  .++3. 1 +1'+* " )"$ ! = '7++ .+     + 0 +).  7  +  9 +   /1.' +.   '3    +887   '7+.  03   + +.   '3.+'7+. . +'++='7++  .+     + 0 +19 +. '3 10. '3+=+1.+31/+ 13" +.// + 3 +  ++3+1

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

  * .+   3+3  3.+  0  ++  0'   + 3+3 ' +"++ . +. ++/+3+/+ +11/  + .+3.+1'3 ++0'  +' +" 3 +/++.8833 17+ ++3 2. ++0 . ++33+63+/++  ++1 3+33 7/3+  +"+3 1 . 1 +./  +3 + +/1 3 +3.+ 1. ++3 7/3+ 3++3 +01++31"  3 +7307'131 +3.    3+/+1/  3  +3  . 1   +   3+.   1+   3+  7/3  +" 1   3'  31 3' +3. 3 .'1++3 1 . 3. ++3. ++#( + 3+.  ++/+3  1.     7   3.  3  1+3   1  7/3+ '+1+; 31+" 17+   ++3+++: +3+788 3. +/+:   +3+3  3+88 33. 3>$<"#  3+3+/+.+ '  +/+.  +. 7 + /++1/      ' . " &  +  ++          +3  1  7+   +.  7' +.  ++313" '+3 1 +'++ 1.+13 +  +3 +1 +3 ++3 +. +++"+ . 3. 07 +37/ + .+'+. +1             .+  '+. +  '++   +  9 .  +88 3. 1 +1'+33  3+88 33. 3 >$- "#  .    1/  "    .   ++  3.   +0   +88 3. 1 +1'+. 3  3+88 33. 3 >$- "#   .    1/    1   .+  '7+.     +.+ 3+ >*!#"#7"<'+7+ /++:  +.+3+  ><$%"#7"$"    3  +  1  73  13   +3  . 1   +   3+.  0+3++. 1 +/++0'+++ 3+.  

       +.   .+"  +.  .' . 7/ * " )"$ !     3  +  03  1   '+  . 1   +  3+. 1+03+88 3. 1 $*" -"$ !+1'+" 88 3. 1 1++ ++3'3+:9 +3++ ++31 :103 *"#$"$ !+03 +/7+" 37++. +1'7+.+ 1 ++3   +/ 3+1+/ 3+ 3. 73013"  3++88+'77. '3. 73.+ 11+88 3. 1 3 ++. 7/39 730 13 3'313+3+'3 3+3 +. 99 3"   +.+3+ >#)%"$+0.+31   '7++.+"+3+1//313 +.3  +1.+3"  1.$!" )"$ %.// 070.+.// +9 +31+ +3 +  +. .+"

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

+.//  3 +.883317+  ++ 2. ++0 . ++33+63+/++ ++1    3  +  3  3  7/3 +  +" 1      33 3+.+  3+ +  9+   /++ .   +  3+  1 3+.+ +++7  +"3+.+3+ >## "<  /0  ++   +  ++. "      +  3  + . 3  +  3 +"// 0 +1 +3+3. +++.  3 7/3+  + 3+/++. ++ ++.  7'1" .+          +/++  . ++ +.   7'1  0  . ++33. ++ "03. +++

32 +6.+. +' +9 +. +31++ 1

3  ++ 3   ++3  +  '" '. 3  + .  3  +  +  3  1    + +/339+1." & 33  +.+3+ >!./  ++ .// 0 +1 '+39,7/ +++ +. 3 +. ++.//  +  ./  +" 1  +/ 3   +  ++  +/+1   +.   1  ++ . 3.  1.  1+ ++37+" . 7 3 .+ + + 7 .// +. +/+1  +. ;. ++ +.   +" 1  ++  +/+1   +.   +  0 ++1. 3. +++" // 0  1++31 31 ? +7+"   .++3  .// 0  '+     +  $!" )"$ %  .//   .+ 3++ +11+ +/+. 3. "  1 +$!" )"$ %+ .// 0 +$," -"$ %.// "  .++3.// 0  1+3   +1" 

  - 1  ++  $!" )"$ %  .    + +  9 .++3  .// 0+      1 + .  3 3++  31 ? +7+ . ++3 3  1+.+.// 0"  1  ++  * " )"$ %    + +  '7+0  $%"##"$ !  '. +3  37  ? +"  +1. #" !"$ % 1 +.// 0 0+.// 0 7'13.+1+"  1 ++ .// 0 +1 ++0 ++3 +/++" 0   +. +   +  3+       ' 3+3   3  +.  +"// 0 +1/ +3++. +  1.+. + +37'13.+3"0 +1 ++ +.  ++  +/+1   +.   +  0  +    +1  .  3. +++1/0 +.  .1/ 1

" 

+ #" !"$ %.//   3+3 3  317+ $!" )"$ % ++3.// 0+13+  3.   +" +.//   +   +  +3  +  1  +/++  .// 0  1  31 ? +"* " )"$ %+.+7+   +  +313 7+3+311/ +9 ++3.// 0 +.7+ ++31 ?  +7+ . ++3.// 0" .7/1++3+00  31+++1'7+0+. 3+" 7 331  3  .+'++;. ++'++ 7+ ++3.// 0+  + +. +9.1"  3 +.// 0 7'13+31  3. " '+  +1  +   +3  1   3    +     +  .+3+   0.// 0+/0 +. + .+.+  77' .'++ +' + +.+13++.//   '773   /0 +.   .  +.  3  7+    . +  '   1 01+ " 

   ++3  /  .// 0  .+ 1 3  3  + .+ 3++.// 3 17'13+3 .// 0/ +3  ++9 +. " /  +  1  .+ 1 3+  /+0 +  1    +3    +  3+1++88 3. 1 $*" -"$ ! 3+. "  ++  3  3  +88 3  3.   3  >$< "# ' 3    33 73  +88 3. 1   +  . ++'+.   788 33  .  +88 3 /0 +.   .+  9    1  +  +88 3. 1   + /  1. 7/1/ +7/+"  /  +  1  .+ 1 3+  /+0 +  +88 3. 1   +    ++3 $*" -"$ !2+""%(# 611 1+/++3* " -"$ !2+""%#6"  .++3+88 3. 1 + +  +19+.' +++ ./  +3++. ++'+.  37+' 788 33 3

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

. + +1 +3++. 3. "   '+  .// 0   +1    +      .  0.' + +  +31 +. "  ++  +.+3+ >#)%"$0.+31   1/+/0 +.+'  .+'7++.// "  +33/++'+0 .+ .+3 1+. 1.// 0 +1 3 +  ++"  701  ./  3+7'13.+.// 0 +1 + +.+ +1 + +1 31.++. " ++  +.+3+ >$#%' 01

3  +  ++ 33  3  317   31"1.+ 1 3+ /++ .+ + 3;+ + 33 9+3+1 31++ 7     31  77  +. " #)" )"$ %  + +  3 9.   '+    1  2+""#<%6"   1     +1   31  10  +3"  // 0    ' +    3+3  1 +    +/+1  '77  * " )"$ !

  ! /+  17/  3 +.  .+/+1 1/ .   +887/ "" $" !"$ !" .     '+    .// 0  +1  / +     +   .++3  7/  3   +.    + 3+  +0  3  .+3.+   ++ ' +"  701  '+3+ 3  3+88 33. 3>$< "#    +88 3. 1   +   3+.    3 +/+  1  +  +  1 9+.' +++./  +3 3+++88 3. 1 + +  "  // 0/ 3++ +3 3+3+ + 3++3 3+  7/3  +  3 +   ' " /  1  7   +. +    +  1 .   3.   0  ++    +.+ 3+ >,"#.+7/3"  // 0+337'133 +1+    

+88+  . . + 1'77 . '   17+3"  @+3  +0 .+ $," -"$ %.// 1/++.+.+1$!" )"$ % .// 0 3.+"  1 3+3+1  +.+3+ ><"$>)-, >))<>)))"$>))!"