Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-05-1793/22 AI generated

2-05-1793/22 · Viru Ringkonnakohus

Case Number 2-05-1793/22
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-05-1793/22 · Viru Ringkonnakohus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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

              

     

       !"  ! 

"! # 



          $%&$'&($$%)*+      (,$-,./'0                         !    

$%&.$&($$/           1122 3        ! (4&$%&($$% "         2  56 1 122 5" 777777777776 2  " * 122&

 56   5" 8!    " .$049.406 "  " !"& # $%&

' (          !  "  )*+,)+-)).    +  "               + #          /             0) 

           1               

     +

2      /    

  " 3-,* +0       

      4

  +      /          1                 +  "    

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

+   </$ :: 2 ! !! +!    :: 2& " +" ::"+*!"::&<49 &.(83 ::" *!+*::;!3 "! !::! " ::E! "   ::      +8!  ; & " !*! :: **":: 2 *2!5<%(6&   <49    3 ::" ! +" ::!  " +* ::E!  ::  8!  " !  :: ! &   ::"  ; ;2  ::!! !"*:: 88

**" 28!::8!&::" ::  *22" +* +8"  883   ;    +*!  :: "   ""&  F  "+8 3+*! " +* +8"::"   +;2  ::!!+* !"*" ":: +*! ::  "<%(  &   "  (%&$(&($$-  + " " :: 2   (  "2  "2:: 2!!&+ 2  2!!+" 22 + !3 3+!"2 "3   +2    !" *" 3 "!"    +* !*! 83 !&  " +"      2+  +8"    " :: 2 !" 3 +!    +!3   "" + :: & +*" "      :: " 8  !  +" *"" 5!28+!6 *" ;;!+8":: 8 !  ! & !  2*     2+  " +!3::A& !2+"*":: 2!"$.&$.&($$95& & ..0' "A!(%&$(&($$-"!"2& 

  ! 0$&$'&($$0   0,(,.,'-,$0  "   +"  "!  ::+"   3  ::  2" *    *2" :: 2 <%( &.  "::  "::" +" *:: 2 *2!+!"::+"  * ":: 2 *22</' &. 8" ;  ! 8 !::""& +*" "   :: 2 ;2  !! ::" 2   !"  2" ::     :: 2 *2"  <%(  .    !*  3 +""    " :: 2 *22</' &.  & 

"   (%&$(&($$- + ":: 2 *2! ++ <%(::"::+ "82 $.&$0&($$-& 3 " :: 2 *22  </' &. 8" ;  ! 8 !::"!  $.&$9&($$-& 

+   <..' &.  ( ::! 2"!   ::" " !! :: !2 ::!8"!++"28+::! 8"!&*22+2"! ::""!!:: ! 2  *22++8 !!++!28+"!; ::; !2 & 

"          $4&$0&($$-     " ! ::! *22+!!&$4&$9&($$-8!    *2:: 2::+ ++ </' &. $4&$9&($$-&::" !   +8  *22+ .9&$9&($$- 2; " ! ;  ::  !8 2  4..4   2  9 ::28+ 2  '--  .$   ! !.0'9D.'.0.&::!::"2  8($&$9&($$-&

     +  :: 2 *22   $.&$9&($$-   $.&$9&($$-  *22+++*!8" 3 "::"2" *22+ !!-28+  $.&$9&($$- ! $4&$9&($$-& ! *22+  .9&$9&($$-++" *22++8 !! %28+&  3+8 !*! ;+%28+2  & 

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

 3!$%&.$&($$/" 2*""; 2 3+8"  ;!&<4-/ &.2&.   3 !8!!2 3 "!& *3 !  2*"   "! 8!    2  +   <4-9 &4!2*"!&



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

+   <(9 &0 +*3  " ; ! *"" !  ::+" ! &  "  +   2 ! "*""!" +      * !" :: 2 2    " " !  ::+" 2  ,!&  !$%&$-&($$42*";+!!5& %$6!8"+3 !2 ;+++ "*" ?1122:: +$'&($$9,$4&$9&($$-@5& (.6&

8"+*+;++* !! 8+ 2 /4'0   , ! "&  .4&$9&($$/! "$.&$.&($$9:: 2 (5& ..06! 2&4&. 2 !8"/4'0!  !8?29&93!88  +3 8"!@  " ! .4&$9&($$/ " + " !8"  ?+!     ! 2  " *" 3   !" 8"+" *!+8 ++ ! @&

+!* ""$.&$.&($$9:: 2 (  !2 +! 2+*"& 

+ <4-( &(+*  *"!! !   " !  8" ! !  !  *28  +!& !*!2 +! ++*"" 2  !  " *"  ::  !       ! $%&$-&($$42*";++! 5& %$6&  ;! *"2 3+8"      *2  :: 2  </' &.      $4&$9&($$- :: 2 0!$4&$9&($$-8!8"!& !"382 ++;!&      ::" !   *22+ +8  .9&$9&($$- 2; "  *   ! " !   "    ;+ !!2*"5& (.%$6& 

+!2+ !" "2  ! 8&"!"!  "!&    :: 2*"  * ! ::" 2    +"&   2 3 883  "!      " 2 !   "! 88+"2 !  "$.&$.&($$4 "<4$ &.0  !!2 ""& 

 "  !   "   <<4-.,4-9 <4-/ & .2&. <44%<4/$ &.&        ! "! #