Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-04-150/10 AI generated

2-04-150/10 · Viru Ringkonnakohus

Case Number 2-04-150/10
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

  . .748      " %/'%)')%%)  5 1- 2  # ,# ## 5###,"' ##  "! #","= #1- 2 "5#5##')('//')%%/  " #6#  #  = "  ;#   " =#" 5' )3'%0')%%) ,        .4%D03! " 5);#!#5;,5"# = "#5##### 5#"# #! ,  5 ,5"  #    ""5!"","5#5'  "#.-"==55('&' -"==5 5 ('&' , 6!   ; ",    ;#5,5"##5! EF&)& /   "   E F- &/) ;# =="; ;# , "   ==5 = >#'  ## ,5 #5 ;!#-"==55('&'### " = #  # #'  #!   1 2    #5;=>#!-"==55('&' , ,# 5# = " - '       .4%D03  -"==5 5 ('&'   1- 2  , ,# 5# = "   " - " #,5#" #= "'#!12 5#,##!   " ###,5#"= "'E   ;#! "#."##%/'/)'/334   )/'/)'/334  ,#  5 >># " ' "  ;"##"#  " #,5#"'    " ##5,#"; G" # = " H'      " # , ;##!  5 5# "   ,    " # #  = # 1 2  # '  %/'/)'/334   )/'/)'/334  ##5!","%/'%)'/33*'"5# 55#   #5 ,"" )/'/)'/334    # ," 5#= "##"#55/'&'!# !    ,## ## , #"  5# = "'#"! "#.  ,%.'%0'/33* 6%.'%0'/33*,#  " #,= #12  5 # -"#>#'  ">>!  # >># ,#  #  " 5"#! #     ,#!  #5 5    5#!  ## = 6  # #..*/))'3% ;;'  '4$     $.         //' 5 1 2  56 " /3'%0')%%4 6 7#   /))-/).8  =#    ! ;    #"  ## 1 2  ' #6,!%3'%/')%%.#,#  E F )4*-)43' 6   ;#!  1 2     )%%/-)%%) ,5# #5 #= '

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-04-150/10 · Viru Ringkonnakohus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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

               

       

     !"# $"         %&'%(')%%*+,   

   )-%.-/0%  

  12  &))(/!0.,# 12    /0300%,#   

/3'%)')%%4 )-%.-/0%       

 12 56   

    )/'%0')%%*+,           512 7#/%%%%/!" /*-/%/  8 # # 2" 9   5# #":

   7# /%%.30/%!   385#5    ! "# $       %&'()')((*   

 ')+(,+%-(

 '   ! "# $  

     '       $  .             /( $!        ! 

    0     $! 

  11            '   2 3*%  '-  

  ) )748       ! 0          '      0    .       

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

 #,"12  - " ##5&&  ! "# . 5 "# "'  %/'//')%%&  - 

  & &748 ##'   # #"  ",6"' )/'/)'/334 , 55  5"#">>#""4)&)*4'

#5 5 /'&' !  # #   5## ## !  5; ">>#" ,  ,5"   , ,# #  = "'  @" 1 2  ##!   5#!    "')*'//')%%/ ###!=""##  = "    =#    =#" "'    1 2  )/'/)')%%/ ## ;#  55'  ##  ;# 55  #!  5  ,')%%) #0.3*03!%0'  #( "70.3*03!%0A*BA(C)(&3&)!)%8,,55"")*03)4! /0'  )3'%0')%%).4%D03  = "  # 5 #  5##   5'      #' 1 2     #   +

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

#!)/'/)')%%/#12   " ##5 55 ,! " 5'/  ;#!  1- 2   , #5 ,55"  #; ">>#" 7!  5  #8 , #5,5"##5!!"   ##F /*!,#"#.# ">>#= "##5'

#!  " #5#!'#5'

  . .748      " %/'%)')%%)  5 1- 2  # ,# ## 5###,"' ##  "! #","= #1- 2 "5#5##')('//')%%/  " #6#  #  = "  ;#   " =#" 5' )3'%0')%%) ,        .4%D03! " 5);#!#5;,5"# = "#5##### 5#"# #! ,  5 ,5"  #    ""5!"","5#5'  "#.-"==55('&' -"==5 5 ('&' , 6!   ; ",    ;#5,5"##5! EF&)& /   "   E F- &/) ;# =="; ;# , "   ==5 = >#'  ## ,5 #5 ;!#-"==55('&'### " = #  # #'  #!   1 2    #5;=>#!-"==55('&' , ,# 5# = " - '       .4%D03  -"==5 5 ('&'   1- 2  , ,# 5# = "   " - " #,5#" #= "'#!12 5#,##!   " ###,5#"= "'E   ;#! "#."##%/'/)'/334   )/'/)'/334  ,#  5 >># " ' "  ;"##"#  " #,5#"'    " ##5,#"; G" # = " H'      " # , ;##!  5 5# "   ,    " # #  = # 1 2  # '  %/'/)'/334   )/'/)'/334  ##5!","%/'%)'/33*'"5# 55#   #5 ,"" )/'/)'/334    # ," 5#= "##"#55/'&'!# !    ,## ## , #"  5# = "'#"! "#.  ,%.'%0'/33* 6%.'%0'/33*,#  " #,= #12  5 # -"#>#'  ">>!  # >># ,#  #  " 5"#! #     ,#!  #5 5    5#!  ## = 6  # #..*/))'3% ;;'  '4$     $.         //' 5 1 2  56 " /3'%0')%%4 6 7#   /))-/).8  =#    ! ;    #"  ## 1 2  ' #6,!%3'%/')%%.#,#  E F )4*-)43' 6   ;#!  1 2     )%%/-)%%) ,5# #5 #= '

  0748 56!)*'%*')%%/;;612 ,5; ,5"!" ;5#""'   !     #  # ,##  !  )%%& #"612  #"#"5,!"# ="' ;#"@! #' #)%%&  "6  #"6   # # ,#!  # "#  5#"' +; 1 2   #"!    # @!     " ##)/'/)')%%/555'55 ###,!  " ##,= " "# ""# =#'    " #  !    !  5##  =  "" 6# ##'    " )%%/-)%%&###55#= #1-2 "# ! #  " ## I   6 )%%. #5 = ="'  ,#      )3'%0')%%)  '.4%D03 5')'

=##55-/'&;' 56!# ;#!12 = #5 =!  #        ,"# - "==55('&'1-2 5#6,,#= "5#'" "6!;#!  ".4%D03 #  5# = " "    " # 5  , "  = "'  # ,       '     # ,#!     " # # , 5# "   66  # )/'/)'/334 '";#!,#### ,5#"' 56!5# #,##!   " #,""= '$#= """; , = " , "'  "6 ;  5 ,5"!  6 =" 6 ,#'  /)'

 5  56 7#  ' /(*-/4)8 ; 56 #"    /3'%)')%%4  ""'  #!"#'#,####, " 5 5,  ,#"' 5%3'%/')%%.# !  6 !  ## "#  "# "5' ;  "#  5 =# ## "5 #5 =="'  56    ; !  5   #5 ,5# ; 6 )%%/ '    5 6 ""   , " #5 ,5#' "#  ,#6  5# 5//'%&')%%) #'  #      5  # " 5 ,5" ="! 5###5=="#""# ""' 5  "5=""!"5 %3'%/')%%.! #;" "6)%%&'+!# "# "5"#!5##,5 " "#   ; #"    E F //. ;#  ;  ;"", #"'

  ( (748 2"###"# ,#!5 >#5#",5#" #"= "'  '   $.    /&' #;5# # "##! 56 ;#"="'  /.'   ,#  ; ",  %/'%*'/33* #5    ;" ;"   #-  5   "# , # , ""&))(/!0.'  1 2   ,#     ; ", -  ##  #5#= ""/0300%'  /0'  ,6 "  5,#   5  F (0. '(  "5,#"'  /(' 56 ;#";6;"J 

,656 ;!12 %3'%/')%%. - 5##12 5#5==" #! 6,###5,5"',##! ##   %3'%/')%%. 1- 2  5 #5 ,5#!  #  ' " 6 1 2  /%'%)')%%.  7#  ' /()8!  1 2    # ##  /%'%)')%%.   #5 '&& ," ,5" ' "  6 1 2 !  ,56  %/'%&')%%. "# " 7#'  ' /()8' #5 ,5" 6 1 2   " %3'%)')%%.  7#'  /(&8' #5 ,55" 5;  %/'%&')%%. 5  #' 

,656 ;!"!12  ")*'%/')%%/ ## #5,5"!6;5'"# 6!12 ,#5;,5"!! = #5"5###7# '/%08'  "# " "#     "  ="  ""' ,6"!#5'&&>#= ==""%3'%)/%'%)')%%.#7# '/()-/(&8'   F (0) '.  ;6  ;5 6 ;#  !  #)%%& "6#"6 #'"## ,# " "   6   5 5,##  5,# "#"' 

6!";!"  " # # )/'/)')%%/ 55 5      " #  55 " #   # #   '   !  "#5  " # ;,""'

  4748   5"#   6 ;#  !     "   ##5#= "'  " # #5'%/'%*'/33*#5'&& ##55'/'& ;  = # #5 ,55; 6" , 5 ,5" ##  5# # #'  ,6  !  #5 5'/'& 6 ;# ## , = # # ###5##!"#5#5,""%/'%*'/33*'    # ,##!    5 %/'%*'/33* #5 ,"" # ## 6 " 5# " , ##  ## 5#"'  5##   )3'%0')%%)'.4%D03 5')'=# ' 

,656 ;!",##  , "==5 5'('&! "! ;# !  1 2  ;#"" !12 #,##! ###5%/'%*'/33*#5,""5#"!   "   ="' 6;5  5# ;#!     " # ## #  ## , 5# "' )/'/)'/334# G78>># H7# ')0-)(8"  #  #5 ,""    " # # , 2'9  5 # >>#   "; G ,# " # =  ,#  " #5H';#!"#>># 5 #2'9   " #%/'%*'/33*#5  ,""!#  " #5"#";>>#  ###,## 5###= "'  /4'     F &  #  %/'%/')%%( ,#  # " 5 "# "  # #";;"  # "#;'  F-#(%'///(/'/65#5"# ;56#";"5###'

5"#= "#'  /*' #"F-#(0.!(04'/5'/!(4%'/ (4/'   

  $"