Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-06-12249/52 AI generated

2-06-12249/52 · Viru Ringkonnakohus

Case Number 2-06-12249/52
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-06-12249/52 · Viru Ringkonnakohus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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text



   

     

                        !"#!$#%!!&'( 

    %)!$)*%%+" 

                          !"#$"%$& '( 

( (  (

,*-#*%#%!!.,          

 '   / ,0 )   

 1 2, %*#!3#%!!& )     (  (   (  ( / ,   '      45 66666666666 ,66666666666766 7 666666666666 77777  2  08 / 5155520  99

,,1  4,5"!!!-%*. , .  5) 285  51   : *+ ,- 

)  ./ "/"00$

  /"0# ""&!1   /

       2      1   (   /

      

2        (1    (  ( /      2       ( 1      ( / +(      (   2   '    (        *

  .021       1         %  (    21 

  33(      

 

 %       /   

    ( 4" 5/.               *

       (%   (       %

(          6   ( (  ( 

 ( /   

    ( 4#$ /7         1 ( %               /         %     '     (            /    (       1   1          ,  *&#!3#%!!$    ,    5  ,1 ' ,*"%$.%.+(5#, 5/ 11;,,,1 5#  5   ,     ,1  1  ,<<,   ,  !*#!&#*"".# *3##*""" 1,1  /,0:/ 21;55,52 45/5,, 528,1(//2,2,,2, 1 ,/5  (//13,,4*.##*"""=*.##%!!+8 ,22 %!!!:,#*.##*"""1,511,1 !*#!&#*"".,<< /   2   1  (,,  5  ,  2,  ,1   ,  ,,,  *%3!  5  ,1  , 5 52/  , (//5,1   ,,<<5,;/  ,3,1 ,1,,<<,21 1  55      ;2 ,  3  ,, ,<<,  1;,2,   52    >,2  1   (  ,2   ,2  ,5  1   5? (//2  ,,,25 ,,5 5# 1,;,(,<< / ,,;,5,5?2,1 , 5 22*&*..%.+5,1 >  ,,,22*!.%-$  , (//55,1 ,<<, ,55  ,;/   ,#,1,;,2,<< /,, 5,5  ,?,<<,1 1  3  ,  2     *  ,  1  &  # ,1  ,   5  ,<< / (/,22  -!#!-#%!!$#<< /,1 (/,,<< /5 @."      %"#!+#%!!$# ,1   5  2/2,  1  ,,5   ,  , # ,1/ ,,,2511522%&"!!&.+ 4##,,*!.%-$1(//2*&*..%.+8#1 ,5  , ,5>20,<<,2* 25,5+&*$&! 4%&"!!&.+?$!58#,1 ,<<,511/  ,,* ,  1  &  5  2,,,;  , ,,  1   ,5  22  "$--$   4+&*$&!7%!58# ,1( 1 *"%$.%.+2 1/ ,1 ,; 1 2(,# 

,*$#*!#%!!$2;;(, 52, #  ,1' 2!$##%!!$1 , 5 / 1;,,  52,1(2,  515#

 -

,   ,  ( 25  1  1  ,1  !*#!&#*"".  ,<< /  #*$A". 2   ,    ,1  ,<<   1  1  ,),  2;;,5  ,;,1   -*#!.#*""&#52,,<< /2;;2,1( 2,5,<< /# ,12;,1 ,1  ,,,,25#2,/50/ ,  /     , ,  ,<< /    2;,5  3),,  ,<<,2  ,, ,,2(/, (/,2,,,1,,<<,2(/, 25,5  ,<< 3,,# ,51 ,,<< /11,1  ( 2,5!*#!&#*"".,1,<<,51123 ,,#,1,<<,(/,1 111,<<,2,/ #,1 ,;,5,<< / ,, ,1,<<,511;2 ,3 ,,# ,11,,; /1  ,,<< / /#";,,,5,;  ,2,,<<,1 02(,  ,1,12,22,(,, ,,2, ,<< /5@*3,,#   )  

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

, ,*.##*""" // ,1,1 22,,,22 *%3!2,,5221,> ,(5 # 5,1,(5 / 5 //5,(//,,,*%3!1(5 2 1 ,1 ,,2,22,*%3!# ,1 0,22, 2/ !-#!"#%!!.,, 1    ,2  (/,2,  1  (/52,//  2,  5  *%#*!#%!!. ,2;;  , 1  ,2  1   5  1  ,,   ,,1 ## >  2# (5     2, ( 2  ,,1 ## >  2,,,2  ##/ ,,5>, ,5 15 ,5#

 $ 1  ,    1;,,  ,2,  ,,1  ## ,,   ,5  >, 5  2, (22#/0,(,(55 >>2 2(5,(5,,/0,5,/(152# ,,2 2;0,2,<<,2,1112 %!!! =%!!*,1,(55;5/ 1(  ;0, 25 1,5,(5,=,<< /25,,,1##>, ,,15    ,5  >, , /   22  ,1 #   1;,,  ; 1  (52,   52,,1,, 52,5; 1(52#         12%!#!%#%!!&1 ,5 0/ ,0 ,/ 0 1;,, 52,1, 5,15#   *   2' ( ( 

,,5; , 12,1 5 5,2,,   5   1  /(15,5    / ,0  ;,5       ,    ,>,2#  ;  , 1  1 ,5,1,*"%$.%.+1 , 5(5#  ,*-#*%#%!!., 5,,;  ,#,1/ , 5 ,5,,# 

 0,2,1; 55 ,, 0,  52    (   5,  1  1   ,  ,(5,#  (,02,,/(15,1, , ,2, 5, @$3+ #$/1 5/(152,,# 

,/ ,0;5, 2;01;2,#  / ,0;, ,52,(552  5 ,,1 5,, ,,5,(5,,;,,,1/5,<<,211 ;2 ,3,,/;, 52 (/,2,  ,2, 1,/5#

 / ,0;,(,1 0,2 ,(55  5  >  , ,;  ,  1  01, ,#   0 , 2,1; 5!*#!&#*"".,<< /#*$A".  ///#.4 5#,# #*-)*+8     (  1 /(15,5# , ,   2,,5  /#.     ,<<,1  4,18 ,;,<<,      ,<< (,2   /,,5  ,<< /  ,2,      (  25,5 ,<<,1,,<<,2,<< ;2 ,3,,12,, ,<<,2  ,,  ,<<51,  1# , ,  52  1  1     *3##*""" ( 2,5,,,2 / 4 5#,# #*.)%!8,1 52 ,     5,      ,2,   1  ,/5  1  , ,  52 !%#!"#%!!+,, 4 5#,# #%*)%%8 ;0,1,;   5,   ,2, 1,/5# ,5  25,1>  2,,5/#.

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

 & / ,0  ;, ,      ,5  ,,1  ##  >,  2   2, (252(,#  0,  2  ,,2,  0,;/; 15D,,,1## !-#!"#%!!.,, ,5>, E52,55 ,,1>, , #,1>, 5,,  5; >554 5#,# #*.%81 ,(555,1,<<,2, ,,<<,2,,12; ,5# 1 > ,,1,, ,  54 5#,# #*%-)*%+8  55  ,2,  5 5 ,1,%!!%(//2,0 1 5 ,  #  / ,0  ;, ,  2    ,( 55  ;; ,  ,(55   5    2, )    2, (  2     (,#

 0,2,,5 1/(15,5 1   2;; 2;,5,,,,51 515,,,51; 55,(552   1,5,1; 552,5525 5#, ,2  >>5(1,,5,(55#  F  ,5      , 0  2,  ,  1;,,  2,2,  1  / ,0  52,#    / ,0   52,  1;,2  1  , ,   ,2,  5,@*$% #*@*.-1@*.+1;;5,1/ ,,22,  5,2 551/ ,,22,  5,15# 

 15 , ,2   ,5, 1  ,2,   5, @$3*@$3%@$3+@$3. #*/#*@$$&1@$.!#