Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-05-21915/8 AI generated

2-05-21915/8 · Viru Ringkonnakohus

Case Number 2-05-21915/8
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-05-21915/8 · Viru Ringkonnakohus:   ) )639 "    !   0$14%)'&*')&&.# #= %'#4%.'&)')&&.,4#224,4">*(4'( *,4?' )' @# 22 #" )3'&(')&&.  22 '/'&%-&)A%%*&-&.'  #422# #+ )&&<#"50$1 4 #22 ?"!#!522,#' )&'%)')&&< ,"#    224 6#  #9' 224 ,"" ?  4?  4#  22?  " 22  #  , 8B"')&'%)')&&< 4224 ,""    !   " #  8 B 1 6#  #9!"5" , ,4" # 22, #" '#, 42244">.<%",!"5 22'   " #     224 6#  #9  #&;'&)')&&.##""45 22' 22?"# !" ? "  $ + %<! !    &%'&)')&&.- )('&)')&&.' "  !   5 22? ,#   4 22## " 5- ?,#"4?'  >%/, # "# ,# "'  4   4 ? ,!   ,# 5"22?'" ")&'&%')&&. # ",# #46# #9'?#4? 22"" ' "5! # !  '+     @# 22"! "5 ?# # "!  "# 22 4#    # # # 22@##'$5222222## "?4?@ '0225'$- 22 "#""@#22' '1%&'&)')&&. 6#  #9'   '      ,4 4'  ,#  4   "  #  " 22?" !"#"#' "??%<'&)')&&.?%6# #9#4 C>;<224,4">*(4(*?'%.'&)')&&.  ''  'D'  ? #4 "??"! " # "#  ,"'  C>)%%22#,224 ,4##4>%%!3;-3.!/%-/(%&;-%&(?#?# 4,4""#'C>)4%#4@@# ><*.&"#@@?"?" ,",?"!" 225 5"!"22#,#"??"C>;4<"?# '  >%&(22#224,4"22@@#, #"@ ""',4224>*(4( *%.'&)')&&.'   )('&<')&&.  #   " 224 22 #"224,4">*)%&;'&<')&&.4  @  ,#" "" %&3 /3%'%% '     

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

               

       

     !"# $"         %&'&(')&&*+,   

   )-&.-)%/%.  

  0$1 #+  22 #   

&3'&)')&&3 )-&.-)%/%.       

 #+ 45   

    ")*'&.')&&*+,           4 # +  6# 77777777777!  77777 8-88! 77777777!   777777777788-88!77777779 4#4# #": 

0$16 %%&;33()!$ <%-%39

## 

4#     ! "    #        $%&$'&'$$% 

&'($)('*+*)

 &   ! "    #  

      &       #  ,             -$ #!        ! 

    .     #! 

  //            &   0 1%*  &)         ! .          &      .    ,       

  & 

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

  ; ;639 ,! 224,4#>*(4( *%.'&)')&&.'     22 #     " 224 22 #" 4 "??# )3'&(')&&.  %)'&&'     22 #"  ""  ?#!   "  22 #")3'&(')&&.%)'&&"%.'&&!"22 #"  5  #'   ,# 22 #" " , ' )3'&(')&&."22422 #"22 # /'&%-&)A%%*&-&.6# #9!" #     ,"# 224 ,44 &;'&<')&&.  ",    " 4#! ,44 !  " 4 ,44  4#"  5""%.*((/'(&'

   )< >  % , # 22 #"  " ," # # 4# 422## " 22 # ?5 "  @  !   22 #"  ? " 4?  ?  4? '   22 #"  %)'&3')&&.! "  ,#  @"5   %%'&3')&&. 4"4' %.'&/')&&. #!"",##' #4= %' #  4   " 224 22 #" #  # ,## 224 ,4" &<'&<')&&.  4 ,#"  ""%&3/3%!%%' ;' #  4  )&'%)')&&< ,"# 224 ,4 %.'&)')&&. >*(4(*6').-)(9'   '+ 4%&'%&')&&.# 6;*-;/9?0$1" ,#"!#?#' # )&'#"5)&&<0$1!"  ! ,"#224!" ,#22 '22#4224""# " , " 422#"   " 224 22 #"4   #'

##?5 #!#22 #"4,### 0$1 ,"#224,44&;'&<')&&.>*) ", ? 0 $1   " 4#! ,44   " 4  4#"5""%.*((/!(&'

   >- )<  % , # # # 4# 22 #"  ","422##"22 #?5 ""- ,@ ! 22 #"?"4? ? 4? ' "??5#"?@'0$122 #" ?%)')&&.'  > 3  %  5 ,# " ? ?" 4?  4?  4?  5" , @#" ""! " 22 , 22#  , 4# " # " , "'  ?4?  5 # 4? ! "   ? 22 #" '  > 3  )  ,4 # ! # , ?#   # ?# 22 " !  , ?#   4? '    4?   ! # , ?#    ? 4 @#" ""4? !"?'?"  4? %)' )&&.'!#'

  < <639

 >-<)%4"",,45?,44"'  > ).  % ? ,5 22 #"  4?  422#" ? "22#"!"54# #"- ,"4  )',,#22 #"4?"'  

  " &3'&)')&&3  6    %.'&)')&&396 %;.-%;*9 #' %'  )&'%)')&&< 0 $1  '+   ,"# 224 ,4 %<'&)')&&.>*(4(*' )' , 0-  $1 '+   ? 5 22 "" )/)*!*& E ,44 4#"@"45""))<(<' ;' , '+  ? 0 $1   )* (%*!).   # "" %(/&!/&' '+   )('&<')&&.  #   " 224 22 #"224,4">*)%&<'&<')&&.!4  ")&'%)')&&<&;'&<')&&.  ""%&3/3%!%%  ,#   > *)  ) ?# @  ,#" "" .) ;%;!&< @ ,#"4"".3<<!*;' '+  !22)&'%)')&&<'  )3'&(')&&."22422 #"22 # /'&%-&)A%%*&-&.!"#  ,"# 224 ,44 &;'&<')&&.  ",    " 4#! ,44 !  " 4 ,44  4#"  5"" %.* ((/!(& ! "  " ?"" 5  4 5 "" ;< *%/!)&'$  ,?#"'  0$1%)'&*')&&. # #+  ' #!#?'    )&'%)')&&< ,"#    224 "??# ! 224 "4? )&'%)')&&.'22)&'%)')&&<'2244('% 4""%%<&!<&4'(';"54""# 43'%4 )*4? '2244'%% '+  5# 22  %.'&)')&&.!  > *( 4 (  4' *' %<'&)')&&. ?  % #4 "??" ,4 ##  > %&; 224  # + %<'&)')&&.*(4(4*22422" ,' %.'&)')&&.'' #  # ''  'D'!  #  # #+ ?%  ,""' '+  ##224,4">*(4'4'(*' C > );  %  ,5 22!   "??# #4! 422## @! 4? !"?4? !"# ,4# #""??"' '+ 422## #' !)&'%)')&&<224,4#%<'&)')&&.*(4(4 *  224 22 " ,' 0 $1   # @  ""' '+   # 22# " 22" 224 ,""  224,4"!22# ,5  ##'

  . .639 '+  ##22# ?#!)&'%)')&&<0$1 '+   2244#44224#",4?"' '+  !?#22@##)&'%)')&&<&.'&)')&&.'22?#! # ! "22# 22#45'" 22#"' 22# ?#5! '+ 22 #"5,##"#' #!224)&'%)')&&<4#'"#22 > ((  % ",   22#  # # $ > )&  )  ""  ?" 224 4# 4"?? ' "  224 4"'  #!   )&'%)')&&< 224 4  )&'%)')&&<  &%'&)')&&. 4 44 4 ?"' 0 $1  '   ,"# 224! " '+ 45" '22"&)'&)')&&.  &)'&.')&&.' )&'&%')&&.  ,"# # 4  4# )('&%')&&.F)('&;')&&.'  #&%'&)')&&.)('&;')&&.' '+ 4 " 22 &)! &;  &<' 5 )&&.' '+  22 "  "  &.'&)')&&.&/'&)')&&.!"#4! '+ 422##"

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

  ( (639 "#     #,         4 '+  " )*'&;')&&* # 5 6 %.)-%.;9 45   &3'&)')&&3 '+  ?",#""#@#!  ##22 #"' 4    ,!   ", " ? " ? "# 4"")*(%*!).#""%(/&!/&' '+ 4,#5 "  ?# !  4  ?"# 224 #!    # # "' '+  4 ?    ?  ##  ##"##"#"# ?"22 #""#! #!" 5!"##"##### "' '+  22" ## "22 ,"!"224,4" 4# #' '+ ?22"@#!",,# 224 ,4" 4?  0- $1 #" ,#'  224 ,4"!4 ?","@"22 #"" ",4224' "#4#5"#"!"  '+  5  " 22 5"!    22,#"5?422#"##' 

0$1 45#     #,   

!  #   "# #!  45 ?#  "@"!#"5"4,#'   22 #"-0$1,4224 '+ >*(4'(* #'    "#  ,4 0 $1 '+  )&'%)')&&< ,"# 224 %.'&)')&&.  > *( 4'(  *  %<'&)')&&. ? '  "??# #4'  22 #4  # 6C9 > ; 4'<   #4 224,4">*(4-#(-*'  C>)%22#,,4#224#4> *(4-#(-*?#!?#>-#%%!3;-3.!/%-/(%&;-%&(?# 4,4""#C-?#""#'  224 ,4" 4,  "   @@!  ,5 22# 4 ,4#! #"">*(4-#(-*?#'  0 $1 %<'&)')&&. ?   ? "?? '+  #4 224 ,4"!  '+ !  "## " "4 22#

' # 5! ? # ""4 22!  ?#  #22#!#22#"!522 5 22   5! ?# @ !   #"?#  6' %;9' 

  3639 C > ); '%  22!   "??# #4! ,5 422## @! 4? !"?4? !"# ,4# #""??"'    "#   '+   "??# #4 # %.'&)')&&. 6' %;9! #  ## # ?# ?  #4"??"' 

 ,5 " 4,# 0 $1  #"   >(.<'(4"4,#"' 

45 ?#"?5?"= 

5!45 ?#22#4?"#224 # "  4,'  # %<'&)')&&. ? '  6' %;9 ?5! '+  "#?!# "#'' 'D'?  ,""'  ! '+ 22"4# ###"22 ,"224 ,4"!"# #?!4# #22! 22,4"4? @'    ## 22# %<'&)')&&. ? ' ! " '+  #4224,4'?4,#@ '+  4 #4 " 22   4"  22 5 5"' #    5 ?#!  ,#"  '+  4 22 4"!4,#"#'   45 #" ?"! 5 4# 4" # ? " # #'    # 4" # @ ",' 

#">-#(.<!(.3'%4'%!(3&'%(3%'         $"