Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-03-178/23 AI generated

2-03-178/23 · Viru Ringkonnakohus

Case Number 2-03-178/23
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-03-178/23 · Viru Ringkonnakohus: 3637-!"- ,"!&  1&   )*&$)&)''%  6  " &  )''.)'(7 > ! , !"  !,:  !$0&'(&)''%"!  !!  :4-!&  ""  !" "" "," !"3 "&<5/1 4> ","3," !"3 "& - "" "!!"-" ","": ! >>!"!&!:!: 3'%&'$&)''%  $''''',">!6- 4!76 "& $$'7&  $'&)1&$'&)''06 "& )55.)('7:- "!&    3,"    " $/&'$&$115 3  -  , !" > !"  3 " 3  9" 3  ""  >" " & "   3   "  3 :!  ""  " "  ,  -!& 3  " 3 9" 3  4""  :"! -!" "=- , !"&   !   - "" >   ! ,"  -,4.  - !!!3-, =  3?? ,"3 !  $1*1 !!: 888 888 " "  "  !  & ,".!>>-!, !">" 3

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

              

     

       !"  ! 

"! # 



          $%&'(&)''*+,-      ).'/.$0*               

 ! "   #     $% &%'  #  #          ('' '''  #  ) # #  #

)1&$'&)''0           2 -3 4       $(&'5&)''*   #  #  #  # 3  67 2  - 6" $$'$)5)'7 3 "!  !&

 67  "   6" 888888888887& * +,!

- .  # )    /01('1/''&            #  #     #  1  .  #             #   1      # #   1    1    

    #          1 #   #     #  # 1 #      #        #      *   $' 

             #       22#     

     1

3   *       

   4/(5 1$    #   

#      # .

# #  # #1       #   # #    

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

 "!??!," -! :: &!:"!:--->"!>!: 4"?? !!&  (& ! -6 "& (5.((7-"3 : -  "!& ,! ::4 !  4   -   ! ! &  " " 3 "!  - 3"4&   " " 33 &     " 3  -" ,""   -   4 -" !& "! ! 4 --, " -& -,"-!  ! ,- -,"  ,-!-4! &  %& ".   $1&$)&)''( !:: 6&  01.*$7    ! ! ,"3  ,-)*''!-3  ,-%'''& 

0&   '%&')&)''% !:: 6  " &  $$5.$$(7 >   43, !$1&$)&)''(!::  ,-!,"&  *& $0&'(&)''%:- "!&   "$/&'$&$115 3 " 39" 3 ", "" " ! , ! 33  -  - !  ,  :& !"">"&" 3 "3:!&  -

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

" 39" 3&" ! !!!3=   !- ","3 !&,  "" " -""-! ",&" " "  !   "  3 -  ! &  3  3,4   ,! ! 3,"! "! ! -  , 3 4 6& , !!7>&"  ->"&> 33:!> 3     3    !" ,"& !" 3 > 6!  "4 "   33  3:!!7 ,"" ! > : -- ! & , 4>   " 3 "  6!  - "  3  ""  "   7&  " 3 -??"    :"" "!"   - >& 9 -??" "" >   

 3", !=- ,- !!!3-,  =  - " !!!3-, =   ,"3 !&  ">     -,! -: !,  ," 3  ! !"!   4 ,:    "" .!>>  -" :" !     ! !!3 -,  =    " !" -" ,"& !!!3-, =  . !>> 3 !,"3 ! 3   "!" 00'''& : !"!"-!!,,!& " :"   "      " :  "! ,""  

 -,!!> ",3&

  >   ! ,"  3: ! "

! !!3 -,  =      .   3   ! !" - ,"!-&    " $115&  "  =-   $/&'$&$115 3 " 39" 3:! "!  "! --",""&            , "   ! !!3 -,  =   ,:  - 3  !"    - "" :"& 

 "!:!!3,"-! 3,""&         # ##  #   #  $$&   3 4 3 4 6  " &  (.*7 >" !  ! ,!"!,! : "!  -    --   ! !    :4-!   "" "!& - "!:! 4:!!&  3 4  !" 3,""&  4>" "," 6<5/%7 > ","3,"!" "6<5/17&  ! > ","3","!"  "&    !    -  3  - -, - /(0(' ,"&-$'''''! >-!,"&   : !   "!    . 9".  " 3  ! ,"      - ""  " -! " ,& ! "!,-  "! 3  ","  -" 3" >"&" 3 " 3:!& 

   !  ! , !  -::      -"=  "",""&  :4!,",","" "-:" --:"!: " ,,3,"!    "!    ,"    "  3 " 3  9" 3  ,  "" " ! , ! - !  !" 3  -" ,  :& ,  ! 3   "" " ":",".!>> 3 &   -  -  .!>> 3   !      "  !!& " !  4 &  4!- $115&!" 3, !! ,3:@    ,  "   3    "" -"  &  !   3  -3:   3 ! , ! 3" 3& 9: !  ! &  !   , , !" " 3 !      4  !  !"  &  "-" 3    3 -    3 , !"  ! 9" 3      , !  3    ""  !"" " 3& 

 )*&$)&)''% :!$0&'(&)''%" !   >>!  "!   "  3  )5&'$&$110 63& $1157   -: ! - 6  " &  %57 !    -: !!   3  !!00'''&  A!: "-"  "! 4 ""<)0) &)!  :  3  , !  -, " > "! !!"& )5&'$&$115 !- !   "  3    -: !  ,"4  ! 3  &!" "-" &     4   3 4  :  "! 3,   3 -, ! :!, , !!& "-:4  3, !! "=-&" 4  4  3, ! 3""  -"&  :"! 3 ","""!" - "   &  $)&! -6 "& /(./%7 4,!4 !" 4!" 3"::!&  !=--: !-" 3-,"" -" "@ 3    3   !!    - !>>  "!"&  "  3" ,33!'$&'$&$111&9 ,: "   &  !67 - 3 -, $11%&   :  :  !>>

!&  !>>"3 " : "!" 3"-"&,3">>&      3  "    !&       " 3  ">!"-B"&  *   ##  $/& -   <%($ &$  4  ! !   " 3,">! 3  "-"&  9 " 3 -" "!)1&$'&)''0! :  "!-$''''',"! !&     3   -" " ! )1&$'&)''0      !   :  "!&   4 -" " !  " 3,"!"&

 43 4  3,""!)1&$'&)''0  4>"<%(0 &$3&)  ,!!, "! :! "& 4>"!!  :4-!!! :4 "!&  <5 &):! !::-"3 "-" !! : -" 4!&!"<( &$ !  3 " "    :","&  <5/% &$34 !" 3,""&  <55) &*   !:  3,"-  -"  "  "": "",""!  ": ""!""!"  "&343,"!!,-,=  -:"34 >>!,,""& 

- <5/1-,> ","3,"!"  "& 

,43 4-:" !  "!:! " 3,""!> " ,"3&  9 - -" $/&'$&$115, !" 3 -3,-, -> &   "- "6 "& )7 , !" ,  ! !!3$/&'$&$115 3!  -,! " 00''' !:'$&'$&$111&3  3" -," , :"!3,-, - /'&'$&$110/(0('& ! -  >!  -, !! -     "  ,4     - " !:" 3,-, -  /'&'$&$110!!/00('! - "> ::"!!5$ )('-,  4","!!5$)('   "

6 "& $007& 

3"4   - "!:"  3 -"'$&'$&$1103,-, -!!/00('     :    : :!&  : !  - " " "      "!&  ,"" 3  -  $/&'$&$115 , !"  3 " 3 C-, 9" 3!! " !,! ""  : "" "  C>      - :"      "! :!  3,"   C>          -,!     -:  !,    ,  - "    !:"  "   3  " ," & "!">  -"":"& 

- '$&'0&)'')"<)0) &$   3:4>3 

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

" 3  "  !!!3-, =   !:  , !" 3&'$&'$&$111& '$&'0&)'')"<$0/ &$:" 4:, -  " !::":-- "-, 3:  :3"!  -  - , &   - "    - "  ," "  3 3&$&) :    " !! 63,-, -7 00'''  ! > !

 !  '$&'$&$111&  3  3"-" ! -" !! ! !=  -,  !   3 &     ! - "  !  : 3," !    "   !! 3,-, -  /'&'$&$110 /(0('    3 3&$&)    3"  !! 00'''  !: '$&'$&$111$$" !&   "  -  4       ,""      $/&'$&$115  3  - -, -  /'&'$&$110 3,-, -  !! /(0('        :"  /'&'$&$110 :! !  3  -"  3,-, - !! &     /00(' -, --: !,! 4: "!& 

  --:"   ,"  , -   ! !!3 3  " 3 :! :! 6  ," : ! :!    !!>>!  !"   7 !:4     ::4  "! ,       3  /'&'$&$110 "      , !  3     "  " 3  - ," -! !, 3"4 -"  "-"--:"3,","&      !  -:"  " 3 ,33!    !",     " ," 3  ! ! :!     ," !!>>!  ! !!3 63 ??  !7 3 !>>""!"!  -- "!3 " ,"""-:">!4 >!"& 3 4 -"-"3,"-:""&   3 4      :    "! :! :4   "6 ,-3 4! !!)E ))('F5(''7!""-- '$&'$&)''%"<%' &$* $$&    "!"& 

 "  !   "   <<%($.%(5 <%(0 &$ 3&) <%%* &$<%0' &$&        ! "! #