Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-06-36831/10 AI generated

2-06-36831/10 · Viru Ringkonnakohus

Case Number 2-06-36831/10
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-06-36831/10 · Viru Ringkonnakohus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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

               

     

     !" ! #$   

            %&'&(')&&*+,$ 

    )-&.-%.*%/ 

   0 123 4 5  " $ $ .67) //,"     

).'/&')&&5          

 2458!!9        &*'&(')&&*              8!!:; 2 4 5 1" *&/57)))   4 6-55 $ ! "-  "3  "! " "! $  !8! ""! "$<

:;

!>>>>>>>>>=-== $! "- "3 !8!"?9$@    !" #$    % &              '()*+)'++%         "      ,   -       "& )      !!"AA$"245"'         8! $,9 " 9

! %& 8A$ !  ! A !  "  8A $  BB"   $!! $' $!!"13C)/*!%! $,9 !! !  

 ) !"  " $!"  ! 0 $""$"$"!'

$!  C .5/ ! 7 !9 9 A"    $9   !'

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

8!!""$$!$!"0!""123C /(.!/A!A9$$,!"' ! !" " 4 5-== $ " !  ' /665'- $" - $ !$!" !"!8   $ $!8 ,! 0'  8!" , - $ !$!" 8! 8"!8 $"   8! !88' A9AA" "  /666' !,8' /6'&/')&&&  )/'&/')&&& ,!"    $ !$!" !8"' /665-)&&&' "! !!!,'$ "    ,"  "  !$  $ 8!' /.'&5'/665 8!"0!$$" 8! -$!$!" 8!"$,," "$!" ,"!!8,! - $ !$!" !' ! )&&&'-  $ !$!" !  8  "' ! )&&&'  ' !"-   $ $!8 !! ,$""' !!,.67) // !" ,$C-!)%&!/'  ('1'!5%3$$A","' 

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

 ( ,!"9!""!" $!"' ,$A 8!$""C/7/A!"  $,!   $,! ," $ !'  C /7/ ! !  "  !"!"  !"  " 9!' "9$!,!"!8!"!"" " 8! "  !$'    " !"!"!9" !9!"!2C/(6 !!!," A/&'      "  -    /%'$"!9!$1'!/6-/)&38!!9!$8!9 A' 

!!"!-!,'!9  !",'        /('  "" A" 9  " A8" 9 , E 8!" 0"        !' !!" 8!"  ""A"'  /7'"A$" 8!!!"A"'     &,    /.'   !"A!!$"$!!"  !" 8!!9!9A!"'  /5' 9 !   9, !"" "   ""

 !"'  !9  $"  C (%* !'/ A!     A"8,!!",""9,"A!""'  """!!",""!!!  !!89$!" !!"8 $9 !!" !"  !9  A !"    8 A!  ""$A"' !! $,9 ," 9   " !" $A!! 8,!8 "!0  !,88A!",",'  /*'$A!","9,!9   A"A!8!   !! " $9 ","'$"!"9," 8! $,"!$!C/7-/'!"!A"89$ !A2C/(6A"A'   !   "" A !8 ,! $,!! "$$"$)/'&/')&&&!8!'!!!8

 !!"! -!"!$! $!"8A$!,!"$$!8!1'!'7(-773'    !""   ! - $ !$!" 8! !$" ,  ,$ !! )&&)'   , ! " 2 C /(. !'/ !$!9!$!'

!9 ,"1!"!"$,$9" $,!38,"$A!"$$9 8!"$  "  8" $9!8 !!  ,"   8,9 ," !$!8!!!"$,!$!' $!"  !!! !" ," !   , " ! !" $,!$A/665-"9)&&) !!!.67) //!$" )7'&5')&&. $$ !8 - $ !$!" 8! !'  $ !$!"!")&&)'-1'!'))-%&3'  /6'    $A" "  C /7-/ A!' " A ! !"!"!"0!"0!"0!$, !" !'  A , )5'&%'/666  !!  !! A ,  ""'  C /7-/ ,   ! ! " !" !" !" !!!"!"0 $!C/7' 8"C/7!'/!!"0!!" !"  " 9  !!! " ! " !" "!"!"$$!,!"8!$!!!88!' )5'&%'/666 ," "" -  !! "  C /7 !'/  , !"!"   " !  8$ C /7-/  !! ! !"!"' !"C/7-/!'/A8"!!"0!"0! $, !" ! !" !" !" " 9  !!! !  ! "  !"!"  $$! ,!" 8!$!! !! !88!' " ! !88 ,! 8" !"!""!!!!!" $,$$!!!,!"!88!' C/7-/!'/!$&/'&5')&&/ !!,C/7!'/" !! ! 8"  %/'/)')&&) !" ! !"  !   !" ""00!"!"! " 9  !!! " !" "  "!" ""A'  )&'!"!A"! 8,""! C/7-/!!$A!"!"A2C/(6 A'  &/'&5')&&/ $"  C /7  /7-/ "" A" " !  !" " 9! !" ! !"   !"!! "!"!"A"!"!8' "!88"$"' !"!!/6'&/')&&& -$!$!"$!,!" !!!"!81'!'7.-763 !$!!&/'&5')&&/$C/7!'/ "$,"%/'/)')&&)' 

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



)('  C /5% !'/ ! 9  !"  !!"  !! $!  $, ! !,8$ AA'  A !$!""!!"' A$$!!"C/.)!'/!!"'  C/5%!'),"9"!"$,9!" !A9$ "9$"!$$!!!"'   8!!9 AA9 !"      8"9 $" !!"!!"AA$""!"'  )7' "!!"C-"(() .%/ .7/ .7(  .75!/8/ ..* .5&!/'           !#$