Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-05-351/14 AI generated

2-05-351/14 · Viru Ringkonnakohus

Case Number 2-05-351/14
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

    

Legislator headnote

AI generated
2-05-351/14 · Viru Ringkonnakohus:     

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

    

     

                      !"#$%#!$$"&'  

    !($)(*)+ 

                         !"#! $%$&'( )*  + * *  *

,++#$)#!$$-,          

 ./,0 1 2,3        $4#$%#!$$" ,     *  *   *  * 2,./,0 15677777777777 ,888888877(77796: (0  1

,,:;,)5,6"$$$4)9 66: , .  - ./-! 0 + , &&121322(

  132 $&    *   4                     4

   1     !"#!  5       * *     1 *      *   5   )    *       

  $254       4         '  *    54 

  66*      

        1 +  

    * 73&%1$              

       *'   *       '

*             * *  * 

 * 1

 ! +  

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

, , 6$-#$?#!$$?,: '//4*4)!$#/, 2:,:, A:/',' //-$$# 

,+!#$%#!$$-,6:',:2,:, A: /', '//+*---%-:'36//*-!*)$#   ,  

,++#$)#!$$-,6,,A,,:,/',,:  A: ' ,,+!---%-,,6' ,,+$$$ ::A3 ,/*%--)*#/,/',,,:,,6 26,//)$$$# ,,  ,  , ,   ,  ,:  3  ,  !$#$*#!$$+  , 88888888887(7 ,(&A #,,(&A  , 6  ,,,6  ,  !+#$)#!$$+  /,,/# ,:    , ,6  6  2AA    ,,    ,,6  ,#   , ,/66>+#+#!>!#+#!,=,6>)#+>+*#% ;,)2':2#*#!#?:2#*#!#-:6,,:3/

 * /,,/,  ,   ;    :  ,,6  '6,  ,,  ,/ ,/;(/:6/6,#

'    ,,  A,3 ,  26  $+#$%#!$$% @ *+#+!#!$$%  ,    ,: ' //,,,*"*+-)632,/3 !$$+  /AA,6  ,   +$$$  #  '    ,,  A,3 ,  26 $+#$%#!$$%@$-#$?#!$$?, ' 4*4)!$# ' 26 $+#$%#!$$%@+$#$%#!$$-,+!---%-#/CC,;/ 23/,,6' 66, ,,6///,/,6: //  ' 6  ,3  6   ,    '  ,/  /6 66/=6:=,,,,CC#,/' /,23/:,//:6 :6,/ , , ,=,6>+): :/:/6,/ , ,;2': 2#-#,:,6 , A,6 63,,, ,: /,26/'23,2CC6/:,2/:6,, /,/2A/=6/,2CC6/ :/: 2  /,26/  ,/  '  6,  /AA/#   6 , /,  ,      ,:  ,6    ,  =,  ,,  A6, /,26//,#/,,:,6 A:66 '  //, /6  ,  ,,3# ,:    ,6   6  3,,6  , /,26/',#

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

 % ,6,3,',/,#=/,: =,26,/2CC66# 6,,: A,6 ,, 6/',, ' ,:, A:,A,#   /',  ,:,  A:  '   +$$$   '3  ?*""-  5)D ,  +!---%-  9 :  6  6:  ,CC,  26/  ,',, /,:AA62'66:,://+?)!,/)%)+?   :  /6  :  A3 ,/6  //  ?%+)$  #     , 26  ,  6,,  )$$$   /',      //  ,:, ,6 A:#   95     )  5) * *  ,:/+)#$?#!$$-2,3,,# 2,3  ,  ,,  ,:    ,  2A/# ,: 6,/,26/6/666,,6,,:A:2==,6   ,, /,,    ,26#     6 ,  2  :6,  /AA, ,A6 ,2,# /A,,2,666,66,::A 6#2,,/6,:A,, /,,6 ,:'2,/66,:6,, /: =/,,/#   +      :/*+#+$#!$$-: ,2,36,,#

,,,: A6,,/,26:,,36 ,,6,,:A/,,6#  

    

,,:A6/,6,,62,3: , A6,:6#,:,,2,/,:6,A,,2 /, /,,,#,:2/,,,=,6,,::A,, 6/,#:6:6,6/,3:/26, ,: ',6#  

  5) * * 

 ,, 6  A   , :  /,:6  :  A  6 /,6 6 ,  2,3    ,  2':6,6 /, ++#$)#!$$-,6:,3 ,/,6,>?)?#+2#) :#!,=,6/,/6/,',,:,/ ,/,A3 ,/# 

 ) A   , :  /,:6,  A,3 ,  :  ,  $-#$!#!$$)  6(  ,   6  ,:  ,  '   //  *"*+-)     ,6'6#!%#+$#!$$)*$#$?#!$$?:+!#$%#!$$-6: '  //,:'2,2:,:, A:/', ' //+*---%- '36//*-!*)$# 

,++#$)#!$$-,6,,A,,:,/',,:  A: ' ,,+!---%-,,6' ,,+$$$ ::A3 ,/6,,*%--)*# 

, , ,/,6,>%*?#+23,,/6 :2':6,6# , ,/6,>%%!#"/A,,2':6  ,, ,,6:6:6,,,6:A66,'66/:,6, :A66/,66/66#23,2':6// ,',: ',:B,, A6,#23,','66 ==/#/'6,'6, ,23,,62':6/# 

3,/,,/,,6 ,/,6, ', ,#      /  ,  66 ,  ,:  '   26  $+#$%#!$$% @ +$#$%#!$$-+!---%-#,:6:,'6, :A6:'6/,,,A,#/,A,,,=, :  , /,  /,,6  '   3# /,  :3   ,A2:,/, /,6:',:2 ,:, A:/', ' //+*---%-5 6#,##!9/ A:/',6+!---%-/A6/,,,A, 6/5 6#,##*)%9# 

, ,   ,/,  6,  >*4! #+ 2#+ * : %  ,3   /,  '  A:  :  '66  :  /,,  6  6 ',,E2,B,6:'6 A,6,,6',: A6,, ,'66/6/,6, 6/B,, A6,2':6/: ,,6,'6,3, ,# 

3,//,A=/,,66 '66:A6# :A3 ,/,3:3/, A:' :,'66/, 6# 23 :',6, '6,  23  /  =,  :  ,    6 /  26  ,  : ,,/, ' ,,6#:,,62, '66'6#A :,:,,6,,2 /,A/, ' 3#/,/A,:, ,/ ,A/==,6,,=6,26     ,2:  ,, /,    ,/  '/,6  6  2= 2  5  6# ,##!+"9/,',,,;2=,,#,: A,6/ ,=66#  A   , :  /,:6,  A,3 ,  /    :  /AA6 /,26/2,5 6#,##!"%(!"?9:2,A3 665 6# ,##!44(*$)9#2,,:6,6$-#$4#!$$?: ,A,,

 ? 66  ++#$4#!$$?  5  6# ,##*$-(*$"9# :  /,:6,    A, ,    /, ,,,2,,A,,6,:# 6,3 ,:  ,  #7  ,  ,A   /:  #7  5  6# ,##*(%9# ,  !-#$%#!$$) ,,,:/,6/8888877(7,(&A 5,##%*(%)9# ,,:6,A,3,$-#$4#!$$?5 6#,##*$?9:$?#+$#!$$?5 6#,##*+)9 2,,/,2,,:6,6688888888887(7/  6,,,:,#+%#++#!$$?5 6#,##*"$9 /,62,,=,:65 6#,##*!$96: /,:6,,:6: ,A,,65 6#,##*!$ 9#

/2,,/,:6,6# :/,:6, ,:2,,A,,2 /,,,,+!#$%#!$$-5 6#,##*)*9# 

, ,   ,/,  6,  >*$* #* ' 6  /,6  2A, 26 /  /,  ,6  ,,  26   /  ,A2,/ =/#=/6 '3,6 ,,6,3626# 

  3 ,  =,6      6  ,,6  ,:  '6   26 /A,,/:,A2, ,=/,,/#   ,6 =,6,3 ,/,6: A: ,6' ::6::A,6,6, ,  2':6/,#   ,      /,,6  26  '/ ' 66,3/,,,=,6:,/,/, A3 ,/#  2,3  3  6/  , ##  /,  ,  ,=,/ #  ,6=/,,,:,/#    ,6  23    :  :,6  /,  ,A2 :A/,6A,,,6',/6/:A6# 

, ,   ,/,  6,  >!4" #+  5  $+#$+#!$$?  ,6  ,/,6,>+*+#+9/,'26, 6:,=/,6#  A , :/,:6,A,,/,$%#+$#!$$),'2 /AA62,,,/:66/,, '/ /  =/,  :  ,/  5  6# ,##!!!9# ,  !)#$-#!$$?  /AA ,  5  6# ,##!"?9    ,:  ,6  ,,  /,26/  2, ,,/666,2':6,6:6/3: ,,# $%#+$#!$$)  ,  2,,    A,  =6 ,  /3  2,,   ,,,,6:666# 

, , ,/,6,>!4"#*2 6/,6,/ ,/',::/ , A,62,,/,2, ,/,26, 6,,62,26, 6=/6#  A , ://,,,',,6#

 - 

 :6 , ,/ ,6, :  ,/, 6, >?)+>?)!>?)%>?)-#+2#*>??":>?-$#